6th Annual Academy Museum Gala

Photo: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

This post contains spoilers for You Can See Everything. 

At the Academy Museum Gala on Saturday night, everyone wanted to talk to Amanda Seyfried but no one, especially Seyfried herself, knew what to say. If you did not see Nathan Fielder’s Elizabeth Holmes documentary You Can See Everything this weekend, you might not know what I’m talking about, and I would suggest you leave now lest you be spoiled.

In the latter half of You Can See Everything, once Holmes has begun to serve her prison sentence and is no longer available to be filmed, Fielder turns to Seyfried to serve as a sounding board and to reenact conversations he’s had with Holmes. Seyfried delivers an astounding performance as Holmes but is perhaps even more compelling when she’s just being Amanda Seyfried, trying to square the empathy she has for Holmes with her defensiveness about portraying her on TV. (To say nothing of her confrontation with Holmes’s husband Billy Evans.) It’s a lot to digest as a viewer, so imagine being Seyfried, not only having lived it but now having to talk around it while wearing an evening gown. She tried her best.

When The Hollywood Reporter asked Seyfried how her life was, she responded that it’s “interesting” and that yes, interviews are tricky right now, but “for a good reason.” She then rambled about how “everything that’s happening is meant to happen” and how “everyone that’s in your life is meant to be in your life.” Seyfried also said that if you want to talk to her over the coming days, you could bring up topics like “the emus,” “Halloween,” and “all things having to do with, like, apple pie and, like, olives, and, you know, really good hard ciders.”

Seyfried told Deadline that the past 48 hours have been “really exciting” and that she’s “heard from a lot of people.” That’s a good start! How does it feel to finally have You Can See Everything out in the world? “It’s just, it is a good— It’s exciting, I guess,” Seyfried said. Does she know that she is the most compelling part of this movie? That she’s getting unprecedented Oscar buzz for her performance in documentary reenactments? Stand up, diva!

My personal favorite of Seyfried’s bizarro interviews was her chat with Variety in which she and Marc Malkin both pretended like they weren’t talking about You Can See Everything. He asked if there would ever be a second season of The Dropout, she smiled knowingly and said “I don’t think so, but life is long.” Malkin asked if she’s a fan of Fielder and Seyfried said that she is, but that she hasn’t “seen everything.” Does she want to meet Holmes? “I don’t— life is long,” she said, again.

Life is long, and I hope that means that we’ll eventually get to a point where Seyfried can talk freely about You Can See Everything. By next week I think we can wrap it up on this charade and start asking Seyfried real questions about the movie. The people want to know how she felt during that dinner with Evans.

Stay in touch.

The latest in style, self, culture, and power in your inbox.

Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice

Related