Philadelphia police officers fired for misconduct have returned to their jobs with back pay, taxpayers have absorbed millions of dollars in disciplinary and civil rights-related costs, and the civilian oversight commission approved by voters still lacks authority to independently investigate complaints against officers.

Those issues were among the topics examined Tuesday as City Council scrutinized Philadelphia’s contract with Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 5 and questioned whether Mayor Cherelle Parker’s administration can secure stronger accountability measures in the next round of negotiations with the union.

“Every single one of them has reinstated the fired officer,” Citizens Police Oversight Commission Executive Director Tonya McClary testified, referring to eight arbitration awards published since the commission’s previous report.

The hearing, held under Resolution No. 260932 introduced by Council Majority Leader Katherine Gilmore Richardson, gave residents an opportunity to address police discipline, sexual harassment, public access to arbitration records and civilian investigative authority before the city and the union begin negotiations expected by the end of the year.

Gilmore Richardson’s Bill No. 200364, enacted six years ago, requires Council to publicly review the city’s proposed police contract before collective bargaining.

“When I drafted this legislation, my priority was to ensure the people who are most impacted by these decisions have an opportunity to share what they believe should be included in this process, what is working, where there are gaps and what they want to see moving forward,” Gilmore Richardson said.

The majority leader recalled the first hearing in November 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, when Philadelphians had their first opportunity to address the city’s police union contract. FOP President Roosevelt Poplar attended Tuesday’s proceedings and was available to answer questions.

Millions paid, officers reinstated

McClary cited investigative reporting showing Philadelphia paid approximately $7.2 million in back pay to reinstated officers between February 2023 and April 2026. She also reported that the city paid $40 million in civil rights lawsuit settlements related to police misconduct in fiscal year 2026.

She cited another $2.435 million contributed in fiscal 2024 to a police union legal services fund that is largely financed by the city.

“We are not only bearing the cost of a broken system, but the cost of the lawyers on both sides of the employment dispute,” McClary testified.

McClary said all eight arbitration awards published since the commission’s earlier report reinstated dismissed officers and were decided by an FOP-appointed arbitrator.

Councilmember Rue Landau questioned the effectiveness of the Police Termination Arbitration Board, created to reduce the number of fired officers who regain their jobs through arbitration.

Cara Leheny, acting director of the city’s Office of Employment and Labor Relations, disputed the completeness of Landau’s figures. She said the board had issued six awards since it began operating. Five officers were reinstated with reduced discipline, while a city-appointed arbitrator upheld one dismissal. Five additional cases were withdrawn by the union, leaving those dismissals intact.

Leheny said eight cases remain on hold, most because of pending criminal proceedings.

Sexual harassment case tests city’s authority

Councilmember Jamie Gauthier questioned Leheny about police Lt. Mark Hayes, who was fired after sending a sexually explicit video to two female subordinate officers and attempting to persuade one of them to lie about the incident.

An arbitrator reinstated Hayes with back pay, and the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled against Philadelphia’s challenge of that decision.

“We are extraordinarily disappointed by the Supreme Court’s decision,” Leheny said.

She explained that police arbitration decisions are subject to a narrow standard of judicial review. Even when an arbitrator gets the facts or law wrong, she said, the city generally cannot obtain a reversal unless the decision falls within limited legal exceptions.

Philadelphia pursued the Hayes appeal because courts have recognized public policy protections against sexual harassment in arbitration cases involving other public employees.

Landau also questioned the city’s ability to challenge disciplinary outcomes and its handling of officers accused of repeated misconduct.

Leheny acknowledged concerns with the system but rejected the suggestion that it is entirely broken.

“I would agree that there are significant concerns at times,” she said. “I don’t think it’s fully broken.”

Voters approved oversight. Investigators still lack authority.

McClary told Council that the police contract continues to prevent the Citizens Police Oversight Commission from conducting independent misconduct investigations, even though more than 500,000 voters supported creating the agency in 2020.

The commission received an average of more than 40 complaints per month during the past six months, she said. Some residents drop their complaints after learning the agency must refer them to Police Department Internal Affairs.

McClary reported that commission staff made nearly 1,000 recommendations while reviewing Internal Affairs investigations over two years, but fewer than half were accepted.

“We’re ready to do more than recommend,” she testified. “We’re ready to investigate.”

Deputy Executive Director Ewuare Osayande said the commission received 311 complaints from January through October. About 44% came from Black residents and 24% from white residents.

Gilmore Richardson asked whether the city’s next bargaining proposals would include independent investigative authority.

“Yes, it will,” Leheny responded.

The administration unsuccessfully sought that authority during the 2025 arbitration proceedings. Leheny said it also would renew efforts to restore Philadelphia’s police residency requirement, which has allowed officers to move outside the city after five years of service since a 2010 arbitration award.

Councilmember Curtis Jones Jr. questioned the commission about complaint trends and requested additional information on the allegations residents submit.

Germantown family still seeking answers

Kaitlyn Horner, a Germantown business owner, described her efforts to obtain information about the death of Elizabeth McGrone, who was struck and killed by a vehicle following a mental health crisis.

Horner alleged that two Philadelphia police officers drove away while McGrone lay in the intersection of Germantown and Coulter streets about 90 seconds before she was struck.

She said surveillance footage from her business documented the officers’ presence, but the Police Department released an abbreviated version that omitted any mention of their earlier involvement.

Horner said McGrone’s sister, Jacqueline Martinez, attended Tuesday’s hearing and that the family is still seeking an explanation four years after the death.

According to Horner, she eventually obtained the officers’ identities through a judge’s intervention in an unrelated criminal case rather than through the police complaint process.

“Her family deserves answers, and her young daughters deserve to know what happened to their mom,” Horner testified.

Landau presses for public records

Landau also criticized the Labor Department for failing to publish recent arbitration awards and disciplinary decisions.

She said only two FOP grievance arbitration decisions from 2025 were publicly available, even though the union has described handling dozens of arbitration matters annually.

Leheny acknowledged that the administration failed to publish the 2025-27 interest arbitration award.

“The failure to publish the 2025-2027 award falls entirely on me,” she said. “It was an oversight.”

She agreed to review the department’s disciplinary arbitration records and address any backlog in publications. She did not immediately commit to releasing bargaining proposals or settlement agreements.

According to the FOP, the 2025 arbitration award provided cumulative raises of 10% over fiscal years 2026 and 2027, along with a $3,000 signing bonus. The union said a top-step Police Officer 1 would earn $104,562, including stress pay.

Councilmember Anthony Phillips also questioned staffing levels, scheduling and officer wellness protections. Deputy Police Commissioner Francis Healy described expanded mental health resources for officers, while Landau raised concerns about body-worn cameras and police responses to people experiencing psychiatric emergencies.

Acting Oversight Commission Chair Malika Rahman, a former law enforcement professional, told Council that public confidence requires more than the release of documents or announcements of disciplinary decisions. Residents, she said, must understand how complaints are investigated and why officers are reinstated.

“Ultimately, we cannot expect the public to have confidence in a process that they do not understand, nor can we expect them to trust a process that does not consistently demonstrate accountability,” Rahman said.

Stay informed and connected — subscribe to The Philadelphia Tribune NOW! Click Here