The Scottsdale Unified School District violated laws governing open meetings – again.
In the public comments section at a Sept 22 public hearing at Desert Mountain High School, Mike Bengert tried to share that a complaint he filed was upheld.
He claimed the “Phase II” committee on potential closures repeatedly violated open meetings laws.
A lawyer representing the district cut Bengert off – telling him he had to stick to the agenda topic of “potential school closures and boundary changes.”
Though SUSD Superintendent Scott Menzel did not acknowledge it at the meeting, earlier that day, Deputy Maricopa County Attorney Caityn Mitchell stated Bengert’s complaint was valid.
“MCAO concluded that an Open Meeting Law violation has occurred,” Mitchell wrote.
Though no punishment was imposed, the Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board
In December 2023, the state attorney general’s office ruled SUSD violated open meeting laws several times during the 2020-21 school year.
The district escaped punishment then – and now.
“As far as available remedies, the work of the Phase II Team concluded in July of this year,” Mitchell wrote.
“Therefore, it is too late to require SUSD to take corrective action concerning future Phase II Team meetings.”
Menzel also did not publicly acknowledge a Sept. 16 letter Mitchell sent to SUSD.
“In the county’s letter they suggested the board tell the public about the violation and that the district didn’t intentionally exclude them from the process,” Bengert told the Progress.
“They didn’t say anything because they intentionally excluded the public.”
In the Sept. 16 letter, Mitchell wrote to SUSD:
“We are aware of the economic and demographic challenges school districts face each year, and we commend Scottsdale Unified School District’s commitment to inclusivity.
“Respectfully, however, this office strongly advises SUSD to reconsider its current use of superintendent-appointed advisory committees.”
She acknowledged SUSD Superintendent Scott Menzel’s creation of the Phase II Design Advisory Team “does not – as a purely technical matter – fall under the statutory definition of an ‘advisory committee or subcommittee’…”
But, she stressed, “the purpose and subsequent operation of the Phase II Team does.”
Mitchell scolded the district for not following the process.
“Although it was created by the superintendent, and the Governing Board did not appoint the committee members, the Phase II Team is still the brainchild of the Governing Board, dating back to 2025, and will be making recommendations for the Governing Board to vote on, rather than recommendations for the superintendent to implement,” Mitchell wrote.
“We understand that the work of the Phase II Team has concluded, and that its final recommendations will be presented to the public at the end of the month and voted on by the
Governing Board in October. It is therefore too late to take corrective action. It is our recommendation that, going forward, SUSD avoid an overly narrow reading of the law when
determining whether an advisory board is subject to Open Meeting Law.”
While advisory boards created by the superintendent, “for the benefit of the superintendent,” are not subject to open meeting laws, the county attorney stated, “advisory boards that are created to provide recommendations to the public body, regardless of how they are created, should conduct their meetings in accordance with Open Meeting Law because the law favors transparency whenever in doubt.”
Mitchell referenced earlier violations:
“SUSD has already been warned by the Arizona Attorney General’s Office that the ‘Open Meeting Law does not permit a governing board to evade the public meeting requirements by
“Informally” forming or establishing, or by directing a superintendent to establish, a committee to perform work that would otherwise need to be conducted in public.’
“The takeaway,” the county attorney concluded, “from the Attorney General’s Opinion … should not be to focus on how an advisory board is created, but rather the type of work the advisory board is performing, and for whom the work is being done.”
Bengert is the father of SUSD grads and grandparent of current district students.
His complaint, filed April 14, faults the district for not holding open committee meetings.
“By preventing the public from attending the Phase II Design Advisory Team meeting, SUSD is once again in violation of A.R.S. §38-431.
“This action deprives the public of its lawful right to attend and listen as decisions affecting SUSD are being made.”
Six months after he filed it, Mitchell generally agreed with Bengert’s assertion:
“This district, despite the prior Attorney General’s finding of violations of the OML, continues to actively find ways to circumvent rather than comply with the law.”
Menzel did not respond to a request to comment on the open meeting law violation.