On the first Saturday morning of the school year, Horacio and three of his children — Margoth, 8; Maithais, 6; and Noah, 5 — walked up 139th Street in the Bronx toward the charter school the kids attend. At the top of the hill, a pair of gray doors (which have since been painted blue) swung open, and the family stepped inside. “I’ll be back around 2,” he told the safety officers sitting behind a desk in the lobby. One was Ellen Coleman, whom everyone knows as Ms. Ellen. She leaned back in her chair, grinned, and greeted each kid by name. “You sure you don’t want to leave them for longer?” she asked. “We’re getting dinner.”

The school, called Strive Charter School, opened in August. It was founded not with a lofty pedagogical mandate or unique classroom-behavior strategy but with the goal of making life significantly easier for working parents. The founder, Eric Grannis, takes pride in Strive’s academic offerings but knows that the school’s main selling point is its hours of operation. Horacio learned about Strive over the summer, when he was handed a pamphlet at the entrance to a subway station. “Open from 7am to 7pm,” the paper read. “7 days a week, 12 months a year.”

During the regular school year — from September to late June — class is in session five days a week, from 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The extended part of the schedule (early mornings, evenings, weekends, and July and August) is optional and free of charge. Those hours will be filled with a variety of programming: tutoring, sports, art, music, viewings in a planetarium, and free play. In the summer, the full week will run like a classic day camp with some additional academic components, including required reading periods, tutoring, and enrichment. Dropping off and picking up a child outside of regular school hours, according to Grannis, should be as simple as stopping by Starbucks for a preordered cup of coffee.

In Strive, Grannis has embraced a dual role for schools as both centers of education and an integral form of child care that many teachers and administrators have long resisted. But the vast majority of working parents in America depend on schools to do their jobs, and Grannis believes educational institutions can and should do even more to help parents stay employed. Across the United States, there are about 23 million kids unable to access after-school programming whose families would enroll them if they had the option. And in New York City, the demand for free or affordable after-hours programming far outstrips the availability. In the 2023–24 school year, there were around 150,000 complimentary after-school slots for the over 643,000 children enrolled in the city’s K–8 public schools. The city comptroller’s office estimates a shortfall of more than 390,000 seats next school year. What’s more, around 30 percent of employed people work over the weekend, which makes Saturday and Sunday child care a necessity too. Strive, which serves grades K–4, aims to bridge these gaps and then some while sticking to a standard public-school budget.

Grannis started the school with assistance from his wife, Eva Moskowitz, co-founder and CEO of New York City’s largest and arguably most controversial charter-school network, Success Academy. The two met in high school and dated through college. He worked for Success Academy early on and explains, with some enjoyment, that when his wife was hired to lead the organization, his first and only recommendation for her was to fire him. (Grannis still does pro-bono work for Success Academy.) Moskowitz has spent years openly criticizing the city’s teachers union, and Grannis shares her sense of embattled disdain. Both say they are looking to serve students and this task has been impeded by complacency and bureaucracy. “This is how it is,” he wrote atop an email exchange he forwarded me between himself and the city Department of Education. “They always make things impossible for us.”

To create Strive, Success Academy’s board voted to transfer one of their charter-school licenses to Strive’s board of trustees, whose members Grannis had recruited. The move was then approved by the SUNY board of trustees — one of the governing bodies overseeing charter schools in the city. The transfer was subsequently challenged in court by the United Federation of Teachers, who argued that the license transfer violated a citywide cap on the number of charter schools in operation. Grannis, unbothered, expects a judge will throw out the case soon. With the school now open, he is focused on the practical challenges of delivering on the promises he made to the parents who took a risk on an untested enterprise and enrolled.

“I work anywhere from five to seven days a week,” Horacio said, straddling the doorstep at Strive that Saturday morning. “And even if it’s five, the weekdays are so crazy. Weekends are my only real time with the kids.” But on Saturday, he was using the school’s open-door policy to keep his older kids busy while he accomplished some errands with his youngest son. He just wanted a little bit of time. “Whatever you need,” said Ms. Ellen. “You run your errands. We’ve got them up there doing art.”

In the 19th century, the school calendar varied widely across America and even within individual states. Schools in one district might run for three months of the year, while those just a town over were in session for ten months. But one commonality all schools shared, wrote historian Kenneth Gold in his essay “The Myth of Summer Vacation and the Agrarian Calendar,” was that they were open in the summer. In fact, in many urban schools, attendance numbers during those months were the highest of the year. It is a fallacy that the modern-day public-school schedule — with its long summer break, weekends off, and early-afternoon dismissal time — came about to encourage seasonal farmwork. In reality, as the century progressed, the modern schedule arose from what Gold describes as a perceived “inferiority of summer term teachers” (the vast majority of whom were women); a series of summer illness outbreaks and heat waves that drove wealthy urbanites to flee cities for country homes; the need to expand, construct, and repair more school buildings as the city’s population grew; and eventually, a decline in student attendance, and a desire for standardization. By 1867, summer vacations in New York City were seven weeks long.

School leaders did worry about teachers’ skills growing soft over the break (concerns over a student “summer slide” didn’t take shape until the 1920s) but eventually justified it as a time for renewal and professional training. Summer education conferences flourished. By the dawn of the 20th century, the school-calendar model had become largely standardized: “A 180-day school held during the fall, winter, and spring; punctuated by a 2-3-month summer vacation,” Gold wrote.

By 1918, every state had some form of legislation making school compulsory, though what compulsory meant varied greatly. At nearly the same moment, early versions of after-school programs began springing up across New York, especially in immigrant neighborhoods. Settlement houses provided food and activities for children in lower Manhattan. A playground movement in the late 1800s prompted the construction of outdoor play spaces often overseen by city-employed supervisors who organized games and saw to the children’s safety. Starting in the 1930s, the city created what has become one of the largest publicly funded in-school after-school programs in the country. The school day began, almost universally, at 9 a.m. until the 1960s and 1970s, when some districts began to move the drop-off time earlier to accommodate parents who needed to commute to work afterward.

Schools across the United States have experimented with the calendar for decades, although none has gone as far as Grannis. In 2018, about 3 percent of public schools in the U.S. maintained year-round schedules. The Center for American Progress has been advocating for a school day that runs from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. for at least a decade (though without an even earlier drop-off and later pickup option, this tweak would still leave most parents scrambling for child care). KIPP Public Charter Schools used to have a program that required all enrolled students to attend school one Saturday a month, but it has mostly been phased out. No school has attempted the one-stop shop Grannis envisions. The closest competitor to Strive in New York City is the Harlem Children’s Zone charter-school network. It has an academic calendar that stretches from September into late June and offers a summer program in July and August, all in the hopes that truncated breaks will help limit learning loss. It also offers free after-school programming until 7 p.m. Monday through Thursday and until 6 p.m. on Friday. The schools aren’t open on the weekends, but they do offer Saturday programming at select central HCZ community centers. But overall, schools in the U.S. are almost uniformly closed over the weekends, which makes Strive’s Saturday and Sunday hours arguably its boldest, most appealing feature.

On the first Saturday of the school year, I followed Maithais and Margoth into Strive’s weekend programming. Grannis had warned me that he was still working out the kinks. For example, there had been problems with a missed bus stop, and the kitchen was still not operational; meals were sandwiches and other packaged foods that didn’t require cooking. The building Strive occupies is owned by St. Luke’s Catholic Church, which doesn’t allow the school to use the space on Sundays, and Grannis was still searching for an alternative. The DOE, he complained in an email, had been opaque and unhelpful. (In October, Grannis reported that the kitchen was now functional and that he had found a likely home for his Sunday programming— a Success Academy campus.) Grannis has hired a soccer coach for the weekends, but he’ll only work on Sundays. There will also be basketball, eventually, but the school’s gym has not yet been set up.

So far, Grannis has hired a staff of 40 teachers and assistants. Especially for experienced teachers, the school’s salaries are markedly lower than in New York City public schools. There, veteran teachers can earn more than $128,000 per year, and entry-level salaries range from $71,314 for those with no experience and no master’s degree to $80,166 for those starting with a master’s degree. Strive, by contrast, offers full-time assistant teachers $60,000 per year for 50 hours per week and $80,000 per year to lead classroom teachers with two years of experience; each subsequent year of experience adds only $2,000. And importantly, teachers at Strive are required to be at school for 210 instructional days, as opposed to the standard public school’s 180. The remainder of the extended hours at Strive are staffed largely by teaching assistants paid about $25 per hour. “There are lots of people who have experience in the world of education who don’t have Harvard degrees or a B.A., necessarily,” says Grannis. At most DOE schools, teachers leading after-hours programming or summer enrichment earn an additional $63.04 an hour. Its salary structure has all but ensured the Strive faculty will be inexperienced compared with that of a typical public school.

Grannis estimates that keeping the school open on Saturday and Sunday will cost Strive around $5,000 each week, or $250,000 over the course of the year. When I visited, Grannis pulled out his phone to check the math and informed me that, working from a budget of around $9 million a year, weekends will take up just 3 percent of his overall budget if he can attract 325 students to the school. “If we stick to the current enrollment,” he told me, “I will have to do some fundraising.” A shrinking student population is one of the most pressing difficulties city schools face.

Before I arrived that morning, Grannis sent me a barrage of emails. Among them was a message warning that attendance might not be high. “I honestly don’t care if you report that attendance was low because my view has always been that the point is to give parents optionality,” Grannis wrote. “Even if only a relatively small number of children come on any given optional day, that may be totally critical to that family.”

When Horacio arrived with his children at 9:15 a.m., there was a steady trickle of parents coming in and out, early proof that the demand Grannis predicted is real. One mother came in asking to order a school shirt for her son, another to retrieve a student who had gotten sick. “He’s not feeling his best,” Ms. Ellen told me sympathetically. A pile of boxes sat near her desk —all packages of books and LEGO sets Grannis had ordered. Myasia Ennis, the head of Strive’s after-school programming at the time (she has since left, and three lead teachers have taken over the project), came in and out of the lobby, keeping tabs on everyone.

Margoth and Maithais stood uncertainly in front of Ms. Ellen’s desk, both wearing their Strive polo shirts, as their father chatted with other parents. Margoth was quiet and wide-eyed as she followed Ennis, looking slightly unsure about what she had gotten herself into.

The first-floor hallway was quiet. The kindergarten classes were brightly decorated and carpeted; purchasing the rugs was a particular preoccupation for Grannis over the summer. Down the hall was the activity room, where the younger children built block towers and worked with Play-Doh under the supervision of Emprise Williams, a first-grade teaching aide and weekend teacher who sat on a chair at a slight remove. “You guys are doing great,” Williams told her charges. “Take a minute and kiss your brains.”

As Margoth settled in, an older group of children played Uno and drew with markers. She sat quietly on the rug while a teacher’s aide played name games with the kids. A group of girls watched in awe as Margoth pulled a pack of cheddar fries out of her backpack. “You got cheddar fries?” asked one girl, starting to play with Margoth’s hair. Margoth nodded.

“You’re lucky,” said the girl. She introduced herself as Emma. Her friend, she said, was named Phoenix.

The girls discussed whether they liked the school so far. They had heard rumors about a basketball program and soccer.

“I like it here,” said one of the girls. “I might just come every day.”

“You’re joking,” said Emma. “Who wants to wake up at 6 every morning?”

They squealed in horror at the thought. Then the aide told them it was time for lunch.

I first met Grannis in March in a coffee shop in South Harlem not far from his home. By the time I arrived, Grannis had parked his bike outside, ordered breakfast, and set out a copy of the book he co-wrote with Moskowitz, A+ Parenting, to give me. Grannis is an ideas man in the classical mold. He has theories about classroom layouts and teaching math, about meal plans, student engagement, and the value of the movie musical 1776. In a near-ubiquitous button-down and slacks, he doesn’t look like a fitness buff, but he is, in fact, an avid biker. Even when he’s not exercising, he is often slightly out of breath from either enthusiasm or activity.

Strive’s educational philosophy was shaped by Grannis’s own experience, what he likes to call “the tasting tour of American pedagogy” (or, more accurately, elite education). He went to the famous West Side Montessori School for nursery school and P.S. 145 and then Collegiate for elementary school. He transferred to the Bank Street School during middle school and attended Exeter and later Stuyvesant for high school. His fondest memories, he says, were at Bank Street, where he outpaced his classmates in math and the teacher gave him and another classmate a textbook so they could study independently. It’s an experience he says he wants to recreate for students at Strive.

Much of the curriculum Strive is using has already been tested at Success Academy, which has a track record of high scores on state tests but also a reputation for harsh discipline strategies and a fair amount of attrition as students move into later grades. The school’s math curriculum is based on a series called Context for Learning Mathematics and focuses on mathematical understanding rather than rote memorization. (Grannis happens to know the creator and author of Context for Learning, Cathy Fosnot, and on one of my visits to the school over the summer, she was there training teachers herself.) The literacy program, Grannis says, embraces a spirit of independent inquiry he hopes will set Strive apart.

The first principal Grannis hired, Rebecca Goodsell, previously worked as an assistant principal at Success Academy, but she left halfway through the summer to tend to a family emergency. Her replacement, Shaniqua Sonnee, was formerly the director of enrichment at Hunter College Elementary School, a highly selective K–12 school in New York. Sonnee has recruited several of her former co-workers from Hunter to lead, among other things, Strive’s science classroom and after-school programming. Grannis also hired a recent college graduate to help him build an app for families, called Strive Arrive, that he says will eventually enable parents to log on and alert the school they are on their way to drop off or pick up their child. Through location tracking, the app will estimate the parent’s time of arrival and, theoretically, with around ten minutes’ advance notice, enable staff to pack up the child’s backpack and get them to the front door for a seamless pickup. “Then they can just walk right out when you arrive,” Grannis told me. So far, the app is not fully operational and the school is handling arrival and dismissal in the usual analog way.

“What they’re offering us has been priceless,” Daniel Ramirez, a father of a Strive first-grader, told me over the phone when I asked how his daughter’s first month has gone. “This idea with this school, it’s just brilliant. And it’s not only brilliant, it’s considerate. It’s considerate of the lives of hard-working people.”

In the months I spent following Grannis as he got Strive off the ground, all of the parents I spoke with who were considering the school faced formidable familial and logistical challenges. More than one had to quit a job over the summer to care for their children. They told me about their children’s strengths, struggles, and interests; the quirks of their work schedules; and the impossibility of efficiently managing their days.

Ramirez lives in the Bronx and works in security in Yonkers, and he chose Strive after the charter school his daughter attended for kindergarten announced it would admit kids to the after-school program by lottery with no guarantee of admission. “My wife and I both work,” Ramirez told me. “I’m not in the business of ‘see if it happens or not.’ I need some certainty.” When a co-worker mentioned he was moving his daughter from Success Academy to Strive, Ramirez decided to follow suit. When I spoke to him in October, he was thrilled with his choice. “They give my daughter a lot of homework,” Ramirez told me. “And we are on top of what’s going on. We ask her a lot of questions. And Aria loves it. She loves her teachers already.” Ramirez and his wife have been using the school’s Saturday hours, although sparingly. “At the end of the day, she’s our child. She’s not the school’s child,” he said.

Raychelle, whose name has been changed to protect her children’s privacy, works a hybrid job in hospital administration. She moved back to the Bronx from upstate New York over the summer. “But working from home doesn’t mean the kids can stay with you. My mom used to help, but now my mom is older,” she explains. She found what she described as a perfect school for her son, who has autism, in the Bronx. But she wanted an academically rigorous fit for her 7-year-old daughter and knew she needed it to be convenient since she was handling both of her kids’ transportation to school herself.

A few weeks into the school year, Raychelle said she had come to love the Saturday program at Strive. Her daughter wanted to go every week, Raychelle told me. “She’s like, ‘No, I want to go to school. They have dance or soccer or Monopoly.’ One day, I was so proud, she was upset that I came to pick her up too early. She said, ‘Mom, I had four properties.’” But Raychelle also shared concerns about the school’s ability to smoothly deliver its curriculum and the meager class sizes in the older grades. “I worry about this learning process as they go through the kinks,” she told me. “I hope they can feed that gift that she has.” She confessed to me that she feels slightly guilty about picking a school primarily because it fits her own schedule, rather than her daughter’s interests and strengths. “That’s my greatest fear. I was up last night thinking about it. I couldn’t go to sleep thinking about it.”

Horacio, Margoth and Maithais’s dad, works in a bodega in the South Bronx. During our first conversation over the phone, someone in the background interrupted him, cursing. He politely asked me to excuse him. He put down the phone and I heard him telling the man to leave. “Get out of the store,” he said sternly. And then again, there was yelling. After some commotion, Horacio picked up the phone again. “I’m sorry for that,” he said.

Last year, as Horacio’s family went through a rough patch, his children did not attend school at all. “I’m just trying to create more stability for me and the children at the moment,” Horacio told me. “The best way we can is through education and keeping them busy.”

He believes in consistency. He believes that, while you may have all the talents in the world, you’re nothing without routine. He is proud of the fact that aside from a bout of the flu and hand, foot, and mouth disease, they’ve had perfect attendance at school this academic year. Horacio lives in a family shelter, where kids may not be left home without adult supervision. He is hoping to find housing somewhere in the South Bronx so his children can stay close to Strive.

He told me that his job as a parent — in addition to giving his kids love and a stable routine — is finding out what they excel at and encouraging them. He wants them to know how to be with other people in the real world, rather than online. Margoth loves to draw, so Horacio fosters it. His youngest, he predicts, will end up in construction or demolition because of his tendency to take things apart. “He’s my little bull in the china shop,” Horacio laughed. His middle child is, at the moment, obsessed with dinosaurs.

“I can see already that Strive is taking care of the academic needs that the babies have,” Horacio told me.

In an idealized America, parents would be available to collect their children when the school day ends and to then oversee their kids at home with the benevolent calm of the mothers of our imagined past, watching them play as the afternoon light dwindles, no iPads or Xboxes in sight. For real working parents, however, the search for child care — after school, on weekends, in the summer, when the babysitter calls out sick, when camp is too expensive — is perpetual and stressful.

Teachers may be wary of conflating education with child care; they may feel the association denigrates or mischaracterizes their expertise and impact. But as the pandemic and its exodus of mothers from the workforce demonstrated, schools function as the most widely used and most effective form of child care we have in America. The overlap of education and child care doesn’t have to look exactly like Strive. The program could be teacher-led or built through partnerships with community organizations. It could be implemented in established and better-funded public schools that give enrolled families more confidence in their infrastructure and academics. But Grannis’s notion to expand in-school child care into the weekends and summer is so intuitive that it’s hard to believe he’s the first to get it off the ground.

On Strive’s first free Saturday, lunch (sandwiches and fruit) was followed by recess. After that, Grannis gathered all the kids, younger and older, and had them help unpack the LEGOs he had ordered. The last student left at 7 p.m., after dinner. By the end of the day, just over 40 of the school’s around 200 students had passed through the doors. He sent an email afterward thanking parents for dropping off their kids and included a video of the unboxing. “We didn’t have a lot of formal programming because we haven’t gotten everything in place yet, so children engaged in a lot of informal play, but that can actually be very educational,” he wrote. “If you ask a class of students if any of them want to help with something, all of their hands shoot up. It is so important to give children opportunities to do work.”

There is a part of me that is loath to see children spending time in any single institution for a 12-hour day. Watching students go in and out of Strive on a Saturday was bittersweet; although they looked excited and their parents relieved, I was struck by the fact that none of these families could afford, as Grannis put it, to “buy time” with their children. “Lower-income parents can’t afford to free up their time the way more affluent families can,” Grannis told me when we first met as he explained why a school like Strive is necessary. Parents, for example, may not have the resources to move closer to their jobs or hire help for time-consuming chores, nor do many have the autonomy to set a work schedule that accommodates their children’s needs. In situations like these, a flexible and familiar school where children feel safe and comfortable is an obvious and ideal child-care solution. Unlike many charter schools in New York, Strive does not weed out kids and families unable to meet attendance expectations or strict homework requirements. Any child who wants to enroll at Strive is welcome (though Strive is currently unable to accommodate students with certain individualized education plans), and in fact, the school is seeking more students.

Grannis is aware of the challenges involved in keeping the school running and funded. While the parents and teachers I interviewed attributed the difficulties of the start of the year, including faculty resignations and facility problems, to growing pains, outsiders — especially those opposed to charter schools in general — have questioned the scrappiness of this kind of venture and the benefit of extending the presence of a new, untested school in any child’s life. There were moments when I, too, strongly questioned whether Grannis and Strive could succeed. On one sparsely attended school-tour day at Strive, the operation had the feel of a start-up venture. A welcome video for touring parents, played inside an inflatable planetarium, featured a Star Wars–style yellow scroll and AI avatars of then-principal Goodsell and her vice-principal. Grannis hired a video editor in the Ukraine to help him produce it. He told me Goodsell moved too much in the regular recorded version, rendering it unusable.

The parents I spoke with early in the year have had somewhat mixed experiences in the time since. By the end of October, Raychelle, the parent who had been worried about the school’s academics, had moved her daughter to another school. “It wasn’t a fit,” she told me. “But I still believe in the school’s mission. I’m still a fan.” Ramirez and Horacio, however, remain happy with their choice. Their kids are settling in, doing homework, and learning.

And within the school, Grannis’s optimism has proven contagious. With Sonnee, he has managed to recruit a staff of aides and teachers who, when I spoke with them, were overtly enthusiastic about the school’s aims. Strive’s assistant principal and science department chair, Andrea Coleman, told me she has arranged a partnership with the Bronx Zoo. “We’re going to do real data collection,” she said. “We’re trying to create the scientists of the future.” Williams, the weekend teacher, said she felt blessed to have found the place. Ms. Ellen told me her employer, a security company, tried to relocate her to another school, but she refused to go. When she’s at work, she likes to imagine how much a school like Strive would have helped when her own children were still at home.

With school well into its second month, Grannis says he has already stepped away from classroom operations, which are now in the hands of Sonnee and an assistant principal. Sonnee smiles patiently while he talks. “We work well together,” she told me as the two reviewed a color-coded weekly schedule. His focus now is on tracking enrollment, ordering supplies, and staying abreast of changes that need to be made. And now that his first school is up and running, Grannis has set his sights on expansion. He recently started discussions with another charter school interested in adopting the Strive model.

Related