The candidate with the scorpion tattoo was ready to sting.
Former state senator Michelle Ugenti-Rita missed a previous Scottsdale City Council candidates forum, during which Councilman Barry Graham, running for reelection, and challenger Raoul Zubia traded light-hearted exchanges.
Not so, at an Oct. 12 forum, held at Scottsdale City Hall.
The three candidates were all smiles before the forum. Once it started Ugenti-Rita – backed by Graham, her unofficial running mate – lashed into Zubia.
“He wants to bring thousands of apartments to Scottsdale,” Ugenti-Rita and Graham repeatedly shot at Zubia.
Zubia, who has received endorsements from Democratic groups and Axon president Josh Isner laughed off the apartment-attacks as “totally false.”
“Development has to be done strategically, responsibly and with making sure that it fits the character of both the general plan and the neighborhood. So to say that all I want to do is build apartments – that is not true.”
After Graham stated, “Mr. Zubia has repeatedly lobbied the city council to rezone retail into high density apartments,” Zubia insisted, “I have not lobbied many times for high density apartments. I don’t know where you’re getting that from.”
Zubia allowed he supported “one project four or six years ago and that was it. But I have not said … that we should build tens of thousands of apartments.
“So, you keep saying that, but it’s not true.”
With a grinning Ugenti-Rita nodding in assent, Graham insisted the record backs up his claims about Zubia, a retired banker who failed in a 2022 bid for City Council.
This was a two-against-one battle, with the pair ganging up on Zubia.
While Graham was soft-spoken and generally issue-oriented, the viper-tongued launched a furious attack at Zubia.
“Where have you been?,” she demanded, telling the sparse crowd Zubia lacks leadership skills. “He’s ill-equipped, he has no budget experience.”
“I think that my community service does show that I know what I’m doing when it comes to big decisions,” Zubia countered. “How to work with budgets – 20 years of banking shows that I know how to do that.”
Ugenti-Rita interrupted him, sneering “you’re a campaigner at best. I’m the real deal.”
Later, she insisted Zubia “flip flops” on issues like Axon and Flock cameras and wants to ruin the city.
“People don’t move here,” Ugenti-Rita said, “to have it look like Tempe – where Mr. Zubia almost lives.”
Zubia countered that he is proud to be a lifelong South Scottsdale resident.
Indeed, as an Oct. 11 Progress story noted, all three went to Scottsdale elementary schools – with Ugenti-Rita’s scorpion tattoo a nod to Anasazi Elementary’s mascot.
Scorpions famously go long periods without water; on that front, Ugenti-Rita repeated her favorite “toilets-to-taps” disdain.
Zubia, meanwhile, repeated his support for Scottsdale’s award-winning Advanced Water Treatment program, which he complained Graham and his colleagues defunded.
Graham countered that the characterization was incorrect, and the City Council is waiting for more information on the costs of the program.
In contrast to Ugenti-Rita’s savage takedown of the program, Graham stated that – as part of a diversified Scottsdale water portfolio – “we’re also leaning into recycling” water.
As for Zubia, “Number one on my agenda is water,” he stated. “You’ve heard earlier that we don’t have a water problem. That is true. We don’t have a water problem but we are running out of cheap water and we need to find a way to keep the water we have and that is through recycling and other projects.”
Countering Ugenti-Rita’s insistence he wants people to drink toilet water, Zubia said Scottsdale’s recycled water “is cleaner than the bottled water we are drinking right now.”
Ugenti-Rita also accused Zubia of “election interference” – for encouraging people to vote just for him, despite two seats being open.
“It’s not voter suppression,” Zubia calmly responded. “It’s not even like that. I’m asking to vote for me because I am the best choice … it’s the only way that we can be assured that we are going to balance out this council and we are going to get back to the residents – listening to the residents.”
Ugenti-Rita criticized Zubia for being “two faced” for demanding civility – after calling council members “clowns.”
And she called out Zubia for suggesting she did not testify about Axon at the state legislature. Last year, faced with a potential referendum, Axon successfully won legislative blessing for its office-apartments-hotel plan in North Scottsdale.
“This has been an ongoing fight for two years down at the legislature,” Ugenti-Rita said to Zubia. “You did nothing.”
After she demanded to know why he didn’t testify against Axon’s successful strategy to win state blessing of its office-apartments-hotel plan, Zubia interjected, “I don’t think you were down there either.”
Ugenti-Rita did, in fact, speak out against Axon’s plan at the state legislature.
“Another example, folks, that he doesn’t know what he’s talking about,” Ugenti-Rita said to the crowd.
“I testified with the CEO (of Axon) right behind my shoulder defending Scottsdale.”
Key election dates
Oct. 7: Ballots mailed; early voting begins.
Oct. 23: Last day to request a replacement ballot by mail.
Oct. 27: Last day to mail back your ballot.
Nov. 3: Election Day.
In Scottsdale, early ballots can be dropped off at Scottsdale City Hall, 3939 N. Drinkwater Boulevard, from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday, starting Oct. 7.