On Monday, the San Diego City Council voted unanimously to shut off the city’s automated license plate readers and end its contract with the vendor. I spent more than 29 years in law enforcement, the final five as chief of the El Cajon Police Department, and I have followed this debate closely.
The vote did not happen in isolation. Cities across the country have dropped license plate reader contracts this year amid a national backlash over surveillance and federal immigration enforcement. Councilmember Stephen Whitburn said his view of the technology’s effectiveness had not changed, but the national context had. Late in the debate, the council also learned the Police Department had used the system during an internal investigation involving a domestic violence victim.
I don’t question the council members’ intentions. This is a serious issue, and they made a hard call under real public pressure. But misuse can happen with any tool police use, from a patrol car to a records database. When it happens, you hold people accountable and tighten the rules. Getting rid of the tool takes away what works along with what went wrong.
The harder question is what comes next, and the answer reaches past city limits. El Cajon, Chula Vista, La Mesa, National City and Oceanside all use license plate readers, and people who commit crimes do not stop at city lines.
I can speak to what the technology does. As chief, I watched license plate reader data help my detectives solve the murders of two teenagers. I am not sure that case would have been solved without it. I am certain it would not have been solved as quickly. In another case, the technology helped us quickly locate a murder suspect in an active shooting, and we apprehended him before he could cause further harm to the community.
San Diegans should also understand where the leading opposition wants this to end. The ACLU’s lawsuit, filed in September, asks the court to halt the city’s use, remove the hardware and delete the data. The Electronic Frontier Foundation’s published policy puts elimination first and calls the technology “irredeemably harmful.” In San Diego, the goal is removal, and voters deserve to hear that stated plainly. It is the wrong goal for a city that wants fewer victims.
I believe part of that position comes from a broader agenda. The ACLU has long campaigned to cut the nation’s jail and prison population in half, and any tool that raises the odds of being caught works against that goal. I see it the other way. Decades of research show the certainty of being caught deters crime far more than the severity of punishment. Tools that raise that certainty mean fewer victims and, over time, fewer people behind bars.
What went wrong here can be fixed with clear rules. If the city revisits this, those rules belong in the use policy itself. Every search should be tied to a case number and a stated, legitimate purpose. Access should be logged and audited on a regular schedule, with the results made public. The department should report each year how often the readers helped solve cases and how violations were handled. Officers who break the rules should lose access, and criminal misuse should be prosecuted.
The vendor is a separate question, and it is the council’s call. Whether San Diego police can use this tool at all is the decision that will shape public safety here for years.
When this question comes back, and I expect it will, council members should ask the critics one direct question: Is there any set of rules under which you would support this technology? If the answer is no, the debate is about whether police should be able to solve crimes this way at all.
I have sat with the families of murder victims. After nearly three decades in law enforcement, knowing what this technology does to solve crimes, I know San Diego is at least a little less safe today than it was before Monday’s vote.
Moulton is a retired chief of police for the city of El Cajon, with more than 29 years in law enforcement. He is the principal of Moulton Consulting Group, which advises public safety technology companies.