The Dallas Stars take the ice for the first period of an NHL hockey game against the New York Islanders at American Airlines Center on Sunday, Oct. 25, 2026, in Dallas.

The Dallas Stars take the ice for the first period of an NHL hockey game against the New York Islanders at American Airlines Center on Sunday, Oct. 25, 2026, in Dallas.

Smiley N. Pool/The Dallas Morning News

The Stars of Willow Bend? Not so fast … 

Shock and awe at Tuesday’s election results nationwide was not limited to candidates being voted in and out of office. Who knew how badly Plano doesn’t want the Stars in its backyard? 

Allow me, at least for a few days, to revitalize hope that the hockey team that has made its home in downtown Dallas (or uptown Dallas, if you insist) will find a way to stay where it belongs. There are ways this can happen, and they make a heck of a lot of sense for the city and for Stars owner Tom Gaglardi, but let’s get to what didn’t happen first. 

Article continues below this ad

I grew up in Richardson. It was a much larger suburb of Dallas than Plano during my days of matriculating through the RISD. Needless to say, that changed in overwhelming fashion over the last half century. During that time, Plano has done everything it could to rebrand itself as a mini-Dallas. Find a good restaurant in Big D, and Plano has replicated it somewhere within two miles of Legacy Drive. 

So I was under the impression — the Stars obviously were, too — that Plano would jump at the opportunity to house a professional sports team. A good one, at that. The proposition on Tuesday’s ballot did not ask Plano residents to suffer an increase in sales tax (as Arlington has done for past stadiums). It did not raise property taxes, either. All the new revenues were to be raised on rental cars, hotels and hikes in parking and ticket prices for events at the new Shops of Willow Bend venue. 

With those options on the table to replace what has been a largely failed indoor shopping mall (other than NorthPark, aren’t they all?) for decades, Plano voted down the Stars, 54.6% to 45.4%. 

Gaglardi’s response to me Wednesday morning: “We’ll figure it out.’’ 

Related: Plano voters rejected Dallas Stars arena funding under Proposition A. What happens now?

Article continues below this ad

The Plano mayor said in a statement there are other options. Stars CEO Brad Alberts has been steadfast in insisting the Stars are Plano-bound and done with Dallas. Most of that thinking is based on the idea that the Stars don’t make much in the way of revenue on the shops and restaurants around the American Airlines Center, which is the new “must have” for the modern billionaire sports owner who can’t get enough.  

Alberts said Wednesday he wasn’t ready to comment on the vote. I will happily do it for him.  

Here’s how the Stars, who messed up this situation in their squabble with the Mavericks over arena revenues, can benefit and remain in the AAC: 

When the lease expires for both teams in 2031, the Center Operating Committee can buy the AAC for $1 million. It’s something that was put into the contract when Tom Hicks and Ross Perot Jr. basically couldn’t agree on much of anything. Both teams held a 50-50 share. But the lawsuit that the Mavericks won gave them the rights to the COC.  

So even though Mavs owner Patrick Dumont doesn’t want to remain in the AAC, he has a very valuable bargaining chip to play. On top of that, one result of Tuesday’s Democratic landslide is that casino gambling will almost certainly be taken to the Texas voters in the near future. It was never happening with the previous administration as Dumont and his Sands allies had learned. That could fundamentally change where the Mavericks want to play. 

Article continues below this ad

The proposed Valley View mall site is not an ideal spot under these circumstances. Stand-alone casinos have been less successful around the country than those situated near a downtown or an entertainment district. Does that bring the City Hall site or somewhere else near downtown back into play? 

Putting those major chips aside for the moment, the Mavs can use their ownership of the AAC in 2031 to funnel it to the city, which in turn can use it to keep the Stars in place. Being able to redevelop the interior into a more hockey-friendly environment would be a nice enticement for Gaglardi. So would not having to spend $400 million of his own money to develop the Plano project. And who knows if that number didn’t just go up in the wake of Plano’s rejection of the city’s $3 billion development proposal? 

Gaglardi has even made moves around the AAC, buying the parking lot west of the arena. Who knows what he has in mind there? But as the lone or primary sports team occupying the building, the Stars could reconfigure (i.e. fewer suites) to a more appropriate NHL model. 

There are lots of moving parts. I have a hunch that when Plano’s Deputy City Manager Doug McDonald said not long ago that there might be some property value decreases for a short time after the mall is leveled, that sent voters racing to the “no” side even after the Stars had spent $1 million pushing people to vote “yes.” 

Article continues below this ad

So today’s very definitive answer is that I have no idea what’s going to happen over the next five years. But I do know the City of Dallas has options that did not exist before Plano said a resounding “no,” and they’re certainly not all bad for Gaglardi and the Dallas Stars.