The Los Angeles City Council tabled a vote Friday on two City Charter amendment proposals seeking to reduce the mayor’s executive directive abilities and power over department heads.
On Friday, Councilman Tim McOsker asked his colleagues on the City Council to send the two proposals back to the Ad Hoc Committee on Charter Review for further discussion, which they agreed on. McOsker serves as committee chair.
Critics of the proposals raised concerns over how abrupt those two items came before the City Council, adding that it seemed strange how quickly the motions were ready to be voted as soon as Nithya Raman won the race to serve as L.A.’s next mayor.
City Councilwoman Raman, represents the 4th Council District, ascended to mayoral office with support from younger voters. She had received an endorsement from the local chapter of the Democratic Socialist of America, though that in itself was a complicated matter as she faced opposition from the larger national organization.
Days before, City Controller Kenneth Mejia described the effort as “shady” in a short video he posted on social media.
“The past year and a half, the city has been working on charter reform. We’ve been having large discussions with the public, with committees, talking about issues to change the constitution of the city of Los Angeles, which is the City Charter,” Mejia said in his video.
“Now, just recently, we elected a new mayor, and all of a sudden, this Friday, the City Council wants to vote on basically weakening the power of the mayor,” Mejia added.
Both motions were introduced in May.
The first proposal — introduced by Councilwoman Ysabel Jurado and seconded by Bob Blumenfield — would give the City Council the authority to remove a general manager by a two-third vote.
The second proposal — introduced by Councilwoman Monica Rodriguez and seconded by McOsker — would allow the City Council to change or overturn the mayor’s executive directives by a two-thirds vote.
Under the City Charter, the mayor has the authority to issue executive directives, or give instructions or orders to city departments, as well as to appoint general managers and commission members. The City Council has the ability to confirm or deny new appointments in this process.
McOsker explained Friday that the two motions came before the council for a vote so as to signal whether they want to move forward with them.
The Ad Hoc Committee on Charter Review is expected to start discussions for the next set of charter amendment proposals with the goal of having the items placed on the November 2028 ballot. Any proposed charter amendments will require multiple rounds of voting, with final say to be determined by the voters.
“We had a whole bunch of information that went out to the public that said we were trying to act today to change the charter,” McOsker said. “Well, it’s civics 101, folks. We can’t change the charter today. We can’t change it tomorrow. In fact, because we just had an election, we are at the farthest temporal point away from changing the charter that any human being could be.”
Council President Marqueece Harris-Dawson criticized Mejia for his video and called him a liar.
“The motion was made before there was even a new mayor, and Mr. McOsker signaled that all motions about the charter reform were coming to the charter committee, and so again, I’m loath to criticize any other elected member, but when you tell a bald-faced lie that you know better about your colleagues, it has to be called out,” Harris-Dawson said.
On Wednesday, the City Council approved a work plan and schedule for the Ad Hoc Committee on Charter Reform.
The ad hoc committee is scheduled to meet Nov. 30 for its next meeting with discussions on “Who Governs? Separation of Powers & Institutional Structure,” to begin.
Discussion on the theme will examine the mayor’s and council’s separation of powers, executive authority, oversight, checks and balances, general manager authority and accountability. Future topics of discussion, include but are not limited to, council expansion, elections, budget and operations, among other topics.
The city is moving forward with plans to implement eight measures that voters approved on the Nov. 3 ballot. Two of those measures are tax-related, while the other six alter various aspects of the City Charter and how the government works.
The council initiated a process to amend the City Charter, following a leaked racially charged audio recording in 2022. The conversation centered on abusing the redistricting process to coalesce power for members.
Four former City Council members also faced separate corruption scandals that resulted in federal charges, which contributed to calls for governance reform and greater transparency and accountability.