WHITEHALL — From the highest point of Whitehall Sands, the Cat bulldozers and excavators shaping the golf course below looked like tiny yellow toys. Derrick Bushman pointed out the church steeples of Independence, six miles away.

It’s difficult to adequately describe the majestic scale of the course, under construction in, around and above the reclaimed Hi Crush frac sand mine in rural western Wisconsin. Whitehall Sands could very well become one of the most photographed courses in America, but not a single photo will do it justice.

I toured the nascent public course last week with Bushman, who along with his brother Mitchell and architect Jay Blasi are building an 18-hole wonder that will serve as the western gateway to great golf on the state’s interior — Sand Valley, SentryWorld and points east (Kohler Golf) and south (Erin Hills).

I’ve been accused of being hyperbolic when writing about great golf courses. So be it. I have played more than 500 courses and walked nearly 100 others while covering major championships and PGA Tour events, and I have never seen anything remotely close in scale to Whitehall Sands.

whitehall-gd1.jpg

Derrick Bushman points to several holes under construction at Whitehall Sands.

Wisconsin.Golf photo / GARY D’AMATO

Start with the dramatic topography of the Driftless Area and throw in a quarry with a massive 90-foot wall as the centerpiece, and you get something Lee Wybranski would paint in his dreams. I must have said “wow” 100 times as Bushman took me up and around the mine in his pickup truck, which worked hard to navigate the climbs.

“I think you’ve hit on something,” Blasi said when we talked by phone. “The scale of the property is extremely dramatic and unlike anything else in golf. There are a lot of interesting features.”

Blasi, who grew up in Madison and is a University of Wisconsin graduate, served as project architect at Chambers Bay, helping transform another former sand-and-gravel mine into the course that played host to the 2015 U.S. Open. He also led the renovations at SentryWorld and will be back in 2027 to tweak the course in advance of more USGA championships.

Whitehall Sands is his first new build in Wisconsin.

whitehall-gd5.jpg

The sun rises over the 90-foot quarry wall at Whitehall Sands.

Wisconsin.Golf photo / GARY D’AMATO

whitehall-gd3.jpg

A view from what will be the back tee on the par-3 eighth hole at Whitehall Sands. It’ll be an 85-yard carry to the top of the quarry wall and the green beyond. 

Wisconsin.Golf photo / GARY D’AMATO

“This piece of land is really special,” he said. “You can probably hear it in my voice. This is a really, really special opportunity.”

Whitehall Sands is located between the small towns of Whitehall (pop. 1,614) and Independence (pop. 1,498), about 40 miles south of Eau Claire. It’s 2 hours from the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport and about 3½ hours from Milwaukee.

“We expect two-thirds to three-quarters of our play to come from the west,” Bushman said. “Sand Valley gets two-thirds to three-quarters of its play from Chicago. We’ll catch the people flying in to Minneapolis. A lot of people will play here and go on to Sand Valley.”

The facility will consist of the 18-hole course, a nine-hole short course and a putting course, plus on-site lodging.

“There’s land for future courses, but one step at a time,” Bushman said. “If you don’t build a good one to start with, it doesn’t matter.”

Green fees will be in the $200 range, which is not outrageous when compared with fees at similar upscale public facilities.

“It kind of has to be,” Bushman said, noting the cost of moving massive amounts of earth and redistributing sand found in pockets across the 230-acre property. “We’re actually tearing it down because it’s too extreme. We have to make it playable.”

Blasi called Whitehall Sands a “complicated build.”

“In some instances, all of the ingredients are there and the process is pretty simple,” he said. “Sand Valley is all sand and nice terrain, so your job there is to find holes, shape them and seed them. Here, we kind of have to build the golf course twice. This year, we’re building the course in the dirt, getting it shaped. Next year, we have to harvest all that sand and spread it like a blanket across the golf course, get the irrigation installed and get it grassed. And then open sometime in 2028. Obviously, all that is weather-dependent. There’s a lot to do.”

whitehall-gd4.jpg

Derrick Bushman points to a feature on the Whitehall Sands routing.

Wisconsin.Golf photo / GARY D’AMATO

Whitehall Sands will measure a bit more than 7,000 yards from the tips; par will be 71. The course concludes with an interesting stretch — just one par-4 over the last six holes (3-3-5-4-3-5).

The short par-4 seventh hole will feature an infinity green perched on the edge of a steep ridge, with the quarry wall looming in the distance. Go 10 yards long, and you’ll need a Sherpa to retrieve your ball.

“It’s a fun green spot,” Blasi said. “The analogy would be like playing along an ocean or Lake Michigan, so (the green) is like an island in the water. You have that infinity feel, but you’re also looking at the wall in the distance.”

The back tee on the par-3 eighth hole will require a carry from the edge of a ridge over a canyon to a green beyond the quarry wall. The hole will measure 185 yards and the carry is only 85 yards or so, but the visual intimidation is off the charts. Are there scarier par-3s? Maybe, but none comes to mind.

“The carry doesn’t matter because it’s short, but it looks like it matters,” Bushman said. “It gets in your head. The (green) is 100 yards behind that.”

Blasi noted that only the back tee will require the over-the-canyon shot. In a merciful nod to higher handicappers, other tees will be placed atop the quarry wall. Just don’t slice.

Pull Quote

“Growing up in Wisconsin and knowing this is what I wanted to do my whole life, it’s always been a dream to do work in Wisconsin. Over the last 10 years, Wisconsin has become the epicenter of public golf in the United States. You see other people get their opportunities, and they’ve all done a tremendous job. But, yes, I’ve long dreamed of having my shot.”

– Architect Jay Blasi

Whitehall Sands will be seeded with fescue in the fairways and bentgass on the greens and will play firm and fast. Fescue typically doesn’t do well in the Midwest; Erin Hills, for example, opened with fescue fairways but converted to bentgrass.

“We’re going to push the (turf) technology,” Bushman said. “Grass gets better every year.”

Because fescue does not tolerate cart traffic, Whitehall Sands will primarily be a walking course. The Bushmans hope to recruit youths from the nearby towns to populate a caddie program. The course will be a challenging walk, though, so there will be limited cart rounds.

“Derrick and I very much share the outlook on what great golf is,” Blasi said. “We’re both walkers and prefer walking courses. We want the walking culture to be the dominant culture and we want to have a caddie program and try to help the town that way. We want that to be the spirit and ethos of the place.

“But if you’re 100 percent walking, you eliminate a segment of the golfing population, so the plan is to have some number of cart rounds available per day. What do we think that number is? Ultimately, that probably will evolve over time.”

Blasi actually was working with Hi Crush Inc. after the mine filed for bankruptcy in 2020. Tim Lambrecht was the company’s chief financial officer and was in charge of trying to figure out what to do with the abandoned mine.

“Tim knew about Chambers Bay and he knew about Streamsong (a multi-course resort in central Florida) as mine exclamation projects,” Blasi said. “Tim found out I was from Wisconsin. We were working with Hi Crush and trying to figure out how to make it work. At some point in 2021, we felt like we were on the 1-yard line. I was pretty devastated when the opportunity slipped through my hands.”

According to two sources, Greg Norman went behind Blasi’s back and approached the mine owners with a proposal to turn Hi Crush into a multi-course resort, similar to Sand Valley. But that proposal never went anywhere, and the Bushmans, retired potato farmers from the Stevens Point area, bought the property in 2025.

Derrick Bushman is a course rater for Golfweek and had gotten to know Blasi, who helps the magazine with its rating program and hosts rater retreats.

“I probably met Derrick at one of those events 10 or 15 years ago,” Blasi said. “We kind of stayed in touch.”

Call it serendipity. After watching David McLay Kidd, Tom Doak and Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw get the design jobs at Sand Valley, Blasi is grateful for this opportunity.

“Growing up in Wisconsin and knowing this is what I wanted to do my whole life, it’s always been a dream to do work in Wisconsin,” he said. “Over the last 10 years, Wisconsin has become the epicenter of public golf in the United States. You see other people get their opportunities, and they’ve all done a tremendous job. But, yes, I’ve long dreamed of having my shot.”

He’s got it now, on a spectacular piece of ground. When he’s finished, Whitehall Sands promises to be a one-off golf experience. And that’s not hyperbole.