Nearly 80 years after the brutal murder of Elizabeth Short, the 22-year-old whose death became one of Los Angeles’ most infamous unsolved cases, a team reinvestigating the Black Dahlia mystery says it has stumbled across another mystery: Where is her autopsy report?
Kimberly Lupini, producer of the upcoming docuseries Deconstructing Dahlia, told Los Angeles that her team recently had an active Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department cold-case investigator inquire with the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner about obtaining Short’s autopsy. The response was startling.
“Elizabeth Short isn’t coming up basically in the archives,” Lupini said, describing an email the team received from the Medical Examiner’s office. “Their response is, ‘We cannot find the Elizabeth Short file.’”
That doesn’t necessarily mean the report no longer exists. LAPD has long maintained records connected to the still-unsolved case and has declined to publicly release the complete autopsy. But Lupini says the apparent absence of the document from the archives of the agency that conducted the autopsy creates a lot more questions.
Credit: Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department
And Lupini says there is evidence that the Medical Examiner had at least part of it much more recently than 1947.
Lupini pointed to Jackie DeRiver, daughter of psychiatrist Dr. Paul DeRiver, who worked on the original investigation. While researching for a book, DeRiver visited the Medical Examiner’s office in 2004 and was permitted to examine what remained of Short’s autopsy report. According to Lupini, DeRiver described seeing only two pages.
“She was told that the ME’s office had the full report at one point,” Lupini said. “But yet now there’s no Elizabeth Short coming up in the archive.”
Scroll to continue reading
Retired LAPD Commander Robert Taylor, who is working with the Deconstructing Dahlia investigative team and speaking on his own behalf, said the group initially wasn’t even asking LAPD to hand over a copy.
“We had several meetings with LAPD,” Taylor told Los Angeles. “We didn’t ask them for a copy of the report because we recognize it was still an ongoing investigation, a cold case.” Taylor said the team offered to examine it under police supervision.
“We just asked to view the autopsy report under supervision of LAPD,” he said.
Lupini also said the team was told at one point it would be allowed to view the report and several other pieces of evidence. She said the apparent breakthrough came after roughly four years of trying to get LAPD to cooperate. But nothing happened.
“Every request made to actually have that meeting and get any further cooperation has either been met with an excuse, a delay, a non-response,” Lupini said.
Taylor said the LAPD never gave the team a firm date. “It’s just been a shuffle,” he said. “‘We’ll have another meeting, we’ll discuss it again,’ that sort of thing.”
Short’s mutilated body was discovered in a vacant lot in Los Angeles on Jan. 15, 1947. She had been bisected at the waist, and Taylor said the original examination documented extensive injuries, including deep cuts extending from the corners of her mouth, known as a Glasgow smile, and blunt-force trauma to her head. Forensic science in 1947 was nothing like it is today.
LAPD criminalist Ray Pinker was able to test a blood sample and determine that it was type AB, Taylor said, but investigators did not have anything approaching modern DNA technology.
“The ability to really do an analysis of the blood in 1947 as compared to today is light years in difference,” Taylor said. That’s important because Lupini’s team says it has now uncovered potential physical evidence that investigators in 1947 never had.
During its nearly six-year reinvestigation, the team identified a location it believes may have been where Short was killed. Lupini said investigators removed newer drywall to reach the building’s original plaster walls and discovered what she described as extensive blood evidence.
Opening of Hidden RoomCredit: Talestorm Productions
“Thirty-two samples we obtained, but there was more there,” she said. “We also found it underneath the wall…and not just a spot, a very, very long board saturated in blood that was removed and sent off to the lab for testing, DNA testing.”
The team has not publicly revealed the location or the identity of the person they consider a suspect while the investigation remains ongoing.
The mystery over Short’s forensic evidence actually dates back to 1949. Lupini said her team found a memo from that year showing that Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office investigator Frank Jemison was trying to track down evidence from Short’s autopsy as the case was being examined by a grand jury.
According to Lupini, Jemison sought Short’s organs and was told they had probably been disposed of and that toxicology had not been performed. That struck the team as odd.
Taylor explained that retaining entire organs would not have been practical, but samples could have been preserved in jars or on slides.
“You wouldn’t have a storage problem,” Taylor said.
This leaves Lupini wondering exactly what officials meant when they said the organs were gone, and whether any samples once existed that could potentially have been tested using technology unavailable in 1947.
“All we have today is the record that exists,” Lupini said. “Why wouldn’t those samples have been kept on a case such as this?” The answer could matter enormously to the Deconstructing Dahlia team, which says they now have support from Short’s family and have obtained a family DNA sample.
Lupini says the autopsy itself could answer questions DNA cannot; particularly about exactly how Short died and whether those findings fit the team’s theory of the crime.
“We have mountains of evidence,” Lupini said. “We don’t want to say this is a motive without that final piece to confirm the motive, and only the details are in that autopsy report.”
The team continues to push publicly for the records.
Its “Justice for Elizabeth” petition, supported by members of the Short family, has surpassed 10,000 signatures and calls for LAPD to release Short’s complete autopsy report and other evidence from the case.
For Lupini, the argument has become about more than solving a legendary Hollywood mystery.
“After 80 years, [the Short family] deserves this autopsy report,” she said. “They deserve to have a private investigation done that they feel can apply new emerging technologies and perspectives to Elizabeth’s case.”
“At the bare minimum,” she said, “the Short family should be entitled to that record by now.”