You think you can make the intersection before the yellow light turns red – so you stomp on the gas.

Or you’re late for an appointment, traffic is light, no cops around – so you edge up to 45, 46, 47 in a 35 mph zone.

Either way, you could get “flashed.”

Around Scottsdale, drivers grimace when they see the telltale flash, indicating a camera just caught them in a possible infraction.

Critics of the system at the state legislature pushed for a proposition regulating photo enforcement systems.

According to the Scottsdale Police Department, knowing they could get flashed makes Scottsdale residents better drivers.

Photo enforcement cameras should not be confused with the much newer automated license-plate reader cameras – such as those of Flock Safety. Scottsdale’s Flock cameras have been called into question by City Council, which in 2027 plans to end the city’s three-year-old relationship with Flock.

Traffic cameras, by contrast, are hardly new: As the Scottsdale Police Department notes, it “has used photo enforcement technology since 1996 to help reduce red-light running and speeding.”

Now, statewide ballots for the Nov. 3 election include Proposition 319, “Prohibit New Photo Traffic Enforcement Systems Measure.”

The “new” in the title is a bit misleading.

Voting yes does support “prohibiting the state, and other government entities, from installing and using new photo enforcement systems to identify people who violate certain traffic ordinances, including traffic signs, markings, signals, and speed restrictions.”

An affirmative vote also supports “requiring local governments that have installed such systems to receive voter approval in order to continue using them.”

As such, a Prop 319 win does not itself require Scottsdale to remove its cameras.

But, if the prop passes, the city would have to allow its voters to decide on the matter.

Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, Tempe and other cities would “continue using the existing systems only if local authorities receive voter approval at a referendum in the November 2027 election.”

Cities that receive approval – if Prop 319 passes – would have free sailing for photo radar for 10 years.

But if the proposition passes and Scottsdale fails in a referendum next year, the Scottsdale Police Department would have 90 days to pull the plug on its city-wide system.

 

‘Force multiplier’

Scottsdale started using photo enforcement technology in 1996.

In the summer of 2025, City Council asked for details on photo enforcement – which Scottsdale Police Chief Joe LeDuc provided Nov. 3, 2025.

Scottsdale operates 15 total traffic cameras, he said, with 11 at intersections and four “mobile.”

He stressed the SPD’s 0.11 cameras per square mile is “the

lowest density among Valley cities” and “demonstrates a targeted, data-driven approach.”

How is the 30-year-old system working?

Great, LeDuc praised, citing a 2023 study that showed a 15% reduction in total accidents – and 49% reduction in fatal wrecks – at intersections with photo cameras.

One slide from his presentation called cameras a “force multiplier,” as they operate continuously – and are not impacted by staffing changes.

You can’t beat them for efficiency, the chief crowed: “Each photo enforcement camera provides approximately 8,700 hours

of traffic monitoring, compared to the average motor unit officer

completing approximately 900 hours of traffic monitoring annually.”

He compared the one-time cost of a $123,000 photo enforcement camera with a patrol officer’s annual cost (salary, benefits, equipment, etc.) of $193,000.

One camera, he noted, can do the work of a dozen officers.

(Includes salary, benefits, fleet, equipment, and overtime)

And, LeDuc stressed, “police staff review every violation before a citation is issued.”

In 2025, Scottsdale officers wrote up 19,741 citations according to Scottsdale Police Officer Aaron Bolin.

Last year, SPD sent out 53,612 photo-originated citations.

One of those went to Scottsdale’s leader.

According to Bolin, “Scottsdale Mayor Lisa Borowsky was photographed by a photo enforcement speed camera at 3:06 p.m. on Oct. 14, 2025.”

Traveling northbound on Scottsdale Road across Thomas Road, Borowsky was allegedly driving 58 mph – in a 40 mph zone.

On Halloween 2025, Scottsdale City Court mailed Borowsky notice of the violation.

According to Bolin, Borowsky did not respond by the deadline of Dec. 1 she was given.

Borowsky said she never received the notice.

“I had no information or knowledge of it whatsoever before I was contacted by a reporter,” Borowsky said.

 

Tempe/Phoenix

Scottsdale’s neighbors also use a similar system.

Tempe’s photo enforcement cameras became operational on May 7, 2025, beginning with a 30-day warning period to help drivers adjust to the new system.

The city installed photo enforcement cameras at 14 intersections “to improve roadway safety and encourage responsible driving,” according to the city’s website.

“The goal is simple: slow down, stop at red lights, and prevent crashes.

The Tempe Police Department responded to a request for information on its traffic cameras by sending three graphics.

One shows all crashes at photo enforcement intersections for the second quarter of 2024, 2025 and 2026.  

There were 166 crashes at those intersections in 2024, followed by 156 the next year and 155 in the same period this year.

“If we compare 2024 to 2026 we have a 6.62% decrease in crashes,” a police spokesman noted.

Isolating rear-end collisions in the second quarter of each of the three years shows a 12% decrease, according to the Tempe Police Department.

A third graphic provides total violations and citations issued.

In the first nine months of 2026, the Verra Mobility system sent just over 125,000 potential violations to the Tempe Police Department – which reviewed and deemed 110,000 “valid events.”

Around 62,000 “notices of violations” were issued, with 48,000 citations issued.

The difference between the two?

“A photo enforcement citation is equivalent to a citation issued by an officer; the primary difference is that it arrives in the mail,” according to the Tempe Police Department.

A notice of violation is sent to the registered owner when police cannot identify the driver. The notice informs the owner that their vehicle was observed speeding or running a red light at a specific date, time and location. 

“The registered owner may provide the Police Department with the name of the person driving the vehicle but is not required to do so,” a police department spokesman explained.

“There is no fine associated with a notice of violation. If the registered owner takes no action, the notice of violation will expire in the system.”

Tempe’s website explaining the system stresses traffic cameras are used for safety, “and research shows that photo enforcement works. 

“According to the U.S. Department of Transportation, these systems can reduce crashes by more than 50%.”

Tempe also cited Scottsdale’s crash-reduction data at intersections using photo enforcement.

Two years ago, Phoenix City Council approved traffic cameras.

According to its website, “The city of Phoenix Photo Safety Program utilizes a total of 17 speed-monitoring cameras placed at various locations throughout the city aimed at changing driver behavior.”

The cameras are aimed at “supplementing traffic enforcement efforts by Phoenix Police and complementing the city’s other Vision Zero strategies.”

Some cities refer to similar programs as “automated enforcement” or “photo radar,” Phoenix notes.

 

Pro Prop 319

Supporters of Prop 319 include the groups Americans for Tax Reform, Chispa Arizona and Progress Arizona, as well as state representatives on both sides of the aisle.

Republican Sen. John Kavanagh, who represents Scottsdale and parts of Phoenix, argues, “Police officers exercise discretion as to when they will pull somebody over. 

“Photo radar, on the other hand, concerning speeding, is [giving] anybody doing 11 miles or more over the speed limit a ticket.”

Democratic Sen. Analise Ortiz, who represents Glendale and Maryvale, insists “photo-enforcement systems increasingly rely on technology like Flock cameras that track our movements and sell our data …

“We can improve street safety with non-surveillance solutions that do not compromise our privacy,” she concluded.

The Yes on Prop 319 echoes Ortiz, saying photo enforcement systems “increasingly use automated license plate readers – the same technology used by Flock.”

Republican Sen. Wendy Rogers, who represents Flagstaff, is harsh on traffic cams: 

“Automated enforcement removes discretion, undermines due process, and turns routine driving into a revenue stream. That’s not how law enforcement should work in Arizona.”

 

Against Prop 319

Groups against the proposition include AAA Arizona, Arizona Public Health Association and the League of Arizona Cities and Towns.

According to Democratic Sen. Lauren Kuby, who represents Tempe and Phoenix,  “Prop 319 does not ban or regulate surveillance cameras – it only dismantles traffic safety tools. 

“Do not confuse red-light and speed safety cameras with ALPR license plate tracking,” she stresses.

Will Humble, executive director of the Arizona Public Health Association, complains of over-reach.

“Nobody likes getting a ticket in the mail. And we totally get why lots of people are frustrated with cities that pepper their roads with speed cameras on streets with unreasonably low speed limits, like Paradise Valley does,” Humble writes in his Prop 319 opposition.

“But this proposition goes too far.

“Why? Because it stops cities and towns from installing lifesaving red-light cameras, not just the photo radar speed traps.

Red-light cameras aren’t the same as speed cameras. They’re placed at dangerous intersections to stop people from running red lights. That matters because red-light runners cause violent T-bone crashes that kill people and cause serious injuries and lifelong disabilities.”