Seven years ago, the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) tried to fire a public housing supervisor named Brianne Pawson, after she’d been accused of helping lead “a culture of misconduct” at the Throggs Neck Houses in the Bronx.
Now, the NBC New York I-Team has learned NYCHA is promoting Pawson to a senior advisory position, helping advise on the entire agency’s supply chain.
“It’s a slap in the face to the residents of NYCHA,” said Council Member Chris Banks, who chairs the Committee on Public Housing. “I think anybody in the public would say we needed to pass on this. We needed to go in a different direction.”
In 2019, Pawson was the subject of scathing testimony before the New York City Council, when Margaret Garnett, then the city’s Department of Investigation Commissioner, told an oversight committee that Pawson engaged in a list of misdeeds as one of the supervisors at Throggs Neck Houses, a public housing development with more than 3,000 residents.
According to Garnett, Pawson engaged in “regular and extensive alcohol use on the job,” along with “time-and-leave abuse,” and “sabotage of NYCHA appliances intended for residents’ apartments.” The former DOI Commissioner also cited evidence that Pawson split up a large contractor job into multiple smaller contracts to circumvent procurement rules.
The Throggs Neck scandal led NYCHA brass to seek Pawson’s termination based on a series of lesser charges, including making a derogatory sexual comment and one instance of possessing alcohol while on the job. When Pawson later appealed NYCHA’s decision, the New York City Civil Service Commission (CSC) found that misconduct warranted “a serious penalty greater than a reprimand,” but reversed the order of termination – upholding a sixty-day suspension.
Lehra Brooks, the Throggs Neck Houses Tenant Association President, said she lived in the complex and served on the tenants’ Executive Board when NYCHA first tried to terminate Pawson. She believes it sends the wrong message to now promote Pawson after trying to fire her.
“Basically, you reward the error, which means that somewhere down the line it will happen again,” Brooks said. “She let us down. She let this whole development down.”
State Senator Nathalia Fernandez (D – Throggs Neck), who represents residents who live in the Throggs Neck Houses, also criticized the appointment.
“I want to believe that there are qualified people out there who don’t have a bad record,” she said. “It really does show me another example of NYCHA’s lack of an ability to have good management,”
Despite the blemish on Pawson’s disciplinary record, NYCHA’s top brass is standing behind her promotion to the title Senior Advisor to the SVP of Supply Chain Management.
“Ms. Pawson serves in a position commensurate with her civil service title, qualifications, and experience,” said Barbara Brancaccio, NYCHA’s Chief Communications Officer. “Her continued – now 17 year – employment and advancement with NYCHA is the result of not only her hard work and determination, but also the Authority’s extraordinary collaboration with labor partners and its commitment to mentor, strengthen, build, and protect New York City’s municipal workforce.”
When asked about DOI investigation, which found evidence Pawson abused her former position at Throggs Neck Houses, Brancaccio said NYCHA has since made “remarkable progress to transform the Authority’s culture” while at the same time suggesting the DOI investigation, itself, was flawed.
“[W]e will not entertain the rehashing of a sensational, long-resolved, nearly decade-old investigation to undermine these achievements,” she said.
But the DOI is standing by its original findings related to Pawson. In a statement to the I-Team, the agency said it provided NYCHA with substantiated evidence of “a number of misconduct allegations that were properly referred to NYCHA.”
“DOI stands by the very detailed testimony delivered by former Commissioner Margaret Garnett to the City Council in 2019, which states that DOI conducted a thorough, independent investigation and determined a number of findings, including ‘extremely troubling evidence of a culture of misconduct, employee mistreatment and retaliation led by the two managers at [Throggs Neck Houses],’ one of whom was Brianne Pawson,” the statement read.
Attempts to reach Pawson for comment have been unsuccessful. Hugo Ortega, the attorney who represented her before the CSC told the I-Team he no longer represents her. A spokesperson for Teamsters Local 237, the union that formerly represented Pawson during her time at the Throggs Neck Houses, said the union has no contact information for her.
Neither Pawson nor her boss, Tony Maldonado, SVP of Supply Chain Management, returned phone messages for comment.
According to NYCHA, Pawson’s elevation is still provisional, because she has yet to take and pass the “Administrative Storekeeper” civil service exam. That exam schedule for that test, and for all civil service titles, is set by the city’s Department of Citywide Administrative Services.
Emily Lucas, an employment and labor attorney, said government managers in New York often hire candidates as “provisional” employees and then schedule them for the next available civil service exam. She added that most prior misconduct findings, like the ones against Pawson,do not disqualify an applicant from vying for a new civil service title.
“The law sets forth very specific reasons to disqualify somebody from eligibility lists in the future. Those types of things are like committing a crime, falsifying your employment application, [or] being terminated from a civil service position which is the same or similar to the one in which you are applying for,” Lucas said.
The 2019DOI investigative report found she had previously tried to circumvent NYCHA procurement rules by splitting up a job to power wash Throggs Neck buildings into five smaller contracts, each less than $5,000. DOI investigators said the “bid splitting” allowed Pawson to avoid procurement rules that require multiple bids to ensure the best deal.
Council Member Banks said the decision to promote Pawson is most troubling to him, because she is now advising on agency-wide supply chain issues, some of them involving contracts and procurement.
“To place her as an advisor in the same unit to oversee or to give advice to whoever the principal may be, that’s concerning,” Banks said. “I think it’s incumbent upon the City Council to seriously investigate this. To take a look at this. To provide some oversight. To see how this whole process went.
NYCHA declined to answer specific questions about the prior allegations of bid-splitting against Pawson or why she never faced administrative charges for alleged bid-splitting.