CHICAGO — Halloween time is upon us; have you carved your turnips yet?
“We spent hours and hours trying to carve out these turnips to make the jack-o’-lanterns,” said Gus Noble, president of Chicago Scots and a Scotland native. “I remember carving these turnips that were so difficult, and then I came to the States and thought, ‘Oh, they’ve got it easy over here.’”
While pumpkins have taken the place of turnips, the roots of Halloween in Chicago are still in Scottish lore and traditions, brought here in the early to mid-1800s by early transplants.
The ghosts of those customs are present in some of the holiday’s essential components today, like trick-or-treating and dressing up in costume. Yet, their Celtic and Scottish cultural context is often forgotten or unknown — a fact Noble said recently came to light when his son, born in the U.S., asked him about Halloween’s origins.
After over three decades of living in Chicago, Noble hadn’t thought about it in a long time, either.
Credit: Pexels
How It’s Done In Scotland
Noble is from a small town in Scotland called Duns. He came to the United States in 1992 after meeting a group of Americans in a pub, one of whom he began dating. They later broke up, but he fell in love again and started a family in Chicago.
“The pagan identity of Halloween remained quite strong in the small town where I’m from,” he said. “It was quite spiritual without being religious. It was an occasion that we all sensed change and connection to something that may be beyond our understanding. It was quite mystical.”
In Scotland, Halloween is an evolution of the ancient Celtic festival of Samhain, representing the summer’s end and All Hallows Eve, when the veil between this world and the spirits of those in the afterlife becomes very thin, Noble said. Spirits can connect, engage and are welcomed into our lives, he explained. Many of them are good, “but many of them can be bad too.”
His experience as a boy included “guising” — coming from the word “disguising,” or wearing costumes.
Gus Noble, president of Chicago Scots. Credit: Provided
“I remember distinctly getting dressed up as something scary, and it was only latterly when I thought about it that if you accept that the veil between this world and the next becomes thin [on Halloween], and spirits and ghouls and things come back into this world, the way you protect yourself is to dress as one of them,” Noble said. “Then you can go out freely, and this became kind of the roots of guising.”
His version of trick-or-treating required him to dress up and perform a poem, song, dance, trick or other performance to earn fruit and nuts. Sometimes, he’d go to houses where you’d have to “duke” for apples either in someone’s home or in a big trough outside. Other times, homes would have sticky treacle scones hanging from strings in the trees, and with his hands behind his back, he’d have to try and bite one.
“And you’d end up, you know, soaking wet with treacle all over your face,” Noble recalled.
When he came to the United States and saw the difference that his kids experienced at Halloween, like not having to sing for your sweets, it was a letdown.
“You just get given candy,” he said. “It was something of a disappointment; I wanted to see kids have to work for their fun.”
Still, he’s able to recognize his homeland of Scotland in Chicago’s modern-day Halloween traditions.
“The scary side of it comes from guising for sure … the trick-or-treating … the fact that you sit on your porch or at the end of your garden and engage with kids,” he said. “There was a tradition of putting empty chairs outside front doors for ancestors to come and visit and welcome.”
Noble’s Halloween experience more strongly aligns with early Scots in Chicago, who were among the first immigrants to the area.
The Chicago Scots organization is the oldest nonprofit in Illinois, founded in 1845 originally as the Illinois St. Andrew’s Society. Life in America came with competing goals: to integrate and to keep their traditions going.
“The Scots were very quick to assimilate to become Americans — not Scottish Americans but Americans Americans, because they saw that as the fast track to prosperity and success,” Noble said.
One of the ways this manifested was through Halloween, then called All Hallows Eve, Hallow Eve, Hallows Eve or Hallowe’en, due to its association with the Catholic feasts of All Saints Day, which occurs on Nov. 1, and the related feast of All Souls Day, which falls on Nov. 2.
“Far back in the dim ages of the past, this ovation to self began,” wrote The Weekly Chicago Times in January 1859. “And from the unanimity with which it was offered, the day became hallowed throughout the Christian world, and the night before was styled, ‘Hallowed Eve.’ This has been corrupted in our day into ‘Hallow Eve.’”
The newspaper blurb is one of the earliest mentions of the holiday in Chicago and discussed how various ethnic groups celebrated it, especially the Scottish, whose customs “we recognize traces of … in our way day and country.” The traditions are encapsulated in famous Scottish poet Robert Burns’ “Halloween” poem, written in 1785.
In 1860, an article from the day after Halloween described the “eve with prophecy in Scottish lays and legends” as lending a “generous hand to the merry maskings and harmless soothsayings” of the local Scots, such as “frolics and junketing,” meaning an early version of trick-or-treating. And in 1861, the Tribune ran a short blurb describing All Hallow’s Evening as a “festival particular to the Scotch and English” and that it “will be quite generally celebrated by our Scotch and English citizens.”
“Our English and Scotch friends have given a happy version to the day by making it the anniversary of those little aerial people, the fairies, who upon this evening, above all others, delight in merry making and mischief,” the paper wrote.
Illustrations of a Halloween feast from the Chicago Tribune, circa 1900. Credit: Provided
Cabbage, Kale And Nuts
Scottish Halloweens, according to 19th-century lore, were more about foretelling love and romance than collecting candy or invoking Frankenstein’s monster.
Between sunset and midnight, divinations could be performed to reveal the future of a person’s love life, according to some traditional accounts. One such custom included peeling an apple without breaking it, then setting the peeled skin around a woman’s head and letting it fall into place. The letter that most closely resembled the shape of the peel would be that of her future husband.
Other purported traditions included eating an apple in front of a mirror while holding a candle in her left hand. By the last bite, the mirror would have revealed features of her spouse-to-be.
There was also the pulling of various plants and vegetables, like kale, oats and cabbage, which would show what her husband would look like, as well as the burning of a pair of nuts. If the nuts burned quietly and evenly, it was a sign of smooth marital sailing ahead; if they hissed and crackled, the relationship may be in trouble.
Because Halloween took place between summer and fall when many crops were due for harvest, the holiday also included a huge supper, often featuring stews and an oatmeal pudding eaten with butter instead of milk. Being the last night of October, it stood “upon the threshold of winter,” when warm-hearted laddies and lassies be wont to gather round the ingle nook,” The Inter Ocean wrote in an 1875 article.
A Scottish Holiday, Chicago-Style
Initially celebrated mainly by the Scottish immigrants living in Chicago, by the 1860s, Halloween was catching on among the city’s other citizens, who were putting their own spin on the holiday.
“The young folks … like to make molasses candy, and know how to eat it,” the Tribune wrote the day after Halloween in 1865. “A large quantity of the sweet material was made and masticated last evening in Chicago.”
The next year, McVicker’s Theatre, a historic theater in the Loop, was set to begin a run of a “beautiful drama” called, “All Hallow Eve; Or, Snap-Apple Night.”
“Many among our population will…observe some of the ancient practices common to All Hallows Day,” the Chicago Evening Post wrote in 1869. “The festival today will be celebrated in the different Catholic churches here,” such as St. Mary’s, where a reverend was to give a free lecture entitled, “Purgatory.”
The Inter Ocean noted a few years later that the Young People’s Mutual Improvement Association of the First Scotch Church would be celebrating “Hallow-Eve” the following night with “literary, musical and social entertainment.” In the next day’s edition of the Chicago Evening Post, in the “Local Brevities” section of the newspaper, it simply stated, “Hallow Eve.”
Another story from 1875 noted Halloween as the “whirligig of time” when supposedly “time-honored festivals which our Scottish forefathers delighted to honor” occurred, still cherished by “the old and young ones of the present generation.” That year, since October 31 fell on a Sunday, the holiday was to be marked the following Monday.
Among the changes made to Halloween during this time was the shift from its supposed traditions of trying to predict love to something new.
“While people have become too sensible in these practical days to believe in omens and ‘ghaists,’ there was just as much sense in the old love-tests of Hallowe’en as in the modern devotion to Spiritualism,” The Inter Ocean wrote.
The McVickers Theatre in the Loop hosted an All Hallow Eve production in 1866. Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Around this time, notices were made in the paper about private citizens throwing Halloween parties, like Mr. H.E. Wookey of Irving Park. Mr. and Mrs. George Waddell of South Morgan Street held a party at their home.
“Halloween is not celebrated this side of the Atlantic as it is in the British Isles,” where the holiday was revered “for the fun that comes with darkness,” the Tribune wrote the same year the Wookey and Waddell parties were held. Still, it was a holiday that brought “rejoicing” to Chicago.
In 1877, a story in the newspaper mentioned that college men from Northwestern had “turned out in force” for Halloween “judging by the depredations they committed” — although “they … did nothing very brilliant” outside the ordinary pranks — except for tying “a couple of cows to the steps of the Women’s College.”
Three years later, a group of masked sophomores put a goat in the college’s cottage, where a senior happened to be. The senior grabbed two of the sophomores and “gave them a sound drubbing.”
“A few moments afterward a scream rent the air from the institution opposite,” The Inter Ocean reported. The screaming was the goat, who’d gotten away and was being “ejected” from where it had wandered from by another student. By 1883, Evanston had deployed extra police on Halloween.
Starting in the late 1870s, the Confectionary Benevolent Association of Chicago began throwing a Hallow Eve ball. The holiday was taking on an American life of its own, with some traditions falling by the wayside.
“In America there is a general throwing aside of quiet ignoring of some of the pleasant feasts that used to be celebrated” as part of a traditional Scottish Halloween, The Inter Ocean reported.
Halloween of 1879 was “duly observed by a number of Chicagoans, and remembered by many more,” the newspaper wrote.
By the early 1880s, an article about Halloween recalled the nut-burning tradition, adding that “there is no need for the maids of Chicago to remain longer uncertain as to what are to be the developments of the year in the matrimonial line when nuts are so plenty and so cheap as the street vendors offer them now.” If nuts couldn’t be obtained, however, “Chicago offers a wide field for prophecy in the cabbage patches that have on several occasions been looked upon as nuisances by our Health Department.”
And by this time, Halloween gatherings held by fraternal organizations such as the Odd Fellows were becoming popular, with members of the Home Lodge No. 416 holding one party with more than 125 couples in attendance.
The Caledonian Society was another early organizer of Halloween events, hosting annual parties and gatherings that featured Scottish music, dancing, literature and speakers. The Inter Ocean reported that more than 1,000 Scots in Chicago met in 1884 at the Hershey Music Hall to “hear a performance as Scottish as haggis,” with bagpipers and singing “in the memory of many a Scot who has now made his home in the West.” By 1886, they were charging $1 for admittance.
Parades were even becoming a thing, with the Chicago Bicycle Club holding a Halloween parade with Chinese lanterns along Michigan and Prairie avenues one year.
By the late 1880s, the holiday was becoming fully intertwined with American tradition in Chicago, particularly as an occasion for women to host parties. An illustrated rundown of Halloween party ideas appeared in the October 1889 edition of Ladies’ Home Journal.
An illustration of a Halloween party from a 1900 Chicago Tribune. Credit: Provided
It was also becoming more rowdy.
“We trust the boys of Chicago will restrain their inclination to reduce the city to a state of chaos,” the Tribune wrote one Halloween.
By the mid-1890s, some considered the holiday a “relic of Pagan times.”
“Did you walk around the block last night with salt in your mouth filled with salt? Did you duck for apples? Did you soak the left sleeve of your shirt, hang it up before the firelogs and watch it til the stroke of midnight? Possibly not,” wrote The Inter Ocean.
The boy of Chicago didn’t “breathlessly wait” to see apparitions of their love life; “he threw a handful of dust into the eyes of the vendor of bananas and chestnuts, and, at a safe distance, watched the facial contortions.” The “youth of the World’s Fair City” didn’t pull up stalks of corn or other vegetation; “they found barrel staves instead of stalks and broke them over the backs of belated and unsuspecting pedestrians.”
The pranking version of Halloween saw Chicago children stealing “smallpox” signs from doctors’ offices and nailing them to someone’s front door.
“‘Washing Done Here’ on a sign in front of a Michigan Avenue mansion might reflect seriously on the compilers of the ‘Blue Book’ … but it brings unalloyed joy to the heart of the infantile vandal who engineers the job,” the paper wrote.
Other stolen and relocated signs included: “Teeth Pulled Painlessly” at confectioneries, “Barn For Rent” in front of a theater, “Suits To Fit” on the doorbell of a judge, “Lookout For Pickpockets” at a police station and “We Strive To Please” in front of cemetery gates. These were found to be “irritable only to the vast minority.”
Halloween decorations in the 2200 block of West Estes Avenue in West Ridge. Credit: Carrie Jackson for Block Club Chicago
Getting Ghoulish
The Inter Ocean explained how, by close to the turn of the century, “the small boys do most of the celebrating” on Halloween. The tradition of terror, it said, had turned to “chagrin.”
“Boys will be boys,” it mused.
Yet perhaps that was an omen of its own, as the late 1800s saw a major shift into holiday-inspired destruction and chaos.
In 1890, 23 boys and girls traveling together on a bus for a Halloween party collided with another vehicle at Kedzie Avenue and Madison Street, although none died.
Elsewhere in the city, the “young rowdies who loaf about Kinzie and Clark streets” burst into Jacobs’ Clark Street Theater, filled with liquor, and “pelted the employees with missiles and then decamped.” Police quickly caught up with the ringleader, but his friends came back to try and fight off the officer. The main rabble rouser, 15-year-old Michael O’Hara, bit two officers’ fingers. He was taken away in the police wagon and ultimately fined $10 and sent to the House of Correction, according to The Inter Ocean.
Two years later, Chicagoans were told to take in their signs, hide loose boxes, secure their gates, unchain their dogs, examine their locks and to patrol their properties incognito if they wanted to get ahead of Halloween mischief.
In one turn-of-the-century attack, burglars broke into Mr. and Mrs. R. Greenhalgh’s house, stole money, turned over furniture and tied the dining room table to a chandelier, then left a note “explaining that Halloween came only once a year.”
A 1910 Chicago newspaper article about Halloween and “amusing pranks for witch night.” Credit: Provided
Halloween Parties And Pumpkins
While it was mischievous times for boys, for girls and women the holiday tended to focus on throwing parties and celebrations.
The “Cooking and Serving” section of The Inter Ocean offered nut-based recipes for Halloween, such as salted chestnuts, for parties held in 1908. The next year, Miss Mathilda Greenwall’s Halloween party for members of the Lutheran League English Church of the Atonement at 70th and Laflin streets was so good that those present unanimously voted her as captain of the next event.
Chicago newspapers helped keep the holiday popular in the early 1900s, with one two-page spread dedicated to ways women could throw Halloween parties, including recipes, invitation ideas and games. In 1910, 300 couples from the Women’s Trade Union League of Chicago — which was on strike — gathered to celebrate at a Halloween party, with proceeds of the party going to the workers.
Around this time, Chicago also began to see an expansion in the commercialization of Halloween, with newspaper advertisements offering pumpkins, lanterns, candies, decorations and other oddities. Halloween parties were expected and highly anticipated by adults and children in Chicago. Popular costumes of the time included witches and goblins.
In 1915, a contest was held by The Chicago Live Stock World newspaper for children to write the best letter about Halloween, which it would feature in a future edition that offered suggestions on new games, tricks and party ideas. The winner would also receive a Halloween lantern the size and shape of a pumpkin made of paper mache. The lantern had a face through which the light could be seen and wore a dunce cap.
Credit: Pexels
Keeping Halloween History Alive
By the second decade of the 20th century, there was a yearning for the old days of a more Scottish-themed Halloween whose customs, some felt, had been lost in Chicago.
In 1919, Jane Eddington of the Tribune wrote about Halloween, particularly its Scottish supper origins.
“Halloween is the permanent Scottish symbol added to our civilization, and if we wish to make it anything more than an echo of an echo to boredom, we must hark back to Scottish life for our inspiration in celebrating it,” she wrote.
The “child’s play of Halloween,” including carving pumpkins, the use of the symbols of dark figures like witches, goblins, black cats and owls, and the invention of “simple tricks or the use of old ones,” has a large background in the past, she said — “and the backgrounds have a large place in the development of humanity.”
Sixty years earlier, in 1859, a Weekly Chicago Times story about Halloween’s origins was written by Thomas Tompkins on behalf of his wife, who “ventures to express the hope, fond, credulous soul, that it may have some effect in, at least, retarding the rather rapid progress of young America.” Halloween, like other holidays in the U.S. with roots in the traditions of immigrants, should receive its due recognition, she said.
“One of the not least suggestive changes of the present day, and one which has been to many of us the cause of the deepest regret, is the gradually diminishing interest manifested in the observance of ancient festivals,” he said. “For fear of lapsing into superstition, we are rapidly running to the opposite extreme — want of belief in anything.”
An image from an old Chicago newspaper showing Halloween-themed baked goods like Witch CapCakes. Credit: Provided
Pleading For Sanity
In 1920, Halloween parties were “being booked for nearly all the hotels of the city,” the National Hotel Reporter reported. One of the parties apparently included stealing a car and firing guns.
A story in the Tribune recalled how three men and three women were found in the stolen car, which crashed into a building at Laflin Avenue and Jackson Boulevard, allowing five of the six to escape. They shot at the man they’d stolen it from while fleeing. The lone woman told officers she’d been out to “a little Halloween party.”
Newspapers featured recipes for dishes such as Deviled Meat, Witch Salad and Witch Soup and Garnished Squash, along with cake, cookie and chocolate recipes.
At the same time, some were taking issue with the holiday because of the destruction the supposed pranks wrought on people’s homes and businesses.
“Without discouraging innocent amusements or harmless child’s play … isn’t it possible in the age of culture and refinement … that we have some respect for the personal and property rights of others?” asked the Suburbanite Economist.
A 1925 newspaper article asked the question more bluntly: “Are Hallowe’en Pranks Getting Worse Or Not?” citing past pranks like putting a milk wagon on the roof of a laundry business, tearing off tin roofs to scare those sleeping inside and filling doorways with shrubs and bushes.
“I used to tell my four sons that when it came to Hallowe’en pranks I could show them a thing or two,” R. H. Rennie told the paper.
However, E.A. McVay of 70th Street disagreed, saying that in the last few years, “damage done by boys on Hallowe’en has become greater and greater and the matter is getting much more serious,” citing broken porch railings, fences and windows. When he was a kid, he used to take gates from the hinges and change signs from business houses, sure, but “nothing was broken up or destroyed,” he said.
The next year, the city announced a crackdown on the hijinks.
“Garbage cans will preserve an upright position, swings [will] not barricade sidewalks, tires will remain inflated and cows will not be perched in trees on Halloween if Supt. William McAndrew’s campaign to put an end to youthful impishness on that night is successful,” the Tribune reported.
Children bob for apples and throw darts at a Halloween carnival put on by former Young Lords gang members at Isham Memorial YMCA at North Larrabee Street and West Ogden Avenue. Credit: ST-80005074-0013, Chicago Sun-Times collection, Chicago History Museum
McAndrew, the superintendent of Chicago Public Schools, sent out binding “anti-mischief” pledge cards as part of his “drive to preserve the integrity of window panes … and the peace of mind of older citizens.”
Plans were put in place to quell the chaos, such as kid-friendly movies playing at local theaters, community singing events and free talks on the “absurdity of studying good citizenship in school and then on Halloween violating” those principles. Police urged a “safe, sane Halloween,” pleading with citizens to do anything they can to minimize destruction. More than 95 movie houses with seats for more than 100,000 students agreed to open their doors early.
“It’s all up to the kids now,” the Tribune wrote five days before Halloween, citing city leaders trying to lure children into making safe choices for the holiday.
Some adults made the opposite choice: A mashup of two South Side parties ended in gunfire that wounded two people and left others with injuries. Another man was stabbed “by a Halloween reveler.”
Apparently, the children’s behavior was satisfactory, though, because by a few years later, the pleading had slowed.
Trick-or-treating became progressively more popular in the 1940s. In the early 1950s, the Peanuts comic strip and a Walt Disney cartoon, along with candy company marketing, helped to spread the practice nationwide on Halloween, giving us the holiday we know today. Chicago, at the time the candy capital of the nation, fully embraced the modern incarnation of Halloween.
Halloween decorations in the 3800 block of North Keeler Avenue in October 2025. Credit: Provided by Anna Zolkowski Sobor.
Resurrecting Scottish Roots
Today, the melding of Scottish and Chicago heritage is front of mind for Noble. He recently attended a tribute show to singer John Prine at the Chicago Theatre, which included celebrity guests. It brought a tear to his eye hearing them talk about what it meant to be a Chicagoan, he said.
“I talk a lot about what it means to be Scottish … But [South Side native] John C. Reilly talked about what it means to be a Chicagoan,” he said. “And I am really proud of my identity as a Chicagoan and a Chicago Scot.”
Even though Scots have a reputation for being stoic, it’s no surprise to Noble that he’s been feeling particularly sentimental, especially around Halloween.
“I guess that’s what Halloween is,” he said. “The veil is lifted and it gives us a chance to explore and imagine … It’s the immigrant experience too, so Halloween is very evocative of what it’s like to move somewhere new, try something new, step into the unknown.”
It’s uniquely a holiday that everyone can take part in, too, he said — a thread that weaves between the many immigrants in Chicago and the U.S.
“I think Halloween is symbolic of not just this one particular day of the year, but the spirit of immigration, of change, of passage from one place to another,” Noble said. “It’s symbolic of: here we are.”
Chicago is a city of immigrants and their traditions, he said, interlaced with the customs of “our [Indigenous] native cousins,” and it’s through the blending of those things that Halloween has become something that everybody can feel part of.
“It’s the one day of the year where everybody gets to celebrate together,” Noble said. “At school, they don’t celebrate Christmas or other religious holidays … But everybody seems to be invited to be part of Halloween.”
That’s a very Chicagoan thing, he said, and “frankly is very Scottish too.”
Kids trick-or-treating in Northalsted in 2023. Credit: Del Nakamura
For Noble, Halloween might look a little more like home this year, he said.
“I’m going to resurrect some of those things of my youth, and as the president of the Chicago Scots, I’m going to be encouraging others to do so,” he said. “We’ll do it at the Scottish Home, and at Gus’s house.”
That means bobbing for apples and maybe some treacle scones, or giving candy in exchange for a little song or dance. At the least, he hopes to share those traditions with his own kids.
The Chicago Scots headquarters is within the Caledonia Senior Living home in suburban North Riverside — a nursing home for the Scottish. At the home, they’ll do the usual pumpkin decorating and “all the things that the American version of Halloween involves.” Last year, the Scottish Home was surrounded by creatures like werewolves, ghouls and monsters, Noble said.
He’s been inspired to try to revive some of the old tricks, too. Residents may not be able to bob for apples, but maybe they could fish for them.
A membership to Chicago Scots also comes with free admission to 130 heritage sites across Scotland, including 20 haunted castles, each with “its own chilling history” — available to anyone who is Scottish by birth, heritage or “by inclination.”
“If you want to be one of us, you’re one of us,” he said. “And [if it’s by inclination], there’s Halloween.”
______________________________________________________________________
Support Local News!
Subscribe to Block Club Chicago, an independent, 501(c)(3), journalist-run newsroom. Every dime we make funds reporting from Chicago’s neighborhoods. Already subscribe? Click here to gift a subscription, or you can support Block Club with a tax-deductible donation.
Listen to the Block Club Chicago podcast: