The Illinois Public Interest Research Group (PIRG) wants Peoples Gas to stop retiring Chicago’s old iron pipes (“It’s time to end Peoples Gas’ wasteful pipe replacement program,” Nov. 17). It’s a dangerous idea that ignores who ordered this work.

In 2025, the Illinois Commerce Commission ordered Peoples Gas to retire more than 1,000 miles of aging iron pipe. The rate filing reflects that mandate.

These pipes are nearing the end of their useful lives, and reliable heat is a public safety obligation. Nobody thinks about infrastructure until it fails, as the country just saw on Nov. 13 when the Federal Aviation Administration grounded flights nationwide for nearly five hours.

PIRG’s claim that Peoples Gas will spend $5.5 billion to achieve $60 million in safety benefits, a penny on the dollar, rests on flawed methodology. No spreadsheet can price safe, dependable heat for millions of people.

Furthermore, PIRG calls excavation damage the biggest threat. That is a case for highly trained union workers, not for leaving aging pipe in the ground.

PIRG began this rate case planning to ask the ICC to enforce the reforms it applauded last year. Now it wants to end pipe replacement. That isn’t reform. It’s walking away from a safety mandate.

The argument that this investment slows the shift to clean-energy homes doesn’t work. Gas is the most affordable, reliable heat in a cold-climate city, and all-electric bills would be at least two times higher. If all homes and all vehicles became electric, reinforcing the U.S. distribution grid could cost $350 billion to $790 billion, or $2,000 to $6,400 per household through 2050, with peak demand in the coldest regions up to five times higher.

Then there is reliability. In July, ComEd asked customers to cut back because the electric grid was under “critical strain.” Relying on that in January is a gamble.

State agencies are sounding the same alarm. The Illinois Power Agency and Illinois Environmental Protection Agency recommend delaying the phaseout of gas- and oil-fired power plants by nearly three years, to 2033, citing a “resource adequacy risk over the coming decade” as data center demand surges.

If the state is hedging on supply, pushing Chicago homes toward all-electric heat is a bet we can’t afford.

Peoples Gas and the ICC share a responsibility to keep the system safe, bills low and energy dependable. Walking away from pipe retirement risks all three. Chicago needs to finish the job the ICC ordered.

— James M. Sweeney, president-business manager, International Union of Operating Engineers Local 150, Countryside

‘SNL’ skit speaks to a real issue

Last weekend, “Saturday Night Live” aired a humorous yet painfully familiar skit that hit home for women caring for loved ones in an increasingly expensive healthcare system. Its timing is relevant: November is National Family Caregivers Month, recognizing 63 million unpaid caregivers across the U.S. who hold our families and care systems together.

The skit resonates because it reflects reality. In Illinois, 71% of the estimated 2.2 million family caregivers are women.

This comedy skit makes us laugh, but it should also inspire our families, communities and society to do better. While caregiving can be a treasured opportunity to spend time with loved ones, it can impact caregivers’ careers, financial security, and physical and emotional well-being.

Too often, families fail to plan, leaving one person to coordinate appointments, manage medications, communicate with healthcare providers and provide hands-on care while balancing work and family responsibilities. The Illinois Family Caregiver Coalition recently partnered with state Sen. Laura Murphy of Des Plaines to introduce Senate Resolution 975, recognizing family caregivers.

The need is clear: 62% of Illinois caregivers juggle jobs while caregiving, 47% experience negative financial impacts and many receive no help with care, paid or unpaid.

The skit offers an opportunity for action at three levels.

Families must start conversations before a crisis, develop shared care plans, and recognize everyone can contribute through direct care, transportation, finances or respite. Communities can strengthen support through employers, healthcare providers, faith organizations, nonprofits and local services such as the Area Agencies on Aging.

Policymakers must turn recognition into resources. With just $5.3 million in state funding supporting family caregivers assisting older adults, Illinois must do more. We urge the governor and the General Assembly to increase investments in caregiver services, respite care and stronger family leave policies.

Let’s move beyond celebrating the fictional “sister” and support real-life caregivers. They deserve more than a thank you. They deserve shared family responsibility, supportive communities and a strong care system.

Caring for loved ones should never mean sacrificing caregivers’ own health and well-being.

— Amy Brennan, executive director, Illinois Family Caregiver Coalition

Story of the haves, have-nots

The Tuesday Tribune was excellent at showing in every section the difference between the haves and have-nots in our society.

The news section discussed the issue of inflated premiums for the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare (“Illinois consumers see higher ACA prices”). Prices increased for one couple from $200 to $750 a month. That is a 375% increase. Other increases cited were small but still very substantial for people living paycheck to paycheck. Our current government not carrying over subsidies is the cause of the increases.

In the Business section, there were two articles of interest. Workers in three Chicago hotels have gone on strike for higher wages and benefits (“Workers strike at 3 Chicago hotels”). These workers are room attendants, dishwashers, servers and front desk agents, mostly low-wage workers. Many are hardworking individuals trying to raise a family. It seems the union is negotiating in good faith. The second article in this section is about CEOs being let go for inappropriate contact with subordinates (“Huang joins growing club”). The former McDonalds CEO was discharged and had to repay the company $105 million in money and stock. How can the CEO of this company earn that amount of compensation when the employees on the line earn minimum wage or near minimum?

Finally, in the Sports section, Brad Biggs answered a fan’s question as to how much monetary support the Bears have to provide to Jeffery Simmons, recently obtained via trade (“Ask the reporter”). Per the NFL Players Association agreement, the Bears need to cover airfare, pay two months of rent or mortgage in the player’s old city, pay moving expenses for the family and pay housing expenses in the new city for seven days. Star NFL players are currently earning millions of dollars. Do they really need these extra benefits?

I am glad that the Tribune published all these articles in a single issue, as it helped show me how unjust our society is to the have-nots. Perhaps our new Congress, which will have representatives of multiple religions, races and genders, will be able to forge an alliance to help bring better conditions to the ones in need.

— Cary Riske, Grayslake

Submit a letter, of no more than 400 words, to the editor here or email letters@chicagotribune.com.