Appreciation strengthened in roughly half of major metros from August to September while weakening in the other half, leaving brokers without a single national narrative to bring to clients.

Northeast and Great Lakes lead while Sunbelt struggles

Annual gains were concentrated in states where chronic undersupply has collided with relative affordability. Illinois led with 6.9% year-over-year growth, followed by Rhode Island (6.4%), Connecticut (6.0%), New Jersey (5.1%), and Ohio (4.9%).

Accelerating metro markets included Cleveland, Albany, N.Y., Providence, R.I.-Mass., Greensboro, N.C., and St. Louis, Mo.-Ill. — markets where job growth, in-migration, and recent price resets have reinforced demand.

Resource-dependent and former pandemic boom states tell a different story. Washington fell 1.0% year over year, Wyoming declined 0.7%, and Texas dropped 0.4%, with Hawaii and Utah posting slight losses.

Six states in total recorded negative annual appreciation.