The Labor Department has unveiled the final iteration of its independent contractor rule proposed in March, mirroring a regulation passed in the closing months of the first Trump administration (and later withdrawn after President Joe Biden took office).
The rule is the latest iteration of a tug-of-war spanning multiple presidential administrations. It would enable more companies to categorize workers as independent contractors rather than employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act.
Industry advocates like the Financial Services Institute have long pushed for laxer standards, arguing that independent financial advisors choose to be independent contractors for the autonomy it provides. But critics of the 2021 rule argued it could make it more difficult for gig and contract workers to advocate for minimum-wage earnings and overtime protections; the critiques (and potential court challenges) are likely to accompany this iteration as well.
The final rule would rescind a rule passed during the Biden administration, which would have affected some advisors working in affiliation with independent broker/dealers. The Biden-era rule considered whether an employee’s work is “integral” to an employer’s business and restored a “totality-of-the-circumstances” analysis to determine whether a worker qualified for FLSA coverage.
The new rule instills an “economic reality” test, asking employers to consider two “core” factors: the “nature and degree of control over the work” and “the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss based on exercise of initiative or management of investment, or both.” Additionally, the rule says employers could consider the amount of skill required, the degree of permanence of the working relationship, and whether the work “is part of an integrated unit of production.”
The Biden administration opted to withdraw the original rule passed in the final weeks of the Trump administration, with then-DOL Secretary Marty Walsh claiming doing so would stop the “erosion of worker protections.”
However, the FSI and other opponents of the Biden-era rule took the administration to court in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals to halt its implementation (though the litigation sputtered to a halt with Trump’s 2025 inauguration and the DOL’s refusal to continue defending the Biden-era rule).
The FSI met with the White House’s Office of Management and Budget earlier this year to make its case for keeping the protections of the 2021 regulation in its newest iteration. In a statement about the final rule, FSI President and CEO Dale Brown lauded the DOL for “providing greater clarity” for independent advisors and firms.
“Independent financial advisors are entrepreneurs and business owners who have chosen independence so they can build their own businesses, hire staff and better serve clients in their communities,” he said, arguing the new rule “recognizes the realities of the independent business model.”
According to the DOL, the department received more than 16,000 comments during the 60-day comment period. The rule would also apply its analysis of employee vs. independent contractor to the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act.