Phoenix, Scottsdale and other cities and towns that use photo radar and red-light cameras – like this one in Anthem – will need voter approval to continue the programs.
(Tom Scanlon/Staff)
The voters voted to vote some more …
The evening of Nov. 11, eight days after the election, Maricopa County released “final, unofficial election results for the 2026 General Election.”
The results showed several state-wide propositions crashed and burned.
Proposition 142 (“Prohibit Race- or Ethnicity-Based Preferential Treatment”): failed, 60% against.
Prop 144 (election reforms, including making major changes to how Arizonans vote by mail): failed, 55% against.
The closely-watched Proposition 320, which would force public school districts to put 60% of their budgets into “direct instruction,” also was rejected with 52% opposition.
This pleased the likes of Deer Valley Unified School District Superintendent Curtis Finch. Weeks before the election, he warned:
“If it passes, it will be devastating to most of the public school districts in the state.”
One of the state-wide measures that passed was Proposition 319, “Prohibit New Photo Traffic Enforcement Systems Measure.”
It was speeding along in unofficial results with nearly 63% approval.
That vote means more votes.
Scottsdale, Phoenix, Paradise Valley, Tempe and other cities would “continue using the existing systems only if local authorities receive voter approval at a referendum in the November 2027 election.”
So a special election will be held next November.
Cities that receive approval – if Prop 319 passes – would have free sailing for photo radar for 10 years.
But if the proposition passes and Scottsdale fails in a referendum next year, the Scottsdale Police Department would have 90 days to pull the plug on its city-wide system.
This could mean a shock to Scottsdale’s long-running system.
Scottsdale started using photo enforcement technology in 1996.
In the summer of 2025, City Council asked for details on photo enforcement – which Scottsdale Police Chief Joe LeDuc provided Nov. 3, 2025.
Scottsdale operates 15 total traffic cameras, he said, with 11 at intersections and four “mobile.”
He stressed the SPD’s 0.11 cameras per square mile is “the
lowest density among Valley cities” and “demonstrates a targeted, data-driven approach.”
How is the 30-year-old system working?
Great, LeDuc praised, citing a 2023 study that showed a 15% reduction in total accidents – and 49% reduction in fatal wrecks – at intersections with photo cameras.
Other almost-final results
One local proposition also got the big thumbs-up.
Proposition 440 asked Cave Creek voters if they want to preserve thousands of acres of pristine Foothills land.
The unofficial decision:
“Keep it green.”
Though the vote has not been finalized, ballot releases from Maricopa County Elections Department showed nearly two-thirds approval for the Cave Creek measure.
Proposition 440 is a proposed sales tax increase that would fund the purchase of more than 4,000 acres of state trust land.
This proposal covers a dozen lots ranging from 20 to 660 acres staggered throughout the Foothills, stretching far east of the town through Desert Hills toward New River.
The tax increase looks poised to go into effect Jan. 1 – and remain for 25 years, or until “sufficient funds have been collected to provide for the obligations” of the state land purchase.
Meanwhile, in the Cave Creek Unified School District Governing Board race, Scott Brown led the way, with 40%, followed by Marla Riney, 37.5%. Sucheta Shah was a distant third, 22.4%.
With two seats open, Brown and Riney are in; Shah is out.
CCUSD voters also were overwhelmingly approving a request by the district to “sell, lease or exchange real property.” Two-thirds of voters gave CCUSD the thumbs up.
Carefree
In the July primary, Carefree voters reelected Mayor John Crane with a whopping 70% of the votes over challenger D. Melissa Price.
Carefree also had three town council seats on the primary ballot. Incumbent Sheila Amoroso (25%) and Les Hardie (23%) had enough votes for an “outright win.”
Also coming under scrutiny, though not part of Proposition 319, are Flock cameras like this one off Carefree Highway.
(Tom Scanlon/Staff)
As Carefree’s election site notes, “Because only two candidates received the statutory majority required for election to the three available Town Council seats, one council seat remains to be filled.”
Carefree voters’ Nov. 3 ballots featured a runoff between Sharon P. Smith and Ted Taylor.
Near-final results showed Smith comfortably ahead with 52% of the votes.
DVUSD
The Deer Valley Unified School District Governing Board has five seats, with two up for election on Nov. 3 ballots.
Karen Pack, Kimberly Fisher and Steve Bottfeld were elected in 2024, with terms expiring at the end of 2028.
Stephanie Simacek and Paul Carver Jr. were elected in 2022, began serving in 2023 and have terms expiring at the end of this year.
Simacek is not on the Nov. 3 ballot.
Carver, David Alvarado, Kristi Cooper and Julie Stockwell were battling for the two DVUSD board seats.
Unofficial results showed Cooper ahead, with 29%, followed closely by Carver, 28%. Those two look to be in, with Stockwell, 27%, and Alvarado, 15%, missing the mark.
SUSD
Unofficial election results show former teacher/administrator Jennifer Johnson and incumbent Amy Carney had strong leads in the race for two Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board seats.
Jeanne Beasley, the third candidate, was trailing.
SUSD’s $375 million bond request looked to be passing with 54% approval.
According to SUSD, “The proposed bond program includes investments in:
• Learning environment improvements;
• Technology enhancements;
• Site lifecycle renovations;
• School safety and security;
• Transportation;
• Administrative capital improvements.
State battles
Anthem, Cave Creek, Carefree, Scottsdale and other voters helped decide on various state battles.
In the secretary of state race, incumbent Adrian Fontes easily defeated Scottsdale Republican Alexander Kolodin, who represents Legislative District 3.
Arizona District 3 includes Anthem, Cave Creek, Carefree and North Scottsdale.
In the battle for two Arizona House of Representatives District 3 seats, Democrats Julie Gable and Richard Spargo failed to ride the nation-wide “blue wave.”
The D3 seats were won by Republicans with strong Scottsdale ties, George Khalaf and Cody Reim.
In the race for Arizona State Senate District 3, incumbent Republican John Kavanagh scored a dominant win over Jeff Fortney, a Democrat; both live in Fountain Hills.
Arizona District 4 includes much of Scottsdale and Paradise Valley.
In the LD4 senate race, Aaron Lieberman, a Paradise Valley Democrat, unseated Carine Werner, a Scottsdale Republican and exiting member of the Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board.
The blue wave was strong in LD4, with former Scottsdale City Councilwoman Tammy Caputi – who failed in a Scottsdale City Council reelection bid in 2024 – and fellow Democrat Karen Gresham cruising to victory, unseating Republican incumbents Matt Gress and Pamela Carter.