Weeks after a Duval County judge convicted him of the kidnapping and murder of 17-year-old Leslie McCray in 1985, David Nelson Austin will be sentenced Wednesday.
In a bench trial (no jury), Judge Meredith Charbula found Austin, 65, guilty last month of all four charges against him: first-degree murder, two counts of armed kidnapping and one count of armed sexual battery.
Austin faces a mandatory term of life in prison without parole for his first-degree murder conviction.
McCray’s family and friends are expected to share victim impact statements at Wednesday’s hearing.
A photo of Leslie McCray is held at a news conference Thursday. (WJXT)
Austin was indicted on the first-degree murder charge in August 2021, after advances in DNA technology linked him to the Christmas Eve 1985 murder case in Jacksonville.
RELATED | ‘Hallelujah’: Family grateful for guilty verdict in 1985 kidnap, murder of 17-year-old Leslie McCray
McCray’s family had partnered with Project Cold Case to push detectives to re-investigate her murder, which led to the retesting of the DNA, clearing McCray’s roommate, who had long been under suspicion, and pointing investigators to Austin.
“It is a blessing that the family was persistent,” Assistant State Attorney Lauren Anderson said. “They called in 2003, and that ignited the retesting, but we were hindered by the abilities of DNA at that time. And then again in 2019, they picked up that phone, and that caused a spiral of events that ultimately led us here.”
When detectives tracked Austin down decades after the crime, he had been behind bars in Michigan since 1991, serving a life sentence for convictions in sexual assault cases there.
Investigators say that six years before his Michigan life sentence began, Austin slipped into the duplex where he used to live and attacked McCray and her 20-year-old roommate.
Austin tied up the roommate and then took McCray from the duplex before assaulting her in a ravine at knifepoint and leaving her to be found hours later stabbed to death.
Judge Meredith Charbula (WJXT)
Detectives learned early in the investigation that Austin had lived in that same duplex before McCray moved in. But in those early days — and for decades after — investigators instead keyed in on McCray’s roommate as the main person of interest.
NOTE: News4JAX is not naming the roommate because he is a surviving victim.
From the beginning, the roommate described a harrowing ordeal involving a stranger who attacked him and McCray, but detectives questioned his story.
In his closing argument in the bench trial, defense attorney Joshua Beard also pointed to the roommate as someone who could be responsible for McCray’s death, rather than his client.
But Anderson said the case came down to Austin’s DNA being found on a swab taken from a sexual assault kit done during McCray’s autopsy.
During her closing argument, Anderson acknowledged the case was circumstantial and had no eyewitnesses, but argued that crimes committed in darkness often leave no witnesses.
David Nelson Austin looks at a picture of Leslie McCray. He is accused of kidnapping and killing McCray on Christmas Eve in 1985. (WJXT)
“This kidnapping is committed in the early morning hours of a darkened apartment. The two victims are groggy from sleep. And the sexual battery is committed in a remote ravine obscured by surrounding trees. No eyes to see, no ears to hear,” Anderson said. “The defendant’s identity is written in the (DNA) evidence he left behind.”
Anderson said that evidence was made more powerful by Austin’s denials that he had ever known or had contact with McCray.
“Those repeated denials matter because that scientific evidence places him in intimate contact with Leslie McCray while his words attempt to erase any connection between the two of them,” Anderson said. “Identity does not depend on eyewitness testimony. The law does not require it. The physical evidence can and, in this case, does speak for itself.”
Charbula agreed, convicting Austin of all charges.
During the trial, Austin opted not to testify in his own defense, and his attorneys called no witnesses.
After the verdict was announced, McCray’s former roommate, who survived the attack, shared this statement with News4JAX:
“I am thankful to the attorneys and detectives who never gave up in the pursuit of justice for Leslie. For more than 40 years Leslie’s family and I have all lived with a mystery and now finally have closure and justice. I am grateful for the evidence that led to this guilty verdict and that the killer will finally be held accountable for this terrible crime.”
Surviving victim
‘I felt terrorized’: Survivor testifies
Now 61 years old, that surviving victim testified in the bench trial, telling prosecutors that he had just turned 20 in December of 1985 and was living with McCray, whom he considered a friend, when they were attacked in their St. Johns Avenue duplex.
The man acknowledged that he and McCray had been intimate for “a week or two” but said the relationship was open and he would not consider them a couple.
He said that when McCray came home on Dec. 23, he had fallen asleep in her bed after taking cold medicine, although it was unusual for them to sleep in each other’s rooms.
He said McCray gave him another dose of cold medicine with codeine after she got home, and the two fell asleep in her bed.
The man then described waking up in the early morning hours of Christmas Eve to a stranger hovering over McCray’s bed with a knife. He said it was too dark to make out any of the person’s features, but it was clearly a man.
McCray’s friend said the stranger told him to lie on his stomach, and then he took strong, canvas straps from the futon in the other bedroom and tightly bound his hands behind his back and his legs at the ankles.
He said he heard the stranger take McCray into his bedroom next door and heard her pleading with the stranger not to cut her. He said he heard them move downstairs and didn’t know what happened after that except that they left the apartment.
McCray’s friend said it took him a while to free himself from the bindings, but when he did, he called the police.
“I felt terrorized and scared and shaky,” he said.
Once the police arrived, a search began for McCray, and hours later, she was found stabbed to death on Old Middleburg Road.
McCray’s friend said he moved out of the duplex immediately because he didn’t feel safe there while the killer was not identified.
Again, McCray’s friend was himself a prime person of interest in the case for decades because police questioned his account of what happened.
But when police began investigating the cold case again in 2019 and 2020, they contacted McCray’s friend, who provided a DNA sample for comparison.
It wasn’t a match to the 1985 sexual assault kit sample.
Solving the cold case
That sent cold case detectives in a different direction, concentrating on another name that had risen to the surface in the early days of the investigation: David Nelson Austin.
Investigators traveled to Michigan to get a DNA sample, and when they compared Austin’s sample to the 1985 evidence, it was a match.
David Nelson Austin (Michigan Department of Corrections)
The lead cold case detective said Austin’s name first popped up in the case because he had previously lived at the duplex where McCray and her friend were attacked.
During opening statements, attorneys for both sides confirmed that Austin had lived there before McCray moved in.
The state implied that was the reason there were no signs of forced entry from the night of the attack. The defense, on the other hand, suggested that Austin’s previous residence in the apartment could offer an alternate explanation for why Austin’s DNA was found on one of the swabs from McCray’s sexual assault kit.
During testimony, prosecutors played an interview cold case detectives conducted with Austin in Michigan. During the interview, he said he didn’t know McCray and never had any contact with her.
Original investigation
Several criminal experts testified to their roles in the 1985 murder investigation that led to the discovery of McCray’s body and the DNA that later pointed to Austin.
Former medical examiner investigator Lou Eliopulos described in graphic detail what McCray’s body looked like when it was found in a vegetated ravine near I-295 and Old Middleburg Road hours after she had been taken from the duplex. He said he saw no obvious ligature marks or defensive injuries.
On cross-examination, Eliopulos said rigor mortis was present at the scene, which is generally seen within about 30 minutes of death, but he did not offer a more precise estimate of how long McCray’s body had been there.
Pathology assistant Arlene Monarch testified that she assisted with McCray’s 1985 autopsy and collecting evidence for her sexual-assault kit. She said samples were collected before the body was washed, but she could not recall whether outside investigators had collected other samples first or the exact collection sequence.
Those samples were preserved, and a grant from the U.S. Justice Department to JSO’s Cold Case Unit covered the cost of having them re-examined in 2019, after McCray’s family reached out to the Jacksonville-based group, Project: Cold Case, and the JSO Cold Case Unit.
Copyright 2026 by WJXT News4JAX – All rights reserved.