The Circle K gas stations at the corner of Roosevelt Avenue and 7th Street in downtown Phoenix.
The Circle K gas stations at the corner of Roosevelt Avenue and 7th Street in downtown Phoenix.

Clarissa Sosin

The gas is too damn high! 

It’s expensive to be an Arizona driver right now. So, when drivers do have to make that dreaded pit stop to fill up their tanks, it’s important to pick a solid station. 

Arizona’s average fuel price as of Tuesday Nov. 10 is $4.23 per gallon, according to AAA Fuel Prices. That’s 26 cents more per gallon than the national average and nearly a dollar more per gallon than the state average a year ago. These prices vary more by county, with Maricopa County having a slightly lower average of $4.20 per gallon, and even by individual gas station. 

Drivers are spending a pretty penny to make their daily commutes, but not all gas stations are equal. According to an analysis of Google reviews by SEO Backlinks, drivers appear to agree on the spots to avoid. 

Sign up for our free weekly newsletter for a recap on politics, dining, culture, music and more

THANK YOU!

You’re all set.

CLOSE

“Drivers will put up with a lot at a gas station,” wrote Oliver Weston, the founder of SEO Backlinks, in a statement. “But the thing that sends them straight to a one-star review is feeling they have paid far more than they would have down the road.” 

The company’s experts reviewed 425 Arizona gas stations, which averaged 3.91 out of five stars. That makes Arizona’s gas stations the 11th lowest-rated in the country. 

The Circle K gas stations at the corner of Roosevelt Avenue and 7th Street in downtown Phoenix. The Circle K gas stations at the corner of Roosevelt Avenue and 7th Street in downtown Phoenix.

Here are the five worst gas stations in the state, according to an analysis of Google reviews. 

5. ARCO on Southern Avenue and McClintock Drive. 

Average ranking: 3

Total Reviews: 223

Address: 3233 S. McClintock Drive

This ARCO in Tempe serves several nearby strip malls and is near McClintock High School and the now-closed Shalimar Gold Club. Currently, it costs $4.50 per gallon to fill up, which is $0.27 above the state average. 

In the gas station’s Google Reviews, customers complained about being overcharged after purchasing gas, the restroom and convenience store being closed, broken card machines and gas pumps and rude customer service. 

One customer named Jese complained about asking for a cup of ice after purchasing a lukewarm Gatorade. The employee told them the cup of ice was a dollar. “Obviously, I didn’t buy anything and went to QuickTrip instead,” the reviewer wrote. “No wonder that store is always empty.” 

4. Shell on Cactus Road and El Mirage Road

Average Ranking: 2.90 

Total Reviews: 116 

Address: 12170 N. El Mirage Road

This gas station is located in the West Valley city of El Mirage. It’s south of the city’s downtown area near the emergency room and medical center. Currently, it costs $4.16 per gallon to fill up, which is a couple of cents lower than the state average. 

In the gas station’s Google Reviews, customers complained about changing policies regarding propane fills in vehicles, unsatisfactory customer service, stale potato chips and dirty bathrooms. 

3. Shell on Lake Pleasant Parkway 

Average Ranking: 2.72

Total Reviews: 106

Address: 34951 N. Lake Pleasant Parkway 

If you’re looking to fill up on gas on your way to Lake Pleasant for a day on the water, you might wanna skip this spot. This Peoria Shell station is located off Arizona State Route 74, known as Carefree Highway. Currently, it costs $5.79 per gallon to fill up, which is $1.59 more per gallon than the state average. 

Many customers complained about the station’s high gas prices, which are consistently $1.50 higher than other stations in the Valley. One Google Review called the station’s prices a “straight up scam.” 

2. Circle K on Roosevelt Street and Seventh Avenue 

Average Ranking: 2.63

Total Reviews: 131

Address: 616 W. Roosevelt St. 

With this gas station’s small parking lot and limited number of pumps, filling up at this busy station off downtown Phoenix’s Roosevelt Row can be stressful. Currently, the hectic station’s gas prices are $0.24 per gallon lower than the state average. 

In the Google Reviews, customers complained about cashiers being rude to a group of girls, aggressive managers and a homeless man threatening customers pumping their gas with a pocket knife. 

“This is a great place to go… for a drug deal!” wrote a customer named Caleb. 

  1. Shell on Buckeye Road and 16th Street 

Average Ranking: 1.72 

Total Reviews: 1,034 

Address: 1515 E. Buckeye Road

Only one Arizona gas station made SEO Backlink’s list of the top 10 worst gas stations in America. This Phoenix gas station near the Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport snuck in at number 10. 

This Shell station is located near the airport’s rental car pick-up and return, but complaints of high fuel prices and price gouging have marred its online reputation. So, the next time you need to drop off your rental car at the airport, you might wanna find another spot. 

In Google Reviews, customers complained that prices were “easily $1.50 a gallon more” and “you might as well let the rental car company fill it up for you,” Mike wrote. Another customer called the gas station a “scam,” and another suggested the state of Arizona and the city of Phoenix should “prosecute this gas station for price gouging.” Customers reported paying as much as $7 a gallon in online reviews.