Image courtesy of Lov2xlr8

For last week’s “Settle The Debate,” we argued what 1990s sport truck was the best. For this week, we will stick with something truck-related: Which well-regarded diesel engine would you choose? The second-generation 5.9-liter Cummins or the second-generation 7.3-liter Powerstroke? In other words, Dodge or Ford?

In debates like this, I tend to give more context, so let’s say you are choosing between a 1999 Dodge Ram 3500 powered by the Cummins and a 1999 Ford F-350 equipped with the Powerstroke. You need the truck to travel the country and tow a heavier fifth-wheel trailer — it’s a long journey, and you want something reliable but inexpensive.

Cummins 5.9-liter 24V Inline-six Turbo Diesel: Found in 1998½-2002 Dodge Ram 2500 and 3500 trucks, this more-than-capable engine evolved from its previous generation to include 4 valves per cylinder instead of 2. The new generation also brought a fuel system upgrade in which the mechanical P-pump was replaced with the electronically controlled Bosch VP44 injection pump. Rated at 235 horsepower and 460 lb-ft of torque, the second-generation Cummins saw reduced emissions, an increase in power, and greater airflow. That being said, the Bosch VP44 would be known for having reliability issues, which puts a damper on an otherwise impressive engine. Nowadays, you can purchase mechanical and electronic upgrades for the pump, so the factory issue does not have to be your issue.

To view this 2000 Dodge Ram 2500 listed for sale on ClassicCars.com, click the above image.

Powerstroke 7.3-liter V-8 Turbo Diesel: When Ford debuted the Super Duty lineup in 1999, it brought heavier frames, upgraded transmissions, an improved fueling system, and a redesigned 7.3-liter Powerstroke V-8 midway through the model year. This engine would become a mainstay until 2003. Featuring a solid cast-iron block, Caterpillar-built HEUI fuel system, and a Garrett GTP38 turbocharger, the 7.3 was rated at 235 horsepower and 500 lb-ft of torque. The most common Achilles heel for this engine is the cam position sensor (CPS) — when the CPS fails, your engine will either refuse to start or stall unexpectedly. Similar to the Cummin’s VP44 issues, there are upgrades that can be purchased to alleviate this common issue. Some sites even suggest purchasing a spare and keeping it in your glove box at all times.

To view this 2003 Ford F-350 listed for sale on ClassicCars.com, click the above image

Which would you pick? Would your chosen truck have four-wheel-drive? Tell us in the Comments section below.