War

The Juicy Bit

Season 1

Episode 7

Editor’s Rating

3 stars

***

With Johnny’s cover blown, both firms scramble to get the upper hand.
Photo: Miya Mizuno/Sky/HBO

Well, it had to happen: Johnny’s cover is blown, and he has no one to blame but himself. This week’s episode is aptly titled: It is the juicy bit, and not just where the divorce is concerned but in terms of the narrative structure of the season. This is the moment the story has been leading to: The firms’ respective reactions to the mole reveal will define what kind of lawyers they really are. All season long, Taylor & Byrne was positioned as “the good guys” and Cathcarts as “the bad guys,” but, perhaps as a reflection of our screwed-up world, the firms turn out to be two sides of the same self-preservationist, unscrupulous coin.

The firms cut a deal: If Taylor & Byrne agree to forget about Johnny, Cathcarts will agree to forget about Flora and the honey trap. This way, everyone leaves this infernal trial with their reputations intact. The deal is good for everyone except Johnny, who is left in the worst position imaginable. It goes without saying that he should have thought of that sooner. For most of this week’s episode — until the deal is made — he still believes he might have a shot at securing that job with Cathcarts, his only opportunity not to get the British equivalent of being disbarred. I still think he should have double-crossed, but obviously he hasn’t watched The Departed as many times as I have, so he scrambles in vain.

This week’s episode opens where we left off, with Serena realizing that Johnny is the mole. She whispers as much to Nick as soon as she gets a chance, but by that time, court is already in session. Nick and Serena are distracted as Prudence delivers her opening statement, in which she emphasizes Morgan’s visionary status and Carla’s middling acting career, and soon Smallwood becomes distracted too: Johnny texts him from his burner that he has “been rumbled.” Smallwood texts back that the job offer still stands if he can produce proof of the honey trap. I’m still caught up on how this evidence could possibly, legally be admitted in court. (I would love to hear from our helpful, informed readers on this point — sound off in the comments!)

Meanwhile, Nick and Serena try to decide what to do. Serena’s first instinct is to stop the proceedings and alert the judge that the trial has been compromised. That’s what they should do, but this is television, folks, and this episode still has 40 minutes to go. As Budgie charms the room with her opening statement — in which she encourages the judge to remember that Carla is a creative professional as they debate the creation of Zephyr — Johnny runs to the Taylor & Byrne offices hoping to get a copy of the receipt for the construction of the conservatory with which they paid off Flora, charged to Bernard’s card. He uses his make-women-stupid spell on Cleo, but it fades as the walls close in: Cleo questions the purchase of the conservatory; the ever-watchful Molly questions Johnny’s urgency; Michael questions why he wasn’t notified if there was a document needed in court; Bernard questions why he is up in his finances without asking. All this questioning happens while Johnny is literally in the elevator, and Michael snatches the receipt from his hand before the door closes.

Johnny briefly loses it in a great short montage that sees him squirm under pressure. He proceeds to Flora’s house, and on the way, calls Bella to propose a midweek getaway, since he won’t be needed in court the next day. Bella correctly identifies this as a weird suggestion to make on a Tuesday. Johnny tries to convince Flora to “do what’s right” and go to Cathcarts to confess about the conservatory, the NDA, the honey trap, everything. He tells her she has been used by Taylor & Byrne, just as he’s been used. But his desperate demeanor is sudden enough to raise Flora’s suspicion. After seven episodes of women being too easily manipulated by Johnny, they finally wake up and smell the rat.

At this point, Nick is looking for Johnny. Still in court, Nick and Serena agree that they need to speak with Bernard, and by the time they get him on the phone during recess, all the stuff with the receipt has already happened. They decide not to alert Budgie to the mole problem because there’s nothing she can do at present, and there’s nothing Johnny himself can do for Cathcarts while Budgie cross-examines Morgan. They also immediately agree that they should not tell Carla, though they might reconsider if they knew she was sleeping with the mole. I thought Johnny might try to use Carla somehow, but at least for now, he’s ignoring her calls. I fear we’re in for a soapy how could you do this to me confrontation in the finale.

The firms race to find Johnny. As Morgan worries about his performance on cross-examination (we’ll get to the trial itself after we have surveyed the depth of Johnny’s snafu), Smallwood instructs Schill to get to Johnny before “Singer,” who has disappeared from court, and offer Johnny a job lest the other side tries to “turn him” (Smallwood is familiar with The Departed). But Schill is too late; Nick has a few hours’ head start and gets to Johnny first. He waits for him in his apartment, where he threatens Johnny with criminal charges for corporate espionage and promises to ruin his career forever. When Schill calls the burner, it’s Nick who picks up (Schill hangs up right away). Nick also tells Bella everything, and she is actually mad for once. She leaves and tells Johnny to be gone when she returns. Johnny weakly apologizes to Nick, but I think the show is banking on a stronger emotional reaction for next week. Archie Renaux embodies Johnny’s desperation well; I’m eager to see him bring this character to resolution.

Nick’s brief phone call with Schill leads to the deal between the firms. Serena and Nick meet with Beatrice, Smallwood, and Schill at the Cathcarts office. At first, Cathcarts plays dumb, but when Nick assures them they have proof, they get to business. If each side can overlook their opponent’s trespasses, neither firm’s reputation will suffer and no client will have to know about anything. They come to a settlement number in about 30 seconds that will hopefully bring this God-forsaken trial to a close, so everyone can forget about honey traps and corporate spies and go have tea and shoot clay pigeons or whatever it is they do for fun. It was that easy!

This is all done without the knowledge of clients or barristers, who might be a little peeved to see their hard work so easily dismissed. Prudence and Budgie spend the day with Morgan on the stand. He oscillates between tenderness and hostility toward Carla, though he brings up her diminishing relevance as an actress as many times as possible. Prudence’s goal is to show that Carla doesn’t have any real professional involvement with Zephyr, while Budgie labors to prove that Zephyr would never have existed without Carla. Under Prudence’s examination, Morgan explains that Carla wasn’t present for most of Zephyr’s development, which took place largely in Palo Alto. By way of illustration, Prudence introduces a photo of Zephyr’s American launch party, which Carla didn’t attend because she was at the premiere of a film she wasn’t even in.

What Morgan forgets — and what evades Cathcarts’ research — is that this launch party took place on the eve of Morgan and Carla’s wedding anniversary, and that Morgan set the party date himself. Budgie argues that, knowing Carla would be at a friend’s premiere, and that their anniversary was on the next day, and that every other Zephyr executive was bringing their spouses to the function, Morgan picked a date Carla couldn’t make to purposefully exclude her and take all the credit for himself. Losing his patience, Morgan scoffs that it’s ridiculous he should have to give away “half of [his] life’s work” because he forgot an anniversary date.

But that’s not Budgie’s main point, anyway; she is only course correcting. The core of her argument is that Zephyr couldn’t have existed without Carla because the idea for Zephyr emerged in reaction to something that happened to Carla, when she was the target of a social-media pile-on and became a viral laughingstock. That was the reason Morgan and Carla went to the cottage in Normandy for a needed respite. Maintaining that Carla was a passive muse, “the Jane to his Serge,” Morgan exploited his wife’s suffering for his own gain. The truth is, he can’t recite the poem that gave Zephyr its name, which we’ve seen Carla recite by heart. He can’t even correctly remember the name of its author. If I ever need a lawyer, I’m calling Budgie.

Budgie’s perfect rhetoric puts Carla ahead, but a string of Zephyr employees — including Gillian, Eric, and an unnamed front-desk receptionist — testify in Morgan’s favor that Carla was never professionally involved with the company. Despite Serena’s encouragement that they’re still in a good position, these testimonies make Carla nervous. Morgan is thankful for his colleagues’ contributions, but he notices that Gillain seems “off.” Carla notices the same thing a bit earlier, when Gillian stops her in the hallway to offer her sympathy for how things turned out and promises to call her.

The weirdness that Morgan sensed in Gillian was nothing less than the turning gears of machination. Gillian does call Carla, as promised, and they meet covertly in Carla’s car. Gillian tells Carla about Ancker’s offer and proposes a plan: If Carla changes her strategy to go after Morgan’s Zephyr shares, rather than cash, Morgan would no longer be the majority shareholder and they could force the sale to Ancker. As a result, Carla would become a billionaire. On the stand, Gillian hinted at her intention — she testified that her contributions to the company have been reflected in her shares. With Carla, she works the overlooked-woman angle, hoping she can convince her to act out of wrath and greed. But Carla has been notoriously wishy-washy when it comes to those cardinal sins. She has gone from honey-trapping Morgan to wanting only “what’s fair”; earlier that same night, sharing an umbrella with her soon-to-be ex-husband, she almost looked wistful. Maybe this final decision will invest Carla’s character with some actual complexity and humanity, though I fear, with one episode left, it’s too late.

• With Morgan on the stand, we finally get a definition of what Zephyr actually is: “A social-media platform with strict community guidelines designed to promote positivity rather than division.” Still sounds like word salad to me, though. I can’t envision what a platform like this would actually look like, especially when a couple of episodes ago, Carla got a lot of heat on Zephyr for bombing her late-night appearance.

• At the trial, the press is present both inside and outside the courtroom. Given the prominent place the media has had in the unraveling of Carla and Morgan’s marriage, I suspect the journalists sitting in on the proceedings will play some role in the finale.

• Taylor & Byrne’s eagerness to make a deal with Cathcarts seemed anti-climactic to me. I understand they’re nervous the stuff with Flora will come out, but isn’t employing a corporate spy a much graver transgression? Is anything that happened with Flora straight-up illegal, or as illegal as planting a mole in the opponent’s firm? As Nick said last week, the espionage plot could ruin Cathcarts forever, while Taylor & Byrne established deniability about the honey trap from the get-go. I wanted to see Nick and Serena coming in for the kill. I’m hoping this isn’t the end of negotiations!

• Let’s place our bets on what will happen in the finale. I think Carla will take Gillian’s offer but backtrack at the last minute, thereby ensuring some kind of dignified ending for herself. I also think Saeed will return to the Taylor & Byrne offices and that we will finally learn what actually happened in New York, though I have very high hopes we won’t have to sit through a flashback sequence. I think we’ve seen the last of Bella, and Johnny will end up as all greedy, selfish men do: lonely and friendless. And I think Carla and Morgan will reconcile. Will we see Gabe again at all? What about Flora? Cast your predictions!

Sign Up for the Vulture Newsletter

Entertainment news, for the pop-culture obsessed.

Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice