Phoenix officials thought the surge in police records requests was a one-time event brought on by the pandemic. It turned out they were wrong.
(City of Phoenix)
Phoenix hopes to eliminate a nearly 40,000-request police records backlog within about a year after the City Council last week approved higher fees and dozens of additional workers.
But the 8-1 vote came only after council members debated whether a department with a roughly $1.3 billion budget should be given the additional revenue.
The council voted 8-1 Sept. 23 for a new fee schedule and 10 additional permanent civilian positions in the Police Department’s Public Records and Services Bureau.
Six other permanent employees will be transferred from elsewhere in the department and 19 temporary employees will be hired specifically to attack the backlog, bringing the additional workforce devoted to the effort to 35.
Police officials told council they expect all 35 to be hired by January, trained within about a month and the existing backlog eliminated within one year after that training is completed.
The plan also calls for substantially higher charges for some commercial records users while making most electronically delivered records free for non-commercial requesters.
The new fees take effect Nov. 1. Under the schedule, electronic documents will be free for non-commercial users, while commercial document requests will carry a $10 fee plus 25 cents per page.
A primary video with a medium blur will be free, while additional video requiring standard redaction will cost $23 for every 30 minutes reviewed.
Crime victims or their representatives remain entitled to a free copy of police records.
The cost for the 10 additional ongoing, full-time employees is $389,524 for the remainder of the current fiscal year and $779,869 annually.
“Expected revenue from the increased fees will be used to fully fund these positions and is forecasted to be $394,768 in the first partial year and $789,535 annually,” a city report states.
“The cost for the 19 temporary full-tome employees is $958,401 for the first partial year and $1,446,075 for the second year. The temporary (employees) will be funded through one-time savings in the police budget.
The council discussion also provided the clearest explanation yet of how Phoenix accumulated a records backlog that at one point exceeded 73,000 requests — and why it has begun growing again after the city had cut it by more than half.
Police officials said the first surge began during 2019 and 2020, when the department was moving from manual records processing to an online system.
Then COVID hit.
The pandemic closed the department’s public service counter and forced staff to be separated, reducing the number working in the office.
At roughly the same time, demonstrations during the summer of 2020 generated large and complicated records requests, some involving hundreds of hours of video.
Those circumstances “slowed our rate of fulfillment,” Assistant Police Director Court Hood told Council, while some demonstration-related requests “required years of time and labor to collectively resolve.”
The backlog peaked at 73,069 requests in 2022, according to the department’s presentation.
Phoenix subsequently attacked it through staffing changes, new software, revised work processes and higher starting pay for records clerks. The backlog fell to 56,590 in 2023 and 27,539 in 2024.
But the decline didn’t last.
Police received 104,012 records requests in 2024. That jumped to 134,447 last year and is projected to reach approximately 139,000 this year.
Hood said officials initially thought the 2025 surge might have been a fluke.
It wasn’t.
If the current pace holds, he told council, 2026 “will be the highest for records requests received ever.”
Police say much of the new pressure is coming from businesses that obtain public records for commercial purposes.
Commercial users accounted for 24% of requests last year but 40% of the existing backlog.
The department said traffic-crash requests increased 56% between 2024 and 2025 and body-camera requests rose 17%.
Police officials offered the council one example of a commercial requester who sought hundreds of video clips totaling nearly 150 hours. The department estimated standard redaction would require about 600 hours of employee labor.
Officials said the requester posts police videos to a monetized YouTube account.
“These commercial requesters are using the public records request process as part of their business model,” Hood said, adding that the workload affects the department’s ability to serve “victims, families, and other requesters who have true needs.”
The department has responded by putting non-commercial requests ahead of commercial ones.
But the delays remain extraordinary for some records.
Nearly 13,000 video requests were awaiting fulfillment as of Sept. 1, with average waits ranging from 1.7 years to about 2½ years. Incident-report waits ranged from 11 days to six weeks, while traffic-crash reports averaged about 19 days.
Vice Mayor Kesha Hodge Washington called the video delay “the most troubling” part of the presentation.
“To think that someone has to wait almost two and a half years to get a copy” of body-camera video concerned her, she said.
Hood said the department’s goal isn’t merely to reduce those waits to less than a year.
Once the backlog is eliminated, he said, police want ordinary video requests turned around “in a matter of days.”
The higher fees for records requests are aimed mainly at commercial users, who often monetize video requests for exploitation on YouTube.
(City of Phoenix)
Hernandez questions fees
Councilwoman Anna Hernandez, who cast the only vote against the plan, said she supports eliminating the backlog but questioned why higher fees were necessary to pay for additional permanent employees.
She noted the Police Department’s overall budget is about $1.3 billion and the revised fees are expected to produce less than $800,000.
“Within that $1.3 billion, were we not able — are we not able — to identify $800,000 that would cover these positions?” Hernandez asked.
She also pointed to police overtime that she said has exceeded its budget by $20 million to $25 million in recent years and questioned whether existing money could instead be redirected toward records employees.
City staff responded that Phoenix is already doing some of what Hernandez proposed.
The 10 new permanent positions will be supported by the fee revenue, but six existing positions are being transferred from elsewhere in the Police Department and the 19 temporary workers will be paid from one-time savings in the existing police budget.
A frequent critic of the police budget, Hernandez remained unconvinced.
She characterized the proposal as another increase in police spending and said the city could cover the expense without raising fees if it controlled overtime.
City Manager Ed Zuercher challenged that argument on two fronts.
First, he said, the fee change is intended primarily to shift costs toward commercial users profiting from police records rather than ordinary residents.
“This is really trying to shift the burden from the non-commercial public, who’s standing in line today behind people who are trying to use videos to monetize on YouTube,” Zuercher said.
Second, Zuercher said police overtime can’t simply be treated as an available pot of money because the department remains short of officers.
Once Phoenix reaches its authorized strength of 3,125 officers, he said, overtime should move closer to budget.
While Phoenix City Council has consistently funded 3,125 police positions – mostly for patrol – it has consistently been unable to fill about 600 of them.
Zuercher also disputed the premise that departments routinely have large amounts of unused money available for reassignment.
“We shouldn’t have $800,000 underused in the Police Department or any other budget,” he said, because city budget officials continually work with departments to match available resources to authorized work.
Councilman Kevin Robinson, a 34-year veteran of the Polcie Department who was assistant chief for eight years before he retired, later reinforced the overtime point.
He noted that when the department is short roughly 600 officers, “you’re going to have overtime.”
Hernandez also questioned whether people involved in police shootings could inadvertently be charged for records because police reports may identify the person shot as a suspect rather than a victim.
She referred specifically to her brother’s case, saying he remained classified as a suspect even in the final police report.
Police officials said victims and qualifying family members will continue receiving records without charge and said staff communicate with requesters when their status isn’t clear.
Hood also said the department would consider modifying its new online portal so requesters can identify themselves as victims and establish their eligibility for free records.