A wide picture of Lincoln Family Downtown YMCA.
The Lincoln Family Downtown YMCA shuttered on Sept. 30.

Clarissa Sosin

Phoenix isn’t saying goodbye to the Lincoln Family Downtown YMCA — yet. 

In a stunning turn of events, the Phoenix Historic Preservation Commission narrowly voted to approve a zoning status that extends protections to the 75-year-old building.  

Julia Taggart, president of the Sunnyslope Historical Society, was in the Phoenix City Council Chambers when the vote took place on Monday evening. She said she was shocked by the outcome. She didn’t even realize they’d won at first.

“I didn’t know until the end. I had to ask someone,” she said. “Nobody applauded or anything. Usually if something is good, people applaud, but it was just silence.”

Sign up for our free weekly newsletter for a recap on politics, dining, culture, music and more

THANK YOU!

You’re all set.

CLOSE

Many expected the Phoenix Historic Preservation Commission’s November meeting to be a death knell for the Lincoln Family Downtown YMCA located across the street from Civic Space Park. The red brick building closed its doors to the public for good at the end of September and shuttered its transitional housing program after YMCA leadership said it was beyond repair and asked the city for permission to demolish it. Then, a couple of weeks later, the Phoenix Suns and Phoenix Mercury announced a $60 million plan to develop a new facility with the YMCA on the land. 

To those who support historic building preservation in Phoenix, the land of nearly endless suburban sprawl, it was a fait accompli. The historic preservation overlay zoning on the commission’s November agenda — the building’s last gasp at a future — would never pass despite the commission’s staff determination that the building qualified as historic. 

Who would dare cast a vote against a mostly funded project that would build athletic and community facilities for children and the community? The red brick building, a fixture in Phoenix’s ever-changing skyline since 1952, was doomed. In the past month Phoenix lost two other storied structures, the Coronado Motel and the KOY radio studio. The YMCA was another nail in the coffin for Phoenix’s architectural history. The required hold on the demolition request ended on Nov. 20, just days after the Nov. 16 meeting. It was going to be destroyed. 

But instead, in a startling development, the divided commission approved the overlay, a zoning status that will require the YMCA and its developers to jump through more hoops to consider demolishing the structure. 

“There’s always an alternative,” said Tricia Amato, the commission’s chair, about the project moments before she voted. “Somebody else could come along. They could sell this building. They could talk to some developers who do adaptive reuse, and see what can be done. And there’s other land, so you could still build this. You don’t have to build it on that parcel.”

Of the nine-member commission, seven attended the meeting and participated in the feisty discussion. By the time it was Amato’s turn, two commissioners had abstained, two had voted in favor and two had voted against, saying that the building was old but not historic. Amato cast the deciding vote, saving the building — for now. 

“Our job is to preserve historic buildings,” Amato said, sternly rebuking her colleagues who voted against the overlay. “We are not here to green light projects, no matter how great they are.” 

The YMCA could not be reached for comment. 

During the meeting, YMCA representatives told the commission it would incorporate red brick and decorative medallions from the old building into the new one and include an exhibit celebrating the YMCA’s 132-year history downtown. The development would also include 57 units of affordable housing to replace the previous transitional housing. 

“We think there could be a really good marriage between the two on transforming the building, but still celebrating what’s currently there,” architect Stefan Richter told the commission. 

However, after being grilled, Richter also told the commission they had not done a formal assessment to figure out if the building could be saved.

Some of the commissioners felt blindsided by the proposal. 

“Do we have any real teeth in the historic preservation laws and ordinances in this city, or not?” said a frustrated Keely Varvel Hartsell, one of the commissioners who then voted in favor of the overlay. “To lose this building without really having the ability to consider alternatives is just really frustrating for a lot of us and disheartening.” 

Preservationists echoed her concerns and encouraged the commission to save the building during the public comment. Other historic buildings have been demolished for new developments only for the property to sit vacant or unfinished for years after. Developers make promises, they said, but they don’t always follow through.

“How many buildings, historic buildings, beloved buildings in Phoenix are now a plaque,” said Opal Wagner, co-chair of Save Historic AZ. “You have the authority to pump the brakes on this project and give it some breathing space to get the adequate information that you need to see whether this building actually needs to be torn down. And I encourage you to do that.”

And that’s just what they did.

Taggart was in favor of the overlay and tried to save the building. But she’d had little hope it would work out. During the public comment she spoke to the commission with that in mind. Instead of asking them to vote for the overlay, she told them about her father who got his scuba diving license at the YMCA decades ago. She asked them to conduct an oral history of the building, to document its role in the city after it no longer existed. 

“I think that’s what people really wanted to see was that their memories and their stories and their own history here with that building were going to continue on,” Taggart said. “Hopefully that’s the case.”