Ain’t That Good News
Season 4
Episode 3
Editor’s Rating
5 stars
*****
If anyone deserves a beautiful Newport wedding, it’s Peggy Scott.
Photo: Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
Sign up for The Gilded Age Club, a subscriber-exclusive newsletter where writers and editors obsess over season four.
THE DRAMA IS FINALLY HERE. The Gilded Age is going for it in season four. Big weddings! Verbose late-night accusations! Robber barons drinking too much laudanum! And The Ladies’ Home Journal functioning as the TMZ of its time. If this episode felt dizzying, it’s because so much is packed in.
First off, Peggy Scott and Dr. William Kirkland are getting married. Agnes, Ada, and Marian travel to Newport for the wedding, so bad luck to Larian fans this week. But it’s all worth it because this episode is so good. Enid and Oscar host their salon, and Bertha is back to peak Bertha “I’ll Steal Your Influential Guest” Russell behavior. It’s good to see her again.
Oscar and Enid’s lavender marriage is thriving as they prepare to host their first artistic salon. Enid directs her footmen on where to place her ornate furniture while her gay husband makes her cocktails. As far as platonic-marriage arrangements go, it really doesn’t seem that bad. I mean, aside from Oscar having to live a lie and Enid having to seek romantic and sexual gratification outside her marriage. But paintings and cocktails! If there were a Partiful invite, I would call it “Paintings and Cocktails,” which is probably why no one lets me host salons.
The salon here is a huge success. Oscar hits on the artist’s apprentice, Mr. Klein, and a shout-out to the lesbian in a top hat, which is maybe the best representation we lesbians have had on this show so far. Everyone has a great time, including influencer Mamie Fish and heiress Carrie Astor, who has chosen to wear some sort of fashionable clown ruff for the occasion. Carrie mentions to Larry that her mother wants to see them together, which Larry doesn’t immediately slam down. Will Larian survive? Larry also brings Jack, who is beginning to find his social confidence. Carrie introduces Jack to her cousin, a Miss Summers (she’s fine), and they do little smiles at each other for the whole salon. This culminates in Jack bidding a thousand dollars on a painting she likes, which, if inflation calculators are to be believed, is about $34,000 today. Jack! What of Bridget? What of your tiny Irish moppet pseudo-girlfriend? This is exactly what she worried about, and now here’s Jack being all “I’m allowed to like other people than the one the audience likes.” Well, I’m here to tell you that you are NOT, Jack.
On Fifth Avenue, Bertha and George are really bringing me the soap-opera shenanigans I crave, if opium addiction can be termed a shenanigan. George is sleep-screaming and waking up all sweaty, and when Bertha asks him to see the doctor, he says, “I FEEL FINE.” Well, I’m convinced. George attributes all of this sleep chaos to his business with Rockefeller, and when Bertha asks if she can help, he replies that he doubts it. Dude? Dude!! Your wife is an asset. How do you think you got where you are? How do you think any of this happened? Business + social conniving! He finally agrees to see a doctor, and we learn he was given a laudanum prescription six months ago but his doctor hasn’t seen him since. The doctor is very “You’re not still taking that, right?” while giving him a look that says “We both know you’re still taking it.” George adamantly denies it. Sympathy for people with a substance use disorder, and also what a struggle for the 1880s, when people understood it even less. Let Bertha help you, George!!
Bertha does help, but first I want to skip on over to Newport and talk about this wedding. It has to be italicized because of My Feelings about this wedding. First, we learn William pulled a Jim and bought Peggy a house in Newport. A big house. It’s so pretty. He calls it a wedding present, which, damn. Peggy has had such a hard journey on this show, and now she has a rich, handsome doctor buying her a house to summer in on a beautiful block in Newport, right around the corner from her cousin. You deserve everything, Peggy! Including your beautiful day dress with a flower sash. A flower sash! I’m a generally exclamatory person, but this wedding has really upped my exclamation game because everything is beautiful and everyone is beautiful and Peggy and William are so happy.
At the pre-wedding party, Peggy’s cousin announces she is a founding member of the Fisk Jubilee Singers (still around!) and she has brought them from Nashville to perform at the wedding. It’s a bold move, but it pays off because Peggy is thrilled. Mrs. Kirkland is less so and speaks derogatorily to her friend of their singing “spirituals.” I appreciate that the 1880s Black community is not treated as a monolith. It’s hard to see Phylicia Rashad scorning the idea of Peggy and William jumping over the same broom Dorothy and her husband did before he could legally marry her, but these opinions did exist. The Kirklands and the Scotts (mostly Mrs. Kirkland) almost come to fisticuffs over the wedding arrangements, but William and Peggy each remind their parents that this day is about them. A tale as old as time indeed.
Peggy wants to start things off well with her mother-in-law, so she visits her alone. Side note: Rashad is gorgeous here. Like, someone paint her. She is luminous. I can’t get over it. Peggy tells Mrs. Kirkland how much she loves William and how despite him telling his mother not to come to the wedding if she couldn’t get past things, Peggy knows he would regret it later. Peggy does not want Mrs. Kirkland to be left on the outside of their marriage, but it is Mrs. Kirkland’s choice. Wow, what an emotionally mature couple.
I can’t believe we get to the wedding already, which means two weddings in three episodes. This season is truly not playing around. Ada and Agnes (wearing pink) are there, and when Ada drops her purse, actor Dennis Haysbert, a.k.a. THE ALLSTATE INSURANCE MAN, picks it up. Romance for Ada with the Allstate man! Romance for Ada with the Allstate man! He is Dr. Harris, and he and Ada keep looking at each other with a look that says “We are going to have a story line that challenges 19th-century ideas about interracial marriage.” Good! Haysbert became the Allstate man because of his remarkably reassuring presence, and I would like to see him on my screen some more.
Marian goes to see Peggy before the wedding and provides some great visuals for Marian/Peggy fans. She gives Peggy the train ticket Peggy bought for her way back in episode one. I completely forgot they met when Marian’s purse was stolen and Peggy bought Marian’s ticket to New York. Bananas. Dorothy gives Peggy earrings her husband gave her when Peggy was born and tells Peggy how wonderful she is. They both cry.
THIS WEDDING SCENE. THE BEAUTY. THE SPLENDOR. THE MUSIC. THE FLOWERS. THE JUBILEE FISK SINGERS. This wedding is so gorgeous, and I love it so much. Dr. and Mrs. William D. Kirkland! Her dad brings up the broom! He lays it down! Mrs. Kirkland sucks it up! They’re smiling so big! They jump the broom! What a wonderful day, though not for Agnes, as we shall soon see.
If you remember, Bertha is going to help George. At the opera last week, she heard about Agnes hosting President Cleveland across the street, and wheels began to turn. Mrs. Astor comes to call and tells her Laura Spelman Rockefeller is holding a fundraiser for Spelman Seminary, which her family founded. If Bertha wants to get in with her, she needs to donate. Bertha asks Mrs. Astor for one more favor, which is to get her a meeting with Mrs. Foster from the Heritage Society. Wheels! Also, I am the biggest fan of the Bertha Russell–Mrs. Astor alliance. I like their friendship so much. They are two titans of society joining forces! It is very fun.
Bertha has spotted weakness in the form of the Ladies’ Home Journal article. Mrs. Knapp Curtis has ripped Agnes to shreds with accusations of poor hostess skills and an outdated home. Bertha moves in for the kill by dropping broad hints to Mrs. Foster about her ability to host the dinner out of her modern and stately mansion. The White House agrees, and all of this is accomplished while Agnes is busy in Newport. These swift moves are made possible by the Russells’ telephone, an invention that Agnes, unfortunately for her, has scorned.
Bertha presents George with the presidential dinner as a fait accompli. “You accomplished all this in one day?” This is like when Tracy Jordan wrote a porn video game and drove Frank insane. Bertha Russell: truly the Tracy Jordan of The Gilded Age. Bertha tells George to invite Rockefeller. Here she is, coming through yet again. They need to get George some help for his addiction, best Rockefeller, and go back to being a low-key evil power couple.
Agnes finally sees the article and is livid. “I thought The Ladies’ Home Journal was a reputable paper,” she cries, claiming it appeals to the lowest common denominator. Checks out. She declares this will be the most polished presidential dinner in history and vengeance shall be hers, for the Lord is too lenient. Agnes demands they leave the wedding as soon as possible to get back to New York. When she arrives home, there is a telegram from Mrs. Foster, telling her of dinners’ venue change. Agnes thought her enemy was the Journal, when all along ’twas the bejeweled woman across the road.
Agnes strides out the front door, across Fifth Avenue, and into the Russell house. It’s late. She demands to see Bertha, and if Bertha is asleep, they are to wake her. This is it. Agnes has been pushed too far. She could handle losing all her money, her sister taking over the house, the terrible new curtains, the disastrous Buster Keaton butler, her gay son marrying a former maid, being libeled in the newspaper, and Marian working an evening shift, but THIS? A dinner taken from her? This is the final inch that causes her to step off the Clifftops of Propriety, down, down into the chasm of Shouting a Lot.
Agnes demands to know how a woman who hardly knows the name of her own grandfather has somehow supplanted Agnes in a society devoted to the history of New York. Bertha handles this calmly because Bertha is always calm in the face of someone else’s meltdown. Agnes will be hosting the dinner but in Bertha’s home. George comes down, politely saying it is quite late, then Ada hustles in, telling Agnes there is an urgent matter at home. Alone, Bertha thanks George for rescuing her and body-language propositions him, which he turns down but congratulates her on the dinner, which may be the key to the family’s survival. Doesn’t Bertha’s dress here look like it’s from a John Singer Sargent portrait? I felt like I recognized it but couldn’t find the painting I was thinking of.
On the street, Agnes swears Bertha will be crushed as Agnes has been crushed, even if Agnes has to sell her soul to Satan to achieve it. Yessssssss, give me all your over-the-top language, thank you. ”I just want to go to bed and wake up in 1881 before anyone ever heard of Bertha Russell!” How dare you.
• If Ada buys one more thing for the house, will Agnes start running around screaming in the street?
• I heard there may be a poisoning at the presidential dinner. Or, I mean, there probably won’t be, but what if there were? What a fun new angle for everyone.
• Word on the street is that Mamie Fish is now an influencer. Who is sponsoring her, and what if it’s Mrs. O.S. Fowler-Chumos, phrenologist?
• If a speaking lesbian doesn’t show up soon, I’m picketing.
We know you have thoughts. Comment your response below for a chance to be featured in the Gilded Age Club newsletter.
Sign up for The Gilded Age Club here or below to continue discussing season four with writers and editors from Vulture, The Cut, and all across New York Magazine.
Sign Up For The Gilded Age TV Club
A newsletter where writers and editors obsess over HBO’s campy 19th-century drama, for subscribers only.
Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice