NEAR WEST SIDE — It was a textbook fall night in Chicago on Oct. 8, 1924. Fair overhead and 58 degrees, it was nice enough to stand outside and chat with friends under a street light, even at 11 p.m.
That’s exactly what William Bell was doing when he was killed at the corner of 14th and Miller streets near the Maxwell Street area.
Bell likely never saw the bat witnesses said Otto Epstein had in his right hand before it crashed against his head. He died on the sidewalk or on the way to the hospital.
Two white women, who complained of being accosted by a Black man, later said they weren’t sure Bell was the one, and admitted two white men in a Ford had harassed them. Still, Bell was dead — Chicago’s first and only documented victim of racial lynching.
The violent killing was significantly less publicized than other killings in Chicago that year. The thrill killing of 14-year-old Bobby Franks by white University of Chicago students Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb, the sons of millionaires — dubbed the “crime of the century” — and the trial of Beulah May Annan, the inspiration for the character of Roxie Hart in the musical “Chicago,” both happened in spring 1924.
Movies, books and plays have used Leopold and Loeb as inspiration for murder stories with complex character arcs.
Bell has been largely forgotten.
“The fact that you talk to people here in Chicago who have never heard of this is zero surprise,” said Peter Cole, a Western Illinois University history professor and founder and co-director of the Chicago Race Riot of 1919 Commemoration Project. “As important as this event was, perhaps, and tragic, the truth is, the average Chicagoan … doesn’t know what happened 102 years ago, in general.”
Bell’s killing is “both unique, one of a kind, but also sort of ordinary, because there’s just such a long history of racism and racial violence in Chicago and the United States,” he said.
“So, in a way, this seems familiar, even though the average person may not know the details.”
So who was Bell, and how did he die?
Who Was William Bell?
Most reports place Bell’s birth in Oglethorpe, Georgia in 1891. He was born into a large family. His parents, Mack and Malinda, married in 1881. A decade later, William, or “Willie” as he was referred to in some census records, came along.
In 1900, when the census was taken, William, who was 8 or 9, wasn’t listed alongside his father and seven siblings. His future wife, Melvie Jones, was listed on the same sheet.
William Bell, pictured in the Chicago Defender, came to Chicago from Georgia around 1921 and worked in a starch factory. Credit: Provided
By 1910, 19-year-old Willie Bell was living in McDuffie County, Georgia, and was listed as a servant in a home with two adult Black women and their 17-year-old niece, according to census records.
In 1917, he registered for the World War I draft. One likely registration card noted he was married and living with his wife, child and mother. On it, his birthday is listed as Sept. 10, 1891, and his occupation was as a farmhand for the Newnan Cotton Mill. He marked the document with an “X” as his signature.
In 1920, he might have made it to the Midwest, living in a boarding house in Hamilton City, Ohio, and working as a laborer doing street work, according to one census record. Another record shows he could have also been living in Georgia with his brother George, both as farm workers. Their father died the same year, according to his death certificate.
It’s estimated Bell arrived in Chicago sometime around 1921.
By 1924, he was working in Chicago, married to Melvie — who also went by Melvi, L.V., Melva, Elva and Melin — and living at 1057 W. Frank St. along with his brother Ernest. His death certificate indicated he was “about 33” when he was killed.
Newspaper accounts at the time said Bell had a “splendid” reputation in his neighborhood.
The Night of Oct. 8, 1924
In the Oct. 9, 1924 edition of the Chicago Tribune, a short article ran with the headline, “Mob Lynches Colored Man, Girl Accuses.”
It described a terrifying scene from the night before:
“Lynch law was applied to Chicago last night when a mob of 200 infuriated residents of the Maxwell Street police district beat, kicked and trampled to death a colored man accused of attempting to mistreat a white girl.”
The onslaught began when Bertha Deutsch, 21, of 1357 Miller St., a stenographer at the board of assessors, and Betty Greenblatt, of 1071 Miller St., a typist for L. Lewald & Co. at 3066 S. Franklin St., accused Bell of approaching them on Miller Street, according to the Tribune.
The women had arrived in front of Deutsch’s home when a “colored” man approached them, they told the Tribune. They refused him, and he “seized Miss Greenblatt by the arm and started to drag her across the street,” the Tribune reported.
The pair screamed, and several men ran out of George Shapiro’s “sacramental wine shop” at 1014 W. 14th St. When Bell saw the men, he let go of Greenblatt’s arm and fled but was headed off by a group of men and soon surrounded, the Tribune reported.
“A dozen blows were aimed at him,” the article said. “And one man, wielding a baseball bat, struck him over the head. The blow appeared to stun him and he fell.”
A growing crowd “stormed around him,” raining down “blows and kicks” as some men trampled him, the Tribune reported. The scene caught the attention of “hundreds” of nearby residents, one of whom eventually called the police. The “entire force available” was sent to deal with the mob, the Tribune reported.
Lynchers were “driven away from their dying victim only after police … charged into the crowd” — seizing about 20 people, but letting all but two go. Only after nearly 24 people were rounded up did it become “quiet” on Miller Street again.
“Race has been feeling high for some time” in the neighborhood, the story noted.
Bell was placed in a police wagon, and death records say he died on the way to Cook County Hospital. Some witnesses, however, said they thought his life ended when his head hit the concrete. And a Daily Worker news story said the next day that the hit with the baseball bat “almost instantly killed him.”
A coroner’s report found Bell had bruising on his face, evidence of hemorrhaging in his right ear and a skull fracture 5 inches long.
Bell’s brother George and friends Thomas Clark and Walter Harper, also Black men from the neighborhood, identified Otto Epstein, of 1011 W. 14th St., as the man who struck the blows with the bat. Epstein — who lived across the street from Shapiro’s wine shop, where he worked as a watchman — denied the accusation and said he was the one who had notified police of the riot. He was among those arrested.
A newspaper clipping of Betty Greenblatt, who accused William Bell of grabbing her, and Otto Epstein, who was accused of beating Bell with a baseball bat. Credit: Provided
‘I Can’t Be Sure It Was Bell’
The next day, the Tribune reported that Greenblatt and Deutsch were “uncertain” Bell was their attacker and “could not positively identify” his body as that of the man who “insulted” them.
“The Negro who accosted us did look very much like Bell — that is, he was dressed similarly — but I can’t be sure it was Bell,” the Tribune reported Deutsch saying. Greenblatt was “equally uncertain.”
The Daily Worker reported that many in the mob “were declared by bystanders to be drunk,” adding that Bell was standing and talking to friends when the assault took place.
The wine shop where the mob came from was only a few feet from the scene; George Shapiro and his “assistants” denied “all knowledge of the affair” when interviewed by the paper.
Epstein was the night watchman at the wine shop, but the paper reported that a Shapiro assistant was actually in charge on the day of the murder. Shapiro “made several contradictory statements” to the paper, explaining that Epstein “probably saw the affair and ran for the police,” but also that most days, “Epstein generally locked himself in the wine shop,” only going out if “some excitement occurred.”
“This place is supposed to close up at ten o’clock every night, you know,” Shapiro told The Daily Worker.
News about the killing spread. The Chicago Defender also ran a story on Oct. 10 under the headline: “Georgia Lynch Law in Chicago.” The story named Bell as a “victim of mob rowdies from the sidewalk.”
“They could not wipe away the stain of the transportation of Georgia lynch law to the city of Chicago,” it said.
A map published in Frederic Thrasher’s “The Gang: A Study of 1,313 Gangs in Chicago,” shows the area where William Bell’s killing occurred and the 1920s gangs that ruled the area. Credit: Provided
What Witnesses Said
Bell’s killing was on the Near West Side in the Maxwell Street area, the Jewish “ghetto” where immigrants from around the world often landed in Chicago. To the south was an area then known as “The Valley,” an extremely poor section run by The Valley gang.
“The Negroes of the ‘Valley District,’ which is populated by both Jews and Negroes, have a different story to tell of Epstein’s activities,” The Daily Worker reported.
Bell’s friends Harper and Clark both told the paper that Epstein had run out of the shop with a baseball bat in hand and “crashed in the skull of the first Negro he saw, which happened to be Bell,” while Greenblatt and Deutsch ran to Deutsch’s house nearby.
“They killed Bell for nothing at all,” said a Black resident interviewed in a pool hall at 1041 Miller St. who witnessed the attack, according to the paper.
The resident said that Epstein was selling alcohol to a “gang of young fellows” who were standing in and around the wine shop, most of them appearing drunk.
Bell was standing on the corner of Miller and 14th streets talking to friends when Greenblatt and Deutsch screamed and ran into a house, the man told The Daily Worker. The witness didn’t see anyone put their hands on either woman, he said.
“At any rate, it was not Bell,” he said.
Epstein then ran out of the shop armed with the bat, drunken customers trailing behind. Bell’s two friends ran, while Bell was “immediately beaten to death by the crowd,” the witness told the paper.
Harry Crawford, the owner of a nearby pool hall at 1339 Miller St., said he was passing the corner of 14th and Miller while two white men in a stopped “Ford” car had tried to “pick … up” the women. Crawford said he heard one of the women tell the men that he’d “better go about your business or something will happen to you,” The Daily Worker reported.
Crawford claimed that the two women then went into Shapiro’s wine shop and told the group of men standing around that “a Negro had attempted to assault her.” Epstein was among those who came out of the shop and started attacking a group of Black men standing and talking on the corner, Crawford told the paper.
“As I fled, I saw Epstein hit Bell on the head with a bat and the others started to kick him as he crumpled to the sidewalk,” Crawford recalled.
“When asked about this version of the story by a reporter of the Negro press, Miss [Greenblatt] admitted she had been approached by two men in the Ford car, and the two girls sent them on their way,” The Daily Worker reported.
Greenblatt then said that after the men in the car left, she was approached by a Black man, but that she couldn’t identify him because it was dark outside, the paper reported. She said that she indeed did go into the wine shop, where she told the men “about a Negro approaching her” but seemingly nothing of the white men in the car who had made advances toward her and Deutsch.
Maxwell Street, near Miller Street, on Chicago’s Near West Side around 1944 — 20 years after the lynching of William Bell. Credit: Wikimedia Commons
The Coroner’s Inquest: ‘I Forgot To Mention That’
By Saturday, Oct. 11, Epstein and an alleged accomplice, Irving Rockowitz of 1045 Newberry Ave., were held by the coroner’s jury, waiting to go before Deputy Coroner Samuel Davis.
Crawford, the pool hall owner who’d witnessed the beating and said he was also struck, testified at the inquest, giving the same story he’d given to The Daily Worker.
Deutsch failed to disclose the story of the men in the Ford during her testimony until the Bell family lawyer, George C. Adams, cross-examined her, the paper noted.
“I forgot to mention that,” she said.
Deutsch said, under questioning from Adams, that her mother had opened the door for the women on the night of the mob, and they then ran upstairs. She said she “didn’t remember” if they told her mother what had happened, according to The Daily Worker.
Greenblatt testified she “couldn’t imagine that anyone had been killed over that,” the paper reported. She said she didn’t visit the wine shop until after the murder, and that Epstein, “Jack” and “Bo” came back from where Bell was lying while she was in the store. Epstein called police, she said.
Bell’s other brother, Ernest, testified that his brother, a worker in a starch factory, “never spent his time in pool-rooms” and had “never been in any trouble.” He also “never drank” and was “perfectly sober” when he left their home earlier in the evening. Ernest last saw his brother at 8:30 p.m. on the night he was killed, news accounts and death records show.
Bell’s friend Harper testified, as reported by the Daily Worker:
“Epstein came up to us as we were walking south on Miller Street, near 14th, followed by two men. Epstein had a baseball bat in his left hand. He asked us, ‘What are you looking for?’ and before we had time to answer he hit me on the nose, making it bleed. Epstein then transferred the bat to his right hand and hit Bell a death blow on the head. I turned and fled.”
Harper was “positive” Epstein was the killer, the Daily Worker reported.
Clark testified that he saw the women talking to white men, and that after he walked away the women ran into the wine shop, the paper reported. Then, “I saw a white man strike Bell with a bat,” Clark said.
After the beating, Clark said he walked back to Bell and found him dead, then went to find his brother.
The Chicago Defender also reported on Oct. 11 that the Pyramid Insurance Company on 35th Street was offering a $500 reward for the arrest and conviction of Bell’s killer or killers. The newspaper described Bell’s death at the hands of “white gangsters” who were “loafing around the saloon” of George Shapiro.
A newspaper clipping of Bertha Deutsch testifying before a coroner’s jury in the death of William Bell. Credit: Provided
The Defender noted that two versions of the crime were circulating: One, that Greenblatt was chatting with Deutsch when “a man wearing a light cap and a dark suit approached her, exhibited some money and made an insulting remark.” She screamed and the women ran into the Deutsch home, only to realize Bell had been killed while they were inside.
She was taken to the morgue to identify him, but couldn’t.
“I know more of the Colored men in the neighborhood because I’ve lived here so long,” Deutsch said, according to the Defender. “But this man — I didn’t make any reply to him because he might think I was encouraging him.”
The other version of the story described by the Defender was Harper and Clark’s, which consisted of Epstein hitting Bell with the bat, after which he “rushed to the … police station and reported to the desk sergeant that a man had been hit.”
Crawford’s version also included the men in the Ford making advances toward Greenblatt, followed by her going to the wine shop and reporting the attack to the men there, who then questioned Crawford and hit him before attacking Bell.
He said all non-white people from the crowd were told to go home by police, and that the police “invaded the pool room of Crawford … and intimidated” the patrons. Eventually, officers realized Bell was innocent.
“The mob picked the wrong man,” Crawford said police told him.
The Daily Worker reported that Epstein didn’t testify at the coroner’s inquest and refused to stand up and take his coat off so witnesses could identify him.
Rockowitz’s lawyer cross-examined Black witnesses on behalf of Epstein until Deputy Coroner Davis “refused to permit the attorney for Irving Rockowitz to heckle the Negro witnesses” any more, according to the article.
Police officer John J. Foley, who testified at the inquest, admitted to “indiscriminate searching” of the neighborhood’s Black-owned restaurants and pool rooms following notification of trouble on the street. Meanwhile, “Bell was [lying] dead on the street.” Only after Thomas Clark came into a business where 20 Black men were being searched and took police to Bell’s body did they discover him.
Others present at the inquest were wine shop patron Al Friedmann, who appeared “badly scratched and cut on the right cheek,” along with Rockowitz, who sported “a badly discolored left eye,” the paper reported.
Rockowitz, a cab driver with the Yellow Cab company, testified he was “actively mixed up in the fighting,” according to the story.
During the proceedings, Rockowitz and Epstein “laughed and jested with friends, especially with the Misses Greenblatt and Deutsch.”
“They even exchanged friendly badinage with the police officers in charge,” the paper reported.
While the coroner’s jury was deliberating, “the youths, between puffs of their cigarettes, joked with the Defender photographer about taking their pictures,” the paper reported. “Their demeanor changed, however, to one of grave seriousness when they heard the jury’s verdict.”
Chicago Justice
By Monday, Oct. 13, attorneys for Bell’s family were meeting with State’s Attorney Robert Crowe, the same man who prosecuted Leopold and Loeb just a month prior. Attorney George Adams demanded speedy indictments “at once,” as with the Leopold and Loeb case, The Daily Worker reported.
The “lives of Negroes in the city of Chicago must be protected,” Adams told the newspaper.
Nathan Leopold (top) and Richard Loeb. Credit: Wikimedia Commons
In his column for the Defender, Chandler Owen evoked the Leopold and Loeb case and that of Beulah May Annan, who was later acquitted on grounds of self-defense.
“Recently we have heard much of Chicago justice,” Owen wrote. “Particularly in connection with the [Bobby] Franks case, where two millionaire youths escaped the extreme penalty for having kidnapped and murdered another … millionaire boy.”
Prior to that time, “attention was directed to the ease with which women murderers here almost invariably escaped the extreme penalty,” Owen wrote.
In another article in the Daily Worker, Greenblatt’s mother pleaded for sympathy for her daughter, whose alarm and story of being accosted — without mentioning the white men in the car — led to the killing. Her daughter was “only eighteen” and had been supporting her family financially for the last five months, since her father lost his job, Greenblatt’s mother said.
Meanwhile, Bell’s death left his wife Melvie and a baby behind. Melvie was in Atlanta when the beating took place, according to reports.
On Thursday, Oct. 16, Assistant State’s Attorney George Gorman “promised” a thorough investigation into the slaying, as well as a “speedy” seating of a grand jury, attorney Adams told The Daily Worker. Later that evening, two “mass meetings” were to be held by Black residents — one on the South Side, one on the West Side — to protest “conditions now prevailing among the Negroes living in Chicago.”
In the meantime, Bell’s friend Thomas Clark was being “intimidated and threatened at his home,” the paper reported, including being harassed day and night by “auto loads of white thugs [that] have driven up and down in front” of his house, promising violence if Epstein was indicted. Attorneys for Bell’s family requested an “extra squad of police” to cover the district.
Black residents organized, forming the People’s Protective Circle, meant to “protect the lives of the Negroes against future outrages,” spearheaded by Robert S. Ephriam.
Chicago’s Black population was “especially incensed because of the long continued police intimidation,” particularly on the South Side, according to the article.
“It is considered a crime, according to Negroes, for a Negro to be seen walking with a white girl,” the story said. “On the other hand, many Negroes report that they have been slugged and beaten by white men without securing the slightest police protection.”
The nationally galvanizing murder of 14-year-old Chicago resident Emmett Till, killed for an allegation regarding a white woman in Mississippi, was still 31 years away.
Black residents reported that they were “in danger of lynching whenever they appear on the streets.”
Black business owners told the Daily Worker that Shapiro’s wine shop where the vigilantes hung out was a “notorious bootleg joint” that the Maxwell Street police, just one block away, “never raided … altho[ugh] they are well aware of the law-breaking activities going on.”
A 1908 postcard shows the “Ghetto of Chicago” on the Near West Side. Credit: Wikimedia Commons
The Valley, ‘The Ghetto’ and Bell
For decades, Maxwell Street Market was “the great Rialto of the poorer class of Jewish tradesmen” where $1 million worth of business a month was transacted (over $19.5 million in 2026), according to Frederic Thrasher’s “The Gang: A Study of 1,313 Gangs in Chicago,” published in 1927.
The market was located in Chicago’s “ghetto,” a “densely populated rectangle of crowded tenements representing the great part of Chicago’s immigrant colonies,” sociologist Louis Wirth noted in his 1928 book “The Ghetto.”
“It contains the most varied assortment of people to be found in any similar area of the world,” Wirth wrote.
Jewish residents lived among Germans, Irish, Bohemians, Polish, Lithuanians, Italians, Greeks, Turkish, “and finally, the Negro,” Wirth said.
The wave of Black residents who moved to the neighborhood was “of more than passing interest,” Wirth said. It added another dynamic to a shifting demographic rife with racial and ethnic social complexities.
“The Negro, like the immigrant, is segregated in the city into a racial colony; economic factors, race prejudice and cultural differences combine to set him apart,” Wirth said. “The Negro has drifted to the abandoned sections of the ghetto for precisely the same reasons that the Jews and the Italians came there.”
Chicago was going through “tremendous changes in that era,” Cole, the historian, said. “The lynching of William Bell very much both defines, but also sort of typifies, what I see happening in Chicago in the 19-teens and the ‘20s.”
In 1890, when Chicago had about a million residents, there were only a few thousand Black residents among them. It wasn’t until the first wave of the Great Migration during World War I that more started to move north, including Bell. And it wasn’t until after the next wave in the 1940s that Chicago’s Black population really began to swell, Cole said.
“So William Bell is not so different than the hundreds of thousands of other African-Americans who chose to leave the South because they rightly believe that they might have a somewhat better life in Chicago,” he said.
Even though the Maxwell Street neighborhood’s residents were largely immigrants — be it from Europe or the American South — it didn’t exactly mean racial or ethnic harmony.
That European immigrants “would embrace racism is sort of just them learning which side you want your bread to be buttered on,” Cole said. “If you’re an immigrant from Poland or Italy and you’re worried about your own situation and your family, you choose ‘to be white’ because to be white in America means you have citizenship, means you can vote, means you can get any job potentially, that you can live in any neighborhood potentially, that the police won’t harass you randomly.
“So it’s a sad story because … William Bell is probably not so different than the people who killed him.”
The southern portion of the ghetto was known as the “Valley” — a “cradle of powerful gang of robbers, bootleggers and beer-runners” who controlled a “string of breweries” in the city, according to Thrasher.
Maxwell Street Police district officers were reportedly among those whose careers benefited from bootlegging and its related corruption. The station itself was built in 1888 to help control a burgeoning population in the city, and by 1906 the Maxwell district was dubbed “Bloody Maxwell” after the crime in the neighborhood.
The nearby intersection of 14th Place and Sangamon was called “dead man’s corner,” according to historian Neil Gale’s Digital Research Library of Illinois History Journal.
“It was rumored that at least half of the uniformed patrol working out of ‘Bloody Maxwell’ in the early 1920’s received $15 every Friday from the Genna brothers by simply stopping by the warehouse for their weekly envelope,” according to Gale.
A statue commemorates the former Maxwell Street Market in University Village on Feb. 16, 2022. Credit: Colin Boyle/Block Club Chicago
An Omen And An Augury
On Friday, Oct. 17, Epstein and Rockowitz were held for a grand jury. The next day, the Defender reported that the coroner’s inquest had found, during a 30-minute deliberation, that Bell died from “a blow with a baseball bat held in the hands of Otto Epstein,” and that Rockowitz was an accessory, recommending them both to a grand jury.
Another William Bell, a Black baseball player in the Negro League’s World Series, was mentioned in a different article in the Defender. That William Bell was a pitcher for the Kansas City Monarchs. In 1924, he had a banner year, boasting an impressive 2.63 earned-run average and winning 10 of 12 games.
“It seems that while historic [B]lack baseball moments were occurring in the East and in the West, in the city that was arguably the capital of [B]lack professional ball, a mob was employing a baseball bat to beat to death one William Bell, Negro,” wrote author Lawrence D. Hogan in “The Forgotten History of African American Baseball.” “Lest the use of baseball bats for something other than hitting a baseball be thought an anomaly.”
In the Defender, Owen cited Chicago’s crime rate the previous year of one murder per day, concluding that “in such a criminal atmosphere it was only natural that, unless unchecked, America’s major crime — lynching — would lift its awful head.”
That Bell’s killing also occurred on the eve of “Chicago Day” — a celebration harkening back to the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition to mark the city’s rebuilding after the Great Fire of 1871 — was not lost on Owen.
“Chicago cannot be excused for this disgrace which has been brought upon the city,” Owen wrote.
The lynching on the eve of Chicago Day was “both an omen and an augury,” he wrote. In particular, Bell’s murder was a “warning to people of easy consciences who will tell you glibly when you are trying to fight lynching: ‘Oh, I’m in Chicago. They lynch people in Georgia and Mississippi, but they wouldn’t attempt that here.’
“As a matter of fact, we should remember that what takes place in Georgia today will be in Illinois tomorrow,” Owen said. “It is fair, even now, to say that this man was not lynched at State and 35th Streets. He was taken in a section of the city, largely white.”
Reading an account of Bell’s killing, Owen said he was “struck by the names of the white participants and the parties connected in one way or the other.” By lynching, they become “3rd degree Klan-masons.”
He called for police involved to be fired, for the mayor to condemn the killing more strongly and for the city’s race commission, started after the 1919 Chicago Race Riots, to function better.
“Finally, our people themselves should be bestirred,” Owen warned. “Chicago is entirely too complacent with corruption, vice and criminality. It is a city without a soul.”
‘Trying To Make The Public Forget’
On Monday, Nov. 3, 1924, attorney William H. Haynes filed a lawsuit against the city of Chicago for $5,000 (about $98,000 in 2026) on behalf of Bell’s wife, the Defender reported.
By December, another story in the Defender reported that still not enough public action had taken place in the wake of Bell’s killing, which had occurred during an election cycle.
“Law enforcers, it seems, are trying to make the public forget this outrage perpetrated on the city streets,” the paper wrote.
Because of that “lethargic attitude,” businessman W.H. Montgomery brought together a group of citizens who were “working quietly, sounding public opinion on this topic.” The result was a petition with over 10,000 signatures to be delivered to Mayor William Dever, calling for Epstein to be brought to trial at once. Pastors distributed the petition to their congregations.
“It is still fresh in our memory that in 1919 racial antipathy grew to a horrible climax of which we loathe a repetition,” the petition said. “Large groups of people can and should live together in peace and tranquility despite any differences in race, creed or color.”
A few days later came a twist: A taxi driver named Max Greenberg of 1312 (or 1324) S. Spaulding Ave. confessed he was Bell’s killer, according to the Tribune. Epstein was still awaiting trial, but would “probably be released,” police told the paper. He was later released on a $10,000 bond and was free until his court date.
Max Greenberg was also indicted. He had admitted to knocking Bell down with his fist, causing Bell to hit his head on the pavement and die. He also received a $10,000 bond, despite the state’s attorney’s office arguing against it.
The Trials
Epstein’s lawyer, W.W. O’Brien, “did not like” the attitude of the initial judge on the case, and requested a change of venue, which was granted. The case then went to Judge William V. Brothers in room 1123 of the county building.
On Feb. 21, 1925, the Defender reported that Epstein’s trial had finally started. Greenberg’s trial was to be held separately, starting on Feb. 25, 1925.
Epstein’s attorneys “tried to shake” witness Thomas Clark’s testimony that Epstein was the bat wielder. In his closing argument, Epstein’s lawyer W.W. O’Brien “sought to prejudice the jury by painting a lurid word picture of racial differences,” according to the Defender.
On Feb. 27, after a four-day trial, Epstein was acquitted, the Defender reported.
The verdict “generally predicted that since Epstein, identified as the slayer, was acquitted, that Greenberg would not be convicted.” Greenberg was represented by D.E. Stefano, the uncle of Assistant State’s Attorney Michael Romano, who’d called Bell’s killers a “pack of wolves.”
By March 9, Greenberg was freed and his charges dismissed, despite his confession. Romano, who was Greenberg’s lawyer’s nephew, claimed they couldn’t get anyone to identify Greenberg.
Epstein and Greenberg were let go within a few days of each other.
A worker placed four red flags after measuring out the approximate location of the unmarked grave for William Bell — who was lynched in Chicago on Oct. 8, 1924 — in Section 23 of Lincoln Cemetery just outside of Chicago in Blue Island, Ill., on Sept. 29, 2026. Credit: Colin Boyle/Block Club Chicago
The Aftermath, And Life After
On Oct. 13, 1924, Bell was buried in Lincoln Cemetery, a historic Black cemetery in Blue Island, south of the city. His grave has no headstone.
When Block Club visited the site, groundskeepers used maps, a shovel and measuring tapes to attempt to plot out his approximate grave site. After multiple calls to the cemetery office and triangulating based on headstones visible beneath the overgrown grass, they placed four red flags at four corners on the ground amid the field pocked with century-old, buried headstones.
In December 1925, the city paid Bell’s widow, who had moved back to Georgia, $4,500 of the requested $5,000. Lawyers for the city didn’t fight it, but arranged “for an immediate settlement,” according to the Defender. The payment was supported by the Illinois Mob Act of 1905, meant to suppress mob violence, which limited damages at $5,000. However, the city did dismiss a case brought by Bell’s sister Lola M. Huff, the administrator of his estate, because the law stated only his widow could claim damages. After the race riots of 1919, the city “almost went into bankruptcy” in paying claimants, the Defender reported.
Epstein married an English woman in 1933. Two years later, their son was born. In 1942, his wife petitioned for her naturalization in the U.S. Census records show he lived at 1340 S. Harding Ave. for many years while working as a maintenance laborer.
Epstein was living in an apartment at 2025 W. Granville Ave. when he died on Dec. 21, 1968, at Bethesda Hospital, according to his obituary. He was 70, a retired 32-year engineer for the Metropolitan Sanitary District.
Rockowitz lived at 1250 S. St. Louis Ave. in 1930, according to records. He was a taxi driver all his life until he died at the age of 77 in 1978.
Greenberg was working in a shoe store and living at 1306 S. Lawndale Ave. with his wife and four children in 1930, Census records show. He last lived at 1224 W. Bryn Mawr Ave. before he died in 1959 in his mid-70s.
Bertha Deutsch was married and had a son in 1925, followed by another in 1927. Her husband Anton, who was from Austria like Bertha, petitioned to become a U.S. citizen in 1928. The couple was living at 4318 Wentworth Ave., according to his petition. They had another son that same year, and one more in 1933.
In 1940, the family lived at 237 W. 58th St., and in 1950 lived at 7042 S. Morgan St., census records show. Her husband died in 1964. When Bertha died in 1992, she had 10 grandchildren and 10 great-grandchildren.
Betty Greenblatt, her husband Abe and their son lived at 528 Lawndale Ave., then at 3744 ½ N. Pine Grove Ave. In 1941, an announcement appeared in the Tribune that a monument was to be dedicated to Greenblatt’s late father, Julius Blum, in the Warsaw section of Waldheim Cemetery. Later in life, she lived at 434 Roscoe Ave. and had two grandchildren. Betty Greenblatt lived to be 80 and died in November 1985, according to her obituary.
Bell’s brother Ernest died of tuberculosis three years after the killing. He was still living in the neighborhood at the time at 1070 W. 13th St. Their brother George died in 1947.
Melvie already had one child with a man named John Brawner in about 1917, records show. He’s also listed as the father of her other son, James, born in 1926. She later married another man, Sim Eberhart, and lived in Philadelphia in the 1940s. She died in November 1960 from heart disease, according to her death certificate. The child of William and Melvie does not seem to appear in records.
The Barbara Jean Wright Court apartment complex, near where William Bell was lynched on Oct. 8, 1924, is seen on the Near West Side on Sept. 29, 2026. Credit: Colin Boyle/Block Club Chicago
Today, the site where Bell was killed is the Barbara Jean Wright Court Apartments, a collection of 272 affordable housing units near the University of Illinois Chicago owned by Jonathan Rose Companies. The spot where 14th Street and Miller Street intersected is now an apartment building and parking lot.
Bell’s story remains little known.
“There must always be a remedy for wrong and injustice if we only know how to find it,” Ida B. Wells, journalist, activist, co-founder of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and unofficial Chicago saint, wrote in her memoir, “The Light of Truth: Writings of an Anti-Lynching Crusader.”
“The way to right wrongs is to turn the light of truth upon them,” she wrote.
A Memorial For Bell
In March 2019, the Equal Justice Initiative, Cook County, the DuSable Museum of African American History and UIC announced a partnership to place a 6-foot memorial for Bell at the DuSable Museum. The marker was to be similar to the memorial for Bell at the Equal Justice Initiative’s National Memorial for Peace and Justice in Montgomery, Alabama, also known as the “Lynching Museum,” which showcases markers for other victims of lynching through its Remembrance Project.
The DuSable Museum installation was slated for 2020 and was to be named the William Bell Remembrance Project.
As of September 2026, it has not yet come to fruition.
Questions about the status of the project sent to Cook County, the DuSable Museum and the Equal Justice Initiative were not returned. Brian Flood, senior associate director of university communications at UIC, acknowledged the question but did not provide an answer. Jonathan Rose Companies also did not respond to inquiries asking if they knew about the history of the property.
“It’s great that supposedly in 2019 that was initiated. Why in 2026 we still don’t have that? I don’t know the answer,” Cole told Block Club. “Of course, COVID is part of the answer. That delayed lots of things, including our work for several years. But, maybe EJI is busy. Maybe DuSable and others need to come up with some money. I do not know.”
Until then, Cole said his Chicago Race Riot of 1919 Commemoration Project group, which formed in 2019 and is volunteer-run, will continue to highlight the systematic inequalities against people of color that still exist.
“To me, at least, part of the answer for the inequalities of today is looking backwards to understand what happened before,” Cole said. ‘The murder of William Bell is not unique. It’s horrible, but there’s a lot of other African-Americans before and after him in Chicago who suffered something similar. One of those might be Laquan McDonald in 2014.”
In July, Cole’s commemoration project group completed its task of installing 38 markers in city sidewalks at the locations where people were murdered, one marker for each victim of the 1919 race riots.
“We believe that in a small way, public art can remember and help us remember racial violence that we believe the city must center,” Cole said.
Workers search for the unmarked grave for William Bell — who was lynched in Chicago on Oct. 8, 1924 — in Section 23 of Lincoln Cemetery just outside of Chicago in Blue Island, Ill., on Sept. 29, 2026. Credit: Colin Boyle/Block Club Chicago
Cole is also part of a group working with the Equal Justice Initiative to collect soil samples from the sites of lynching victims, which will potentially be displayed at its museum, he said. A sample from Bell’s death site is expected to be collected in the fall.
“We believe the events of 1919, as the largest episode of violence, murder and racial violence in the history of Chicago, are particularly important — but it’s not the only horrible thing to happen before and after that also deserve our attention,” Cole said. “William Bell’s murder is one of them, and because it’s also just five years apart, we in CR19 very much see that as sort of a part of the same.”
“The average Chicagoan still doesn’t know these events happened, let alone that it impacted them,” Cole said.
More can, and should, be done, Cole said, “including remembering William Bell in various ways.”
Colin Boyle contributed reporting.
______________________________________________________________________
Support Local News!
Subscribe to Block Club Chicago, an independent, 501(c)(3), journalist-run newsroom. Every dime we make funds reporting from Chicago’s neighborhoods. Already subscribe? Click here to gift a subscription, or you can support Block Club with a tax-deductible donation.
Listen to the Block Club Chicago podcast: