Victorians have praised an undecided voter at Tuesday night’s leaders debate for saying “exactly what everyone has been thinking”, after he slammed the election candidates for their lack of transparency and accountability.
Audience member Billy, who sat front and centre for the entire 90-minute debate, expressed to the four political leaders, “nobody believes a word” they say anymore before firing two hard-hitting questions that saw Opposition Leader Jess Wilson gulp and Premier Ben Carroll frown.
Be the first to know when news breaks. Download our new app
“Most of the people that I’m in contact with are all stating the same thing. They finish their sentences with the same disappointment in their voice,” the TAFE teacher said.
“They (say), you guys, politicians are all the same. Who can you trust? They’re all in it for themselves. Their pensions, their perks are the things we can only dream about. They’re so far moved from our reality, it’s ridiculous. Nobody believes a word you’re saying anymore.”
Billy then proceeded with his double-barrelled question which he said was aimed at not just the Liberal and Labor leaders but One Nation Leader Warren Pickering and Victorian Greens Leader Ellen Sandell.
“Given that nobody believes a word that you say, the real issues are around one question, two parts: What specific actions – and it’s to all of you – what specific actions will you take and make to rebuild public trust after years of politically enforced overreach and the recent events and controversies that have affected confidence in all politicians?” he said.
“And how will you increase transparency and accountability, so all Victorians … I’ve met blokes that are rusted on Labor voters who are not voting Labor anymore, rusted on Liberal voters that are not voting on Liberal anymore.
“How will you increase transparency and accountability so all Victorians can see that whatever mistakes are made, they’ll be dealt with in a trustworthy and honourable way – because honourable should be removed from most politicians’ titles.”
Watch the People’s Forum in full on News24
‘I hear you’: Leaders respond
A loud applause echoed throughout the room before Ms Wilson took to the mic.
With conviction, the Liberal Party leader expressed that she “completely heard” Billy’s concerns.
“I hear you that you are fed up with politicians, you’re fed up with the spin and you just don’t trust us anymore,” she said.
“I’ve spoken about this a lot recently. I’ve spoken about the fact that we’ve seen this fall away in trust and government, in our institutions, in our politicians because we have politicians who stand up and make very big promises one side of the election and then do something completely different after. Of course that breaks down trust.”
Ms Wilson acknowledged that she “could not fix everything overnight”, adding she would be “lying” if she said she would fix the state’s pothole, crime and debt crises in the first day of a Liberal government.
She then highlighted how her government would implement a live expenditure tracker to show taxpayers where their money goes.
But on a more “fundamental” note, she said: “It’s on leaders to turn up on the bad days as much as it is on the good days, to take responsibility and most importantly to tell you how we’re going to fix it”.
“It might not be easy, but you deserve honestly from those who you elect,” she said.
Mr Carroll was next to chime in by sharing how on his first day as Premier he vowed to call a Royal Commission into the construction sector.
“I did and it’s up and running. I could have done what others so, ran away from that. I ran towards it because I love the Labor Party and I love the Labor movement,” he said.
“You know what I love even more, the state of Victoria. I’m giving you and every Victorian the answers they deserve and need.”
Mr Pickering was quick to fire back by asking the Premier whether he made those commitments before or after he “knifed his predecessor in the back prior to saying he wouldn’t”.
He then touched on how freedom of information laws gave the government the green light to keep cabinet documents secret and how this should be lifted to ensure transparency.
Finally Ms Sandell said Billy had every right to raise his question before expressing “we just need to follow the money”, in a statement that humoured Mr Pickering.
‘He nailed it’
Despite their spiels, Billy still wasn’t satisfied with their responses.
“Look it’s not going to be fixed with a slogan ‘I’m going to do this’. People want to see change. It’s an experience they want to see, not have lip service paid to,” he said.
Former 3AW Mornings host Neil Mitchell later praised the TAFE teacher’s question.
“He’s got to be premier or he’s got to have his own program, he nailed it and he proved his point because none of them really answered his question, which is how do you restore trust,” he said.
“They deflected and waffled most of the time.”
Billy wasn’t the only talking point of the night, with Mr Carroll’s failure to name his predecessors also making it into water cooler conversations on Wednesday morning.
Ms Wilson mocked the Premier on Tuesday evening for not having the courage to say Daniel Andrews or Jacinta Allan in front of the live audience.
“You can say his (Dan Andrews’) name; it’s OK,” Ms Wilson said.
“I can say their names just as you can say Jeff Kennett’s name,” Mr Carroll hit back.
“Jeff Kennett,” Ms Wilson rebutted.
“You are ashamed of their legacy … They’re not Voldemort.”
The crowd laughed and cheered at the response as Mr Carroll sheepishly went quiet.
Mr Carroll was also labelled a “laughing stock” after he made multiple mistakes when addressing the crowd.
At one stage the flustered Premier called a voter the wrong name twice, despite her interjecting for clarification while in a second instance he confused family titles by referring to a voter’s son-in-law as their son.
Meanwhile, Ms Wilson maintained her conviction throughout the entire 90 minutes, even intervening when her rivals tried to interrupt her by demanding they “let me finish”.
‘Crime is to the s**thouse’
Mr Pickering was also hailed for his description of the state’s crime crisis where he compared Victoria to “Gotham City” from Batman, after an undecided voter expressed that “crime is to the s**thouse”.
“Let’s be honest, it’s terrible, and now we’re seeing vigilantes come out and get themselves in a world of trouble,” he said.
“I don’t give a damn if our prisons are full. You’ve broken the law. You’re going to jail. They’re bringing in a Supermax in New South Wales. That’s where you’re bloody going,” he said.
Ms Wilson said a government under her leadership would go “one step further” after sharing the opinion it was “Labor’s legacy” that crime was “out of control”.
“They weakened the bail laws in this state, and we’ve seen a government that has been weak on crime,” Ms Wilson said.
“That’s why we’ve put in place a one-strike rule for bail. So that if you break bail, you go to jail.
“But we’ll take it one step further … we will create a new Court of Criminal Appeal here in Victoria.”
Ultimately, among all the chaos, Tuesday night’s debate came down to one question – will Labor’s 12-year reign come to an end in Victoria?
In Mr Pickering’s eyes, it is up to Victorians to save the state.
“No one is coming to save us, Victoria, we must do this ourselves,” he said.
Victorian voters will start heading to the polls today with booths closing 6pm on November 28.