Unlike O’Sullivan, most of his friends were pursuing careers in higher-paying specialties like radiology or surgery.
To make matters worse, O’Sullivan planned to leave Boston for his residency. It was too expensive, and there just weren’t great opportunities for the sort of training he wanted. So, he chose a program in Fort Worth, Texas.
“First, you tell them that you’re going into primary care and then you tell them that you’re moving to Texas to do it, and you visibly see their minds explode trying to figure out how you can make two stupid moves in one go,” said O’Sullivan, 26.
“It shouldn’t be this way,” he said, shaking his head.
Dr. Collin O’Sullivan checked Leticia Beltran’s ears at John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth, Texas, on Oct. 29. (Shelby Tauber for The Boston Globe)
O’Sullivan, who graduated in May, is one of a shrinking number of Massachusetts-trained doctors pursuing careers as primary care physicians. In 2023, just 14 percent of all new doctors in the state entered primary care, down from 19 percent in 2012. Nationally, that figure remained steady at 22 percent, according to a new report.
In medical school, students are immersed in a culture that prizes specialties over primary care, a catchall term for the doctors of first resort — the ones you see for physicals, screenings, and sore throats. That’s especially true in Massachusetts, where large teaching hospitals dominate medical education, and students rarely encounter PCPs.
“You’re almost indoctrinated that primary care is for second-class citizens, people who aren’t good at other things, and that couldn’t be further from the truth,” said Dr. Michael Silverstein, a health policy expert at Brown University.
The dwindling pipeline of students is a key reason for the shortage of primary care doctors. If the trend doesn’t reverse, there’s little hope of shortening appointment wait times, easing reliance on emergency departments, or curbing health care costs.
As O’Sullivan packed up his South Boston apartment last spring for his Texas move, he questioned whether leaving one of the world’s top medical hubs was the right decision. “There’s not really a better place to study medicine,” he said.
But increasingly, he felt his interest in primary care was out of whack with what Boston’s medical culture valued most.
O’Sullivan moved the last of his boxes out of his apartment before driving to Fort Worth, Texas, on May 18. He is one of just 25 Massachusetts medical school graduates who matched into a family medicine residency. (Jessica Rinaldi/Globe Staff)
Massachusetts is a medical training powerhouse. More than 3,000 students attend its four medical schools — Harvard, Tufts, UMass Chan, and Boston University. And some 1,500 graduates from around the world matched into first-year residency positions at Massachusetts hospitals this year.
Medical students spend four years learning how the body works, how diseases develop, and how to diagnose and treat patients. Then, as newly minted MDs, they enter three- to eight-year residency programs that offer specialized training in their career of choice.
Because hospitals run most residency programs, they largely determine how many doctors are trained and in which fields. And doctors often stay where they complete their residencies.
In Boston, the ecosystem tilts heavily toward specialization.
“Fewer students are choosing primary care partially because the way the larger curriculum is structured gives people in those formative years a lot of exposure to specialties,” said Dr. Michael Fischer, head of internal medicine at Boston Medical Center. “Some of the rewards of primary care, the real depth, takes time, and that’s hard to convey in just a few years.”
Large hospital systems also make most of their money from specialty care, which encourages more investment in fields like cancer, cardiology, and orthopedic surgery.
Dr. Michael Fischer of Boston Medical Center said positive role models are essential to help students envision a future in primary care. (Jessica Rinaldi/Globe Staff)
The hierarchy isn’t new, said Dr. Debra Shapiro, a longtime primary care physician in Cambridge.
In her eyes, the student pipeline to primary care isn’t vanishing — it’s nonexistent. The problem isn’t unique to Massachusetts, she said, but it’s worse here because the academic medical environment tips the balance more sharply toward research and specialty roles.
“If you want to move up, primary care is not what you do,” Shapiro said.
In dozens of interviews and responses to a Boston Globe callout, Massachusetts medical students who hoped to build lifelong relationships with patients as PCPs described moments when they realized their aspirations clashed with a system that lures them toward other fields.
“The city’s highly specialized, high-tech medicine is its hallmark,” said Silverstein, a former pediatrician at Boston Medical Center.
As a result, he added, “It seems easier to get a bone marrow transplant in Boston than a yearly physical.”
For Caroline Morehouse, a second-year Harvard Medical School student considering primary care, choosing a career path also means navigating expectations about what a Harvard-trained doctor should become.
Morehouse, 25, grew up in Connecticut, studied at Oberlin College in Ohio, and spent two years as a research fellow at the National Institutes of Health before entering medical school. Her interest in medicine grew in part from working in a memory care unit while in college, where she saw how illness shaped people’s daily lives.
She was drawn to the idea of knowing patients well enough to understand not just what was wrong with them, but what mattered to them. At a primary care clinic in Jamaica Plain, she watched a physician who knew her patients, understood their priorities, and made time to follow up on concerns.
But at Harvard, surrounded by celebrated specialists, she has questioned whether pursuing primary care would mean not making the most of her coveted education.
In such an environment, she said, caring for the whole person can seem less intellectually rigorous than mastering one specialty or part of the body.
O’Sullivan checked a patient’s blood pressure during an appointment. (Shelby Tauber for The Boston Globe)
“‘Specialty disrespect’ is a documented phenomenon,” said Morehouse. “People tell me, ‘Aren’t you too smart to be a primary care doctor?’”
And students aren’t just absorbing other people’s judgments. They’re watching the work itself.
Dr. Amy Kuhlik, who served for 25 years as dean of student affairs at Tufts University School of Medicine, said primary care rotations expose students to the rewards of longstanding patient relationships but also to exhausted physicians wrestling with insurance approvals, electronic records, and online messages.
“That burnout has a big impact on students, not just on the physicians,” Kuhlik said.
That’s on top of lower salaries. Primary care physicians generally earn less than other doctors, despite managing complex cases and heavy administrative workloads.
Nationally, primary care doctors earn an average of roughly $250,000 a year, according to a Globe analysis of federal wage data, while specialists can make twice as much. And medical students graduating in 2026 with debt carried an average of about $236,000 in educational loans.
Morehouse recalled a classmate who shared her passion for diagnosing patients and solving complex medical problems but wouldn’t consider primary care because of the lower pay.
Dr. Wayne Altman, co-owner of Arlington-based Family Practice Group, sees those decisions as rational.
“Students do rotations, and they observe primary care clinicians running around with their heads cut off,” said Altman, who is also a professor at UMass Chan Medical School. “If I can get paid double to help the world in a different way … and the way I was originally thinking is incredibly stressful, it’s an easy decision.”
For new doctors, three types of residencies can lead to careers in primary care: internal medicine (adult patients), family medicine (adults and children), and pediatrics. But fewer than one-quarter of residents training in primary care will become PCPs.
John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth has internal medicine, family medicine, and pediatrics. (Shelby Tauber for The Boston Globe)
Internal medicine, the largest pathway, is a prerequisite for many specialties, so most internal medicine residents don’t end up becoming PCPs, while nearly all family medicine residents do.
A Globe analysis of Massachusetts medical school graduates found a 23 percent decline in the number of students entering all three subfields over the last decade. The biggest drop was in family medicine: Just 25 graduates matched into family medicine residencies in 2026, down from 54 in 2017. Meanwhile, across the country, the subfield is growing to address rural health disparities.
Harvard Medical School, which runs arguably the most prestigious program in the country, once had a dedicated department of family medicine but no longer does.
Dr. Bernard Chang, dean for medical education at Harvard Medical School, said Harvard tried to revive its family medicine track with a residency at its affiliated hospitals, because it’s the only primary care pathway that trains doctors to care for patients of all ages. The effort failed. Instead, the school has focused on exposing all students to primary care through a yearlong clerkship.
In 2025, Harvard also launched a pilot program pairing interested students with PCPs at community clinics over multiple years. About 15 students are enrolled this year, including eight from the first-year class.
Some see the rise of so-called hospital medicine as another barrier to students and residents considering becoming PCPs. “Hospitalists” are typically internal medicine doctors who care for sick or surgical patients admitted to hospitals. The number of hospitalists nationwide grew by more than 50 percent between 2012 and 2019.
Shapiro, the Cambridge doctor, said primary care physicians used to routinely enter hospitals to care for patients, but in recent years they’ve been displaced by hospitalists. As a result, residents have less exposure to PCPs than they have in the past.
Compared to primary care, hospitalist positions typically pay more and offer more predictable hours, with fewer responsibilities spilling into evenings and weekends.
“A patient once described my job as being the ‘hairdresser of medicine,’ and that really resonated with me,” said Dr. Amanda Whitehouse, a 2021 UMass Chan graduate who works as a PCP in Springfield. “I get to know my patients, celebrate their milestones, support them through difficult times, and care for their families.”
Massachusetts medical schools and policymakers are taking steps to repair a primary care pipeline they acknowledge is broken.
State lawmakers in June approved a $10 million pilot scholarship program that covers some need-based tuition and fees for eligible UMass Chan students who pursue family medicine and commit to practicing for five years in Massachusetts. UMass Chan also offers an accelerated three-year medical degree pathway for students pursuing any type of primary care, allowing them to enter residency a year earlier.
This year, Lowell Community Health Center started a program with Tufts Medicine, adding six family medicine residents after receiving a $500,000 federal grant in 2023. The partnership is based on a first-of-its-kind program in Lawrence that trains doctors in community health settings rather than in hospitals.
Dr. Kumble Rajesh, the Lowell center’s chief medical officer, said primary care shortages and recruitment challenges drove the decision to launch the residency. “There’s so much primary care need here and recruiting is always a challenge,” he said, making it a “no-brainer to try to grow our own residents who will hopefully stay to serve the community.”
O’Sullivan talked with Leticia Beltran during a physical exam at the John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth, Texas. (Shelby Tauber for The Boston Globe)
In Texas, Dr. Collin O’Sullivan, the Boston transplant, is now six months into his family medicine residency at John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth. O’Sullivan marvels at the range of experience he’s gained — far more than if he’d chosen to specialize. He’s performed intubations, endoscopies, and colonoscopies. In one month, he performed 42 circumcisions, something he saw an obstetrician perform only once during his entire training in Boston.
“Now that I’m on the other side, especially in rural schools, you get afforded more autonomy because there’s less hierarchy,” he said.
He frequently sees farmers who travel more than three hours for care. “They don’t want to be referred to a specialist; they want a doctor who can do it all where they are,” he said.
For now, he is ecstatic to be doing work he once had to explain to skeptical classmates.
“The thing that makes me happy is that I’m kind of living it out,” he said. “I’m changing the stereotype I constantly faced. I’m gaining more than my peers in knowledge, and that’s important because the pay and prestige won’t change.”
He hopes the students who shadow him will see something different than the career he was warned against, and that they’ll be more likely to choose primary care.
“It’s where we really do the work that helps people get better,” he said.
Are you a primary care doctor in Mass.? Please take the Globe’s survey here.
O’Sullivan spends a significant amount of time charting patient notes, but is hopeful that artificial intelligence will soon become a useful tool, allowing him more time with patients. (Shelby Tauber for The Boston Globe)
Sarah Rahal can be reached at sarah.rahal@globe.com. Follow her on X @SarahRahal_ or Instagram @sarah.rahal.