WATERTOWN, New York (WWNY) – The Watertown city council decided Thursday morning to start over when it comes to finding someone to lease and run the Thompson Park golf course.
The vote was 4-0, with council member Robert Kimball absent.
By its vote, the council rejected a proposal from Andrea Doane, which was submitted in October.
“It’s my view this process has been tainted. I believe it’s incumbent upon council to ensure this process is executed in good faith and with integrity,” said Doug Osborne, the only council member to speak.
“This time the only way to achieve that is to reject the current bid and start over,” he said.
It was not clear Thursday when and how new proposals will be solicited, and what the timeline will be.
After Doane’s proposal was submitted, and after the deadline for submissions had passed, another one came in from Watertown developer and owner of Ives Hill golf course, Jake Johnson, and restaurateur Shannon Exford.
Before the meeting, Doane sent a letter to council comparing her proposal to the Johnson proposal. It points out that Doane’s offer shares golf course revenue with the city. (Article continues below letter)
Doane proposed a one-year lease with an option to renew up to three more years, which could be negotiated.
Doane would lease the course for $21,000 annually. She was the only person to submit a proposal by the city’s deadline.
The Johnson/Exford proposal calls for an initial 10-year lease with two 5-year options. The lease would pay the city $25,000 a year for the first five years, then increase 2% a year. Over a decade, the payments would total more than a quarter million dollars.
The proposal says Exford and Johnson would commit to a set financial level of improvements to the clubhouse and course over the first five years.
Copyright 2026 WWNY. All rights reserved.