With the City Council holding a key vote Monday on the massive Midway Rising project, San Diegans need reassurances that the developer can be trusted — and that Mayor Todd Gloria and the City Council can be trusted to do full due diligence on key details.

In September 2022, all three competitors for this Sports Arena redevelopment proposed mixed-use buildings that were 86 feet high instead of the 65-foot height limit in the current zoning because that height would be the most economical to build. I support the increased height.

Midway Rising could have asked for a community commercial zone, which allows buildings up to 100 feet and, with the state’s affordable-housing density bonus, enough homes for the project. Instead, it wants a mixed-use zone that would allow 240-foot buildings across the entire site — and twice the building area shown in its plans. It is also seeking a specific plan that would allow 250-foot buildings on 10% of the site.

Yet none of the mixed-use buildings shown in the project are even half that height. The developers say that they want additional flexibility. Why? Flexibility for what? Are they planning future changes after they get council approval?

Midway Rising is also asking to remove the Community Plan Implementation Overlay Zone designation, which requires public and environmental review for any future changes to the project. Midway Rising claims that the overlay zone is not necessary because it will comply with the mixed-use zoning and specific plan that the council will be approving.

But Midway Rising officials are not pointing out that the extremely broad and flexible mixed-use rezone and specific plan would allow more than double the building area and height that they are currently showing in their plans. With their proposed elimination of the overlay zone, any such changes could be processed through a ministerial building permit with no public review. What do they have in mind that they are not telling the council or the public?

The new mixed-use zone could allow approximately 10.5 million square feet of building area, far more than originally proposed. What would the additional traffic impact be?

Discussion of height has focused on 250-foot buildings on 10% of the site. But the mixed-use zone would also allow 240-foot buildings everywhere else. Do the mayor and City Council understand the potential additional environmental impacts that could result from the flexibility the developers have in the new mixed-use rezone and specific plan?

None of these impacts were analyzed in the project’s Environmental Impact Report.

I recommend the mayor and City Council seek these safeguards:

1. Approve a rezone and a specific plan that allow only what is shown on the proposed plan or put conditions on the project requiring that it not exceed the currently shown height and building area.

2. Maintain the Community Plan Implementation Overlay Zone currently in place to require public and environmental review for any future changes.

3. If the city lets Midway Rising build 250-foot towers of luxury units, it should require the developer to build the 250 middle-income homes it originally promised and later dropped.

Ziebarth is a retired architect who volunteered for 27 years as a member of the Citizen Advisory Committee for the Zoning Code Update and is the recipient of a Lifetime Achievement Award from the American Institute of Architects San Diego. He lives in Point Loma.