In addition to deciding on local representatives, Scottsdale voters will weigh in on a number of statewide propositions.
One of them has public school district administrators scrambling – if not shivering in fear.
The Oct. 6 Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board meeting will go down in local history for the 3-2 vote to close Laguna Prep and Copper Ridge, which will be the third and fourth schools to close in barely more than a year.
While the crowd that came to the Coronado High auditorium were eager/anxious about that agenda item, SUSD Superintendent Scott Menzel first took a dive into a subject that could cause more long-term pain.
“Proposition 320,” he began, “is a legislative referral to the ballot for the Nov. 3, 2026 election.”
If the proposition passes, districts like SUSD will be required to “spend 60% of operational spending on direct instruction measure.”
Putting three-fifths of spending to “direct instruction” may sound like a modest proposal.
But this would have a massive impact here and elsewhere.
As Menzel outlined at the Oct. 6 meeting, this could be a nearly $15 million shift for SUSD.
Over the 2024-25 school year, Menzel said, SUSD had “54% of our expenditures in direct instruction,” and 70.6% of its spending in overall “classroom spending.”
“If this were to pass using those numbers,” Menzel said, “the district – and particularly the governing board – would have to move $14.9 million in expenditures from every other line item outside of direct instruction in order to meet that requirement.”
Teachers, teachers’ aides and substitute teachers are considered “instruction.”
Included in “non-direct instruction expenses”:
“It’s a significant impact on the district,” Menzel said.
Noncompliant districts are required to make adjustments each year – or face penalties.
But, the proposition does not require schools to reach the goal in one year.
“It’s not expected you go from 54% to 60% in a year,” Menzel noted.
Penalties can be imposed if a district does not make progress of at least 0.5% toward the 60% goal.
Waivers can also be granted, Menzel noted.
Board member Matt Pittinsky turned to fellow board member Carine Werner, who also is a state representative.
He demanded to know “what the state legislature’s motivations were” in putting the proposition on the ballot.
“One hundred percent support local control,” Werner coolly answered.
Turning to the crowd, she added: “This was moved forward to be put on the ballot so you all can decide if this is something you want to do . . .”
Pittinsky perhaps disingenuously asked her, “So if the majority of Scottsdale residents vote against this it doesn’t pass?”
He was told to direct his question to Menzel. Pittinsky asked the same question he asked Werner, adding on how Scottsdale residents “value
“This is a statewide ballot referral that was put on the ballot by the legislature,” Menzel said.
“If our voters didn’t support it but others around the state did, because it’s a majority, it would apply to us.”
Board member Mike Sharkey asked Menzel: “So, we both have to cut $14.9 million from one side and add it to the other?”
“Yes,” Menzel said. “It’s a shift in funding.”
There is some flexibility in what can be added, he said. “You can hire more teachers’ aides, you can bring in more substitute teachers … There’s nothing in the proposition that says it will result in increasing teacher pay,” Menzel added.
After complaining of “politicking” on Pittinsky’s part, Carney asked Menzel to clarify the percentage increase.
“We’re at 54% now,” Menzel said. “So, if it passed, you have to go to 54.5%, then 55(%) – that’s the minimum threshold as defined as ‘progress.’
“Also, it said if you made more progress in one year, it could be counted to a subsequent year.”
For the 2024-25 school year, SUSD’s budget lists “operational” spending at $250 million, or $12,876 per student.
As previously mentioned, “instruction” is 54% of that, or $135 million ($6,959 per student).
According to the 2024-25 budget, SUSD spent $33.5 million (13.4% of operations) on plant operations, $28.1 million (11.3%) on student support, $22.3 million (8.9%) on administration, $9.6 million (3.8%) on transportation and $8.2 million (3.3%) on food service.
As the one-year, 0.5% gain cost was not included in the presentation, the Progress asked Menzel to break this down – and outline what cuts would be needed.
“Based on the audited numbers from fiscal year 2025, 0.5% is around $1,241,667,” Menzel said.
“We do not have recommendations for the cost shift that would be required.”
If the proposition passes, “This would be a topic of conversation as we prepare the budget for 2027-28,” Menzel said.
And, he stressed, “the decision to close two more schools was designed to address the structural budget deficit, but those savings did not include the potential for needing to shift $1.2 million in expenditures from other line items into direct instruction.”
The SUSD superintendent pushed back on one word in the question.
“It is misleading to frame it as a ‘cut’ since it is a shift in where the money is spent, not reducing $1.2 million from the bottom line,” Menzel noted.
“So the question is what other parts of the budget would be reduced – remembering that 80+% of our budget is tied up in people – in order to increase the direct instruction line item.”
Yes and No
The Maricopa County election packet includes arguments in favor of – and against – Prop 320.
The proposition, Victor Riches of the Goldwater Institute argues, “ensures that funding for our schools goes to the classroom, not to bureaucratic bloat.
“Over the last 20 years, the percentage of funds used for classroom instruction has dropped to just 52%. This means that barely 50 cents of every dollar now makes it to its most important destination: classroom instruction.”
Riches pointed to wasteful spending, such as “a school district spend(ing) $500,000 sending staff to Caesar’s Palace for a Las Vegas conference and another district spending $18,500 of public monies on membership dues and golf tournament tickets.”
And, Riches stressed, “Recent investigations found districts paying their superintendents up to nearly half a million dollars a year through outrageous compensation packages, featuring perks like $1,000 a month car allowances – while teacher salaries have
barely kept up with inflation.”
With milder language, Kimberly Miller of Arizona Women of Action seconded that, stating via Prop 320, “Teachers will gain competitive pay, essential supplies, and the ability to focus on inspiring students.
“…Our communities will thrive with efficient, accountable spending,” she continued.
Robb Vaules, CEO of Scottsdale’s Yellowcross Healthcare, countered that in urging a No vote on Prop 320.
“While the proposal sounds like it prioritizes classroom spending,” Values wrote, “it fails to recognize that many of the services my child relies on every day exist outside the narrow definition of ‘direct classroom instruction.’
“Students with disabilities need more than a teacher in a classroom … By forcing districts to spend at least 60% of their budgets in a narrow set of spending categories, Prop 320 takes away local flexibility and could result in cuts to programs, support personnel, school safety measures, and facility maintenance.”
Pinny Sheoran of Scottsdale’s League of Women Voters also urges voters to reject the measure.
“While classroom instruction is essential,” Sheoran allowed, “quality education depends on much more than a single spending category.
“Arizona schools must also provide transportation, school safety, special education services, counseling, technology, family
support services, building maintenance, and other programs that help students succeed,” she added.
“The needs of a large urban district differ from those of a rural district, and a one-size-fits-all mandate does not recognize those differences.”