This week’s gross challenge really shows why a cast full of normies makes for better television.
Photo: Euan Cherry/NBC
While we continue to suffer from a lost eighteen minutes, this episode was a fun one. The players got one Traitor, and they are celebrating at a candlelit dinner. Everyone got fancy, which normally means some insane wardrobe choices from our D-list celebrity cast, but since these are low-key normie influencers, everyone just looks nice. There is Scottish food! It includes Scotch eggs, which are surprisingly good. Joe tells everyone he threw up a Scotch egg in Vegas, ruining the food for all. I’ve never been to Vegas, but it doesn’t give me Scotch egg vibes. Is that a Vegas restaurant staple? Was there a mass Vegas Scottish migration? Is there a surplus of Presbyterian churches in Las Vegas?
Joe is in a slightly elevated Hawaiian shirt and a blazer. Almost everyone else is in tartan, so I want to know more about his decision-making process when packing. People start sharing what they’re proud of so far and what the money would mean to them. Abbey B, who must have traveled outside the timeline and read my critiques of her from last week, really shows up this episode. She talks about being home most of the time because she takes care of her daughter, and how it’s very isolating. Abbey did the show to do something for herself, which Kriste fully supports. The enormous jump from medically complex caretaker to “what if I went to Scotland to do a game show?” is funny, but I do also support you, Abbey B. Most parents, when they talk about doing something for themselves for once, go get a massage.
Morgan is proud of herself for helping to get a Traitor. Morgan, I love you and all the videos you post, but you really did not want to vote for Tomica. Shane talks about wanting to help his family financially after the death of his sister. Aghhh. I don’t know what the fix is for this show, because when it’s D-list people, they don’t really care about the money and don’t try enough in the challenges. When it’s your average person who has a great need for the money because our economy and social system are broken, it’s a bummer. It feels more like The Hunger Games when it’s like, “Will Shane continue to constantly fear not being able to provide for his family? Or will he win this game show that is a mix of luck and skill?” Someone (the government) give Shane and his family enough money that they’re not living in fear! Maybe by taking some money from the people who have enough money for thousands of lifetimes but will only be able to use it in one!
Okay, anyway, so yeah, this bums me out. The Traitors are feeling bad for betraying all their new friends. Can we make this game more game-like and have it wreak less emotional devastation? Or is the devastation part of the allure? Alan hears my plea and emerges from the shadows to invite the players to a nightcap and a deadly game with the Traitors.
We learn that Joe and Katie were given a task two hours earlier. They need to poison another player’s chalice. The players will be able to trade, so it is indeed a Wallace Shawn in The Princess Bride moment, and my reference to that in a previous recap was made too early. This is much more 1:1. Joe wants to poison Victor’s cup, but Katie thinks Victor would try to trade. That’s for sure correct. I think they should poison Wyatt since he’s part of the Victor voting bloc, but no one listens to me.
At The Great Poisoning, Alan tells the players the rules, which include that a Traitor cannot be murdered, so if they drink, there will be no murder. Ben and Victor are suspicious of Kriste for immediately grabbing her chalice. Why? Victor tries to switch with Joe, Katie, and Abbey, but no one will switch with him. Even if Joe and Katie weren’t Traitors, they could fairly assume that Victor would be poisoned. At the last moment, Shane asks Joe to swap, which he does. We will learn who was poisoned at tomorrow’s breakfast.
The next morning, we find that the hilarious Morgan (look, if you haven’t seen her vids, you just have to trust me) is no more. Morgan, I will miss you, but you brought nothing to the table other than your kind and attentive demeanor. To do a quick cast check-in, those remaining are Abbey, Ben, Clyde, Jay, Joe, Katie, Kriste, Shane, Victor, Wyatt. Is that three women and seven men? Yeah. Did we start 50/50? Also yeah. Hm. Interesting.
The mission that day is at the insect cabin. Do you remember the insect cabin? Beetles and mealworms everywhere. Well, it’s back, and now it’s haunted. Alan informs the players that the cabin is haunted by spirits in search of the treasured items they left behind. Once the players are inside, the spirits will call (on the phone) and tell them about the item. They have to find the correct item and hand it to the spirit outside the door within the allotted time. If they fail, the player handing over the item will be dragged from the cabin and removed from the mission. There is also a shield at stake.
Everyone comes in wearing safety goggles. The first spirit asks for a spicy home brew under the floorboards. This is where the game is more fun than I expected (much like the chalice challenge!), because when they pull up the floor, there are so many bottles. Everyone starts tasting the varied, apparently disgusting, bottles. “Not spicy,” says Abbey B. “EVERYONE’S GOING TO HAVE DIFFERENT PERCEPTIONS OF SPICY,” Katie shouts. They finally find the correct one, and Shane hands it over to the spirit. They get $9,000 in exchange.
Clue two is about a wedding outfit. We get the classic beetles and mealworm drop from the ceiling. There are so many white outfits, most of which at the outset look like wedding dresses. Jay hands one over and gets taken by the spirit. The third call is about the shield, which is inside one of the teddy bears in the toybox. VICTOR finds it (boooooooooo) and hides it. The third call is for an amethyst necklace that got flushed down a toilet. Now it’s Abbey’s time to shine. For once, someone’s career is actually paying off. Abbey is a nurse. Abbey does not give one fuck about diving headfirst into a disgusting, filthy toilet and wading through a thick brown liquid to find a necklace for a pretend ghost. She finds it, and they bank another $9,000. No one kill Abbey after this.
At the castle, we don’t have enough time for a roundtable, but we get pre-roundtable chatter. People are suspicious about no one finding a shield. Victor looks squirrelly. Kriste thinks Wyatt is a Traitor and Victor is trying to get people onto Joe. Other people think it’s Kriste. Victor is frustrated that more people are not on his side despite him being right. That is fair, Victor, but in their defense, you are super annoying.
Who would I vote for on Traitors? It’s hard to judge what one would do without having the insider knowledge, because who knows the full context of what’s happening in that castle, but based on what’s presented, here are my picks:
No Insider Knowledge: Ooo, this week is more fun since we don’t know which way they’re going to vote. With the knowledge currently presented, I think I would vote for Kriste, leaving two women in the castle. Internalized misogyny is a thing.
Yes Insider Knowledge: If not Victor, then Wyatt. I’m glad someone is targeting Wyatt now, but do the Traitors even have a strategy here? Or is the strategy “Don’t get found out”? That’s not a strategy, guys!
Sign Up for the Vulture Newsletter
Entertainment news, for the pop-culture obsessed.
Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice