Barrister and anti-corruption campaigner Geoffrey Watson SC has criticised the Prime Minister for controlling and doling out when independent MPs and senators get taxpayer-funded staff insisting the “unreviewable power” must be changed.
The furore follows revelations that the Prime Minister secretly offered One Nation MP David Farley an extra taxpayer-funded staffer this week, prompting Pauline Hanson to accuse him of trying to buy off MPs.
One Nation has now accused the government of trying to exercise “undue influence” over MPs and triggering calls to reform from Geoffrey Watson SC, who is a director at the Centre for Public Integrity.
Under the Members of Parliament (Staff) Act 1984 (MOP(S) Act), the allocation of adviser staff to a minority party is a matter vested in the Prime Minister personally.
“The law is a very bad law because it, unusually by Australian standards, it gives unaccountable, unreviewable power to one person, the Prime Minister. The law should be changed,’’ Geoffrey Watson SC said.
“The second point about it is that ordinarily it might be able to work reasonably well.
“Except currently, the person who has that power seems to be willing to use it for party political manipulative purposes”
Mr Watson, who was also a former counsel assisting the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption, said there were several examples of why this was a problem.
“There’s the one given by Senator Hanson, which may be right or wrong, but in the case of Senator Payman, it’s very plain that she’s being denied staff because of some feud and that quite frankly is disgraceful.
“Meanwhile, he’s given the appropriate funding to the Greens. Why? So there won’t be crossbench support to support a change in the particular law. The whole exercise is entirely cynical.”
“The law is very bad. It’s bad if the person who has the benefit of that law misuses it. It’s being misused.”
Mr Albanese’s office has been contacted for comment.
News.com.au has also obtained a letter sent by Pauline Hanson to the Prime Minister in August outlining their staffing complaints and the stark differences between how some independents are resourced compared to others.
“Commonwealth law uses five members as the threshold for a recognised non-government minority party. The Australian Greens meet that threshold, and you have allocated their adviser staffing on that basis,’’ Senator Hanson said.
“One Nation now meets this threshold. The Australian Greens have 11 parliamentarians and are allocated 17 personal employee positions. We therefore ask that One Nation’s personal staffing allocation be determined on a proportionate basis consistent with the allocation you have provided to the Greens.
“We seek an increase from four positions to nine, with the following allocation of adviser positions (reflecting parity with your previous decision for the Australian Greens.”
“This is a modest request based on the staffing allocation you have already provided to another minority party. lt would provide One Nation with staffing proportionate to your allocation to the Australian Greens, without reducing any other party’s allocation or giving One Nation more favourable treatment.”
One Nation releases bombshell Albo letter
Mr Albanese has secretly offered One Nation MP David Farley an extra taxpayer-funded staffer, prompting Pauline Hanson to accuse him of trying to buy off MPs.
In a dramatic escalation of the war over staffing and ongoing claims that the Prime Minister is controlling when and how independent politicians get staff, One Nation has now accused the government of trying to exercise “undue influence” over the MPs.
The offer is in a letter obtained by news.com.au and signed by the Prime Minister dated October 26. The job is worth up to $200,000.
In a statement on Thursday night, One Nation revealed that David Farley had “brought the following matters to the attention of the leadership of One Nation.”
“Over the past few weeks, the Prime Minister has met with David privately,’’ the One Nation leader said.
“The Prime Minister initiated these meetings. This week, David received a letter from the Prime Minister stating that he had allocated David a personal staff position outside of One Nation’s unresolved staffing request.
“David did not request this allocation of staff. No reason was provided by the Prime Minister for the provision of this staff.
“Following these discussions, senior ministers raised grant funding under the Sustainable Communities Program for the Murray Darling Basin. David did not initiate the discussion regarding this program.
“Taken together, these actions have left David and One Nation deeply concerned that the government is seeking to use taxpayer funds to exert undue political influence over politicians.
“We have decided to expose these grubby dealings because the public deserves to know what the Albanese Labor government is doing behind closed doors.”
One Nation has spent month arguing for a more “transparent and objective allocation of staffing for parliamentarians.”
“The Prime Minister has refused to respond to these calls,’’ Senator Hanson said.
“Yet astonishingly, this week the Prime Minister provided a letter to David directly granting a Personal Adviser 3 position, paid up to $200,000, effective immediately. David has rejected this unsolicited allocation.”
One Nation Senator Pauline Hanson has backed the Member for Fowler, Dai Le MP and Senator for Western Australia, Fatima Payman to demand “consistent, transparent and independently determined staffing allocations.”
“The Prime Minister should not personally control the resources available to his political
opponents,’’ Senator Hanson said.
“While this power has always been open to abuse, it has, in our view, been weaponised to an unprecedented extent under this Labor Government and this Prime Minister”
“One Nation will always stand up for the interests of all Australians. We won’t be bought or
divided by this Prime Minister.”
In response, Mr Farley has now written back rejecting the offer and asking for all further negotiations to be addressed to One Nation leader Pauline Hanson.
PM’s cold reply to senator’s desperate plea
Earlier, Mr Albanese down Senator Fatima Payman’s plea for more staff after she accused him of waiting for a Helen Haines event outside her electorate office as her staff deal with vile abuse.
The former Labor MP turned independent has a famously combative relationship with the Prime Minister after she quit his government to sit on the crossbench in support of Palestine.
But this week, she shocked colleagues by accusing the Prime Minister of “waiting for something like what happened to Dr Helen Haines to occur to my office, to me, for him to take our request seriously”.
This story is developing. For updates download our new app
She later apologised to Helen Haines for the remarks but not to the Prime Minister, who was confronted with questions over his refusal to grant her request for more staff as an independent.
At a press conference in Canberra, the Prime Minister was asked if it was appropriate that he is “the arbiter, the sole person who decides staffing arrangements.”
“Fatima Payman has the same numbers of staff now as she had when she was elected as a Labor senator, indeed one more, because we granted an additional staffer to all senators and all members of the House of Representatives,‘’ Mr Albanese responded.
Senator Payman told news.com.au that she did not have an extra staff member. Like all MPs and Senators she has five Electorate officers, although one was on stress leave following an “onslaught of comments and death threats.”
“In between looking after a 5-month-old baby and making sure I’m at estimates hearings on time, I don’t have enough staff to respond to the PM’s disinformation,’’ she said.
However, the number of staff senators have has increased from four to five, as the PM suggested.
She also provided a staff list confirming that she had been denied a personal staff member as an independent, unlike most other independents.
For example, Tasmanian Independent Senator Jacquie Lambie has three personal staff in addition to her five electorate staff, while Senator Payman has none.
Vile abuse
Senator Payman’s outburst follows years of security incidents. Most recently, a Bunnings worker avoided jail time after he targeted her with what magistrate Anna Smith labelled “repulsive” threats, including a phone call where the court was told the man said:
“I hope you goat f*****g degenerate terrorist c**t get hit by a truck (before) … he reverses over your f*****g foul terrorist head, just to make sure that he did the job properly..”
Senator Payman was also called a “filthy Islamist terrorist”, a “rapist” and a “filthy f*****g pedophile”, along other baseless slurs, the court heard.
After a public backlash over the remarks, Senator Payman revealed on Wednesday that she contacted Helen Haines, who is lying in a Melbourne hospital bed after a double amputation, to clarify her remarks.
“In Senate estimates last night I was frustrated and exhausted after almost two years of asking for the staffing my office needs. In expressing that frustration, I referred to Dr Haines’s attack, which is obviously front of mind for all of us,” she told news.com.au.
“While my intention was not to diminish the attack on Helen, I understand that it could be seen that way and I apologise if this has caused any distress to Helen, or her family.
“While poorly worded, the issue I was trying to raise is real.
“My office has referred more than 100 incidents of threats and abuse to the Australian Federal Police. My staff carry the burden of monitoring, reporting and managing that material every day, on top of the work of representing Western Australians as an independent.
“Even if you take away the fact that I am a high-profile, visibly Muslim, female Senator, I am still operating an office with two fewer staff than my colleagues on the crossbench.”
What Senator Payman said about the PM
Just days after revealing voters were sending her office images of faeces and a Queensland man was charged for sending her office vile abuse, Senator Payman stunned colleagues with her remarks over the failure to provide her with more staff.
“I’ve been waiting two years, chair, and I am tired of looking in my staff’s eyes and saying you’ll just have to deal with this because the prime minister is petty and is taking it out on me,’’ Senator Payman told parliament.
“Please raise this with the prime minister. Because if he cares so much about the welfare and wellbeing of people who work in this building, then I implore you and the prime minister to look into the fact that my staff are burning out. They can’t take this any longer.
“Is the prime minister waiting for something like what happened to Dr Helen Haines to occur to my office, to me, for him to take our request seriously?”
Special Minister of State Don Farrell pushed back in the committee hearing, suggesting the remarks were “outrageous.”
Pauline Hanson’s surprise support for Fatima Payman
Pauline Hanson has backed independent WA senator Fatima Payman’s remarks suggesting the Prime Minister is “waiting” for a Helen Haines-style attack on her office.
“Anthony Albanese is proving exactly why the power to decide staffing allocations should be taken out of his hands. “It’s hypocritical for the Prime Minister to lecture everyone about turning the temperature down while abusing his powers against his political opponents,” she told news.com.au.
“The Prime Minister has ignored our request for staffing proportionate to the allocation he has given the Greens. Our request includes staff to co-ordinate logistics and security to keep people safe. He granted David Shoebridge’s request within two weeks. Our request from August remains unanswered.
“You don’t get to preach about politicians’ safety while denying your opponents the staff needed to help keep their people safe. It’s a grubby abuse of power.”
The late-night outburst occurred on the same day that parliamentarians gathered to pay tribute to Helen Haines after she underwent a double amputation after a man allegedly drove at her outside her electorate office, prompting calls for a kinder, gentler, parliamentary debate.
Senator Payman has formed an unlikely alliance with One Nation in campaigning for additional staff,
The One Nation leader stood side-by-side with Western Australian senator Fatima Payman and independent Fowler MP Dai Le to demand Anthony Albanese allocate additional staffing for the minor parties.
Read related topics:Anthony AlbanesePauline Hanson