The Jacksonville City Council approved, by a 10-8 vote, an incentive package that advocates hope will spur downtown development and bring a grocery store and new housing to the Northbank.
Ordinance 2026-541 will give the developer Gateway Jax $9.2 million in cash once the Pearl Square development is complete, along with $12 million from the Downtown Investment Authority, $7 million from the developer’s N8 Project, and $21.75 million in property tax credits in the form of REV grants phased out over 17 years. The developer insists upon public subsidy as a precondition to the build.
The grocery store, likely to be a Publix, would anchor a 259-unit apartment building along with other retail and provide downtown with the grocery store locals have wanted for many years.
Controversy clouded the vote, particularly over Amendment 3, which is expected to lower property tax collections by $200 million in 2027 and $300 million by 2028. The Finance Committee was deadlocked on the item last week.
“This notion that we’re going to save money only makes sense if we cancel these other projects,” said Republican Rory Diamond.
Republican Mike Gay noted the original $28 million cash ask was cut down to $9 million.
“It doesn’t make any sense,” Gay said, wondering why the developer wanted so much money in the first place and why the proposal had no affordable housing component.
Republican Ken Amaro said the developers had presented and fulfilled their plans, noting that, as property of the First Baptist Church, it previously didn’t generate property tax. Now, he said, it could “transform” Downtown.
“Scared money don’t make money,” said Democrat Rahman Johnson, borrowing language from Nino Brown.
Johnson called the $9.2 million a “couple of dimes” in the larger budget, dismissing concerns and arguing the project increases the tax base.
Republican Raul Arias noted that Jacksonville had given nearly $100 million in cash incentives to developers since 2023, when the current Council came in, arguing that policymakers aren’t “scared” but urging them to vote no on this.
Early in the meeting, City Council President Nick Howland lauded the “property tax relief” in the provision and said legislators were prepared to make adjustments and were already “serious about spending.”
The city’s general counsel will perform a legal review of the amendment, including what may come in the implementation session. Council auditors will also be compelled to consider impacts, including positive ones from a more robust property market. Council will convene November 30 in a special meeting to discuss those findings.
Republican Ron Salem voiced frustration that the city did not make budgetary provisions in case Amendment 3 passed, with Mayor Donna Deegan deciding to forestall budget adjustments until the FY 27-28 budget.
Salem also questioned the need for a “quality grocery store” downtown, noting that there is an ALDI on Market Street.
Gay also invoked Amendment 3, saying Council needed to be “wise and look at what the future holds.”
After the vote, Mayor Donna Deegan issued a statement.
“I’m grateful for the majority of City Council members who put Jacksonville first and voted to keep our momentum going. I also thank the DIA and Gateway Jax for maximizing the return on investment for taxpayers. The combination of a full-service grocery store and pharmacy with more retail and residents makes the next phase of Pearl Square a truly transformational project, one that will deliver hundreds of millions of dollars in commercial tax revenue that can be invested in neighborhoods across the city. A thriving downtown is good for the entire city, and this is an investment in our collective future.”

