In the 156-year history of college football, many different programs have been looked at as the top dogs of the sport.
There is a constant debate among fans and personalities about who the greatest college football programs of all time are. Most fans know who the consensus number one program of all time is, but after that, it’s pretty wide open.
The goal today is simple: Find the 10 best college football programs of all time.
13 programs were considered for the list, as they are the 13 programs most synonymous with college football.
More NCAA Football Content From TWSN:
The Rules
There are 13 programs in consideration for this list, and those 13 teams were ranked from 1 to 13 based on seven different categories. If you were first in a certain category, you receive one point. If you were second, you receive two points, and so on.
The categories are as follows:
Most Wins, most claimed National Championships, most Heisman Trophy winners, most weeks at #1 in the AP Poll, best Bowl Game winning %, most Conference Championships, and most Consensus All-Americans.
The teams were then ranked from worst to best, with the team that had the lowest total points being crowned the king of college football.
The 13 teams in consideration are as follows:
Alabama
Clemson
Florida State
Georgia
LSU
Miami
Michigan
Nebraska
Notre Dame
Ohio State
Oklahoma
Texas
USC
Now that the teams and rules are out of the way, let’s look at the teams that just missed the cut.
The Honorable Mentions
The three teams that were on the outside looking in were the Clemson Tigers with 78 points, the Miami Hurricanes with 74 points, and the LSU Tigers with 64 points.
There is tons of history with those three programs, including the fact that each of them has one of the greatest college football teams, if not the three best college football teams of all time.
These three programs missing out let you know just how tough it was to make the top 10. Now, let’s move on to the main attraction.
Top 10 College Football Programs Of All Time
These 10 programs embody excellence in every way and stand above all the others as the very best of all time.
Disclaimer: There was a tie to start things off, surprisingly, so we will break the tie by a head-to-head record between the two programs, for this time only.
10- Florida State Seminoles
Total points: 58
Florida State is on the wrong side of the only tiebreaker used for this list, but they’re on the list as the 10th-best college football program of all time.
The Seminoles were at or near the bottom of a few of the bigger categories, but what really helped them was their winning percentage in Bowl Games, which is .610, good enough for third among all other teams on the list.
What hurt them most was their total wins, as they have only 583, which is the least of any program on the list, and their claimed National Championship count is only three, tied for last with Clemson.
The team from Tallahassee is still one of college football’s premier programs, even if they may not feel like it after a very bad 2024 season.
9- Georgia Bulldogs
Total points: 58
Georgia gets the ninth spot due to having a better head-to-head record against Florida State, but both teams had 58 total points.
They were middle of the pack in most categories, but they were never at the very bottom, so it saved them a lot. The thing that did help them out the most is how great they have been in Bowl Games.
They have a .627 winning percentage in Bowl Games, which is the second best of any team in the running for this list, but it was the only category they truly excelled.
As mentioned, what really hurt the Bulldogs most was the fact that they were mostly in the middle of the pack for all of the other categories, coming close to last in a few, but they’re still here, and it’s all that matters.
8- Texas Longhorns
Total points: 54
Texas is one of those programs that may seem like they should be higher on the list, and that’s probably due to just how culturally relevant they are as a whole. Bevo is one of, if not the most recognizable, mascots in the country, the Longhorn logo is perhaps the most recognizable in college sports, and they have Matthew McConaughey roaming the sidelines of every home game, which makes them even cooler.
Texas has 961 total wins, four claimed Natty’s, and two Heisman Trophy winners, which may all seem like low numbers when you think about Texas football, but once again, a lot of the hype around Texas can center around the cultural relevance and “Aura” of the brand, and not exactly the program itself, but that goes for every team, just a little more so for the Horns.
What held them back was definitely the lower National Championship and Heisman Trophy winners total, as they were near the bottom in both.
Still, though, they’re a top-five program in total wins, they’ve got 34 Conference Championships, 63 All-Americans, and burnt orange is a pretty good color that looks good on anybody.
7- Nebraska Cornhuskers
Total points: 48
Nebraska hasn’t felt like they should as a program in quite some time, but even though they’ve not been the same for the last 20 or so years, they are still a very rich football program with tons of tradition and history.
Three of the program’s five claimed National Championships came in the ‘90s when they were THE dynasty. The ’90s Nebraska teams are among some of the best of all time, and they’re a huge reason that Nebraska has been so prominent in college football, as many fans still have amazing memories of how dominant those teams were.
What helps them out a lot is the fact that they’ve won 46 Conference Championships, which is the second most of the programs on the list. However, what hurts them is their .500 record in Bowl Games, which was the third worst of the 13 teams in the running.
Things are also looking up for the program right now under Matt Rhule, as they’re still selling out each home game and keeping their great traditions alive, and with Dylan Raiola at quarterback, maybe they can make some noise over the next few years to get Cornhusker football all the way back on the map.
6- Michigan Wolverines
Total points: 39
The first half of the sport’s greatest rivalry is the first team on this list that I would consider to be “College Football Royalty.”
The big, bulky “M” is right there with the Longhorn as college football’s most recognizable logo; they play in the sport’s biggest stadium, properly named “The Big House”, and they are the winningest college football program in history, with 1,012 victories, being the only program to surpass that 1,000 mark.
The Wolverines also have the second most claimed National Championships of all time with 12, and they’re top three among teams on the list in Conference Championships with 45, and All-Americans with 89.
What keeps them from being higher on the list is their poor Bowl Game record of 24-29, which is a .453 winning percentage, as well as the fact that they’ve only spent 36 weeks at the top of the AP Poll, which was the 2nd least of every team on the list. They do have a winning record over Ohio State, though, and some will tell you that matters more than any other stat on the list.
5- Notre Dame Fighting Irish
Total points: 36
Notre Dame gets clowned for not having sat at the big boy table since Rudy, but there is some truth to it, as they’re the only team on the list that hasn’t won a National Championship in the last 35 years.
Still, though, the Golden Domers have a pretty rich history and some impressive numbers to back it up, even if they’ve not played like a champion since 1988 (sorry guys).
962 total wins, 11 claimed National Championships, seven Heisman Trophy winners, 98 weeks at #1 in the AP Poll, and 109 All-Americans is good enough for the top four in each of those categories.
The MASSIVE thing holding them back? Zero Conference Championships. Yep, being an independent quite literally made the difference in Notre Dame being fifth on the list and possibly being FIRST on the list. Style points for Touchdown Jesus, though.
4- Oklahoma Sooners
Total points: 30
The other half of the Red River Rivalry makes it to the Mount Rushmore of college football programs. They may not have a winning record against Texas, but they’ve got a lot more history than Texas in almost every way.
Oklahoma has 950 total wins, seven claimed Natty’s, seven Heisman Trophy winners, 98 weeks at #1, a record 50 Conference Championships, and 82 All-Americans, as well as the honor of being “Quarterback University”.
If anything is holding the Sooners back, it is probably their All-American count, which is still great, but they’re VERY close behind two schools on that list that happen to be above them on this respective list.
Overall, Oklahoma is a wildly consistent program that wasn’t near the bottom of any category, and is at the top or near the top of most, so here lands Boomer Sooner.
3- USC Trojans
Total points: 28
Here is the West Coast representation that some have been waiting for.
USC is easily one of the coolest programs in the country for a multitude of reasons, from playing in the LA Coliseum, to the wide range of celebrities that populate the sidelines, to the fact that they had some of the most culturally relevant teams of all time in the early-to-mid 2000s headlined by Matt Leinart and Reggie Bush that would reshape the sport as we knew it.
The Trojans have 11 claimed National Championships, a record eight Heisman Trophy winners, 91 weeks at #1, 37 Conference Championships, 84 All-Americans, and the best Bowl Game winning percentage of any team on the list, with a 36-20 record at .643%.
The only thing holding them back is their total win count. With 882 total wins, the Trojans have only the ninth most wins of the teams on this list, but being top three is still a great feat.
2- Ohio State Buckeyes
Total points: 27
Here is the other half of the sport’s greatest rivalry. They’re also following in Oklahoma’s footsteps of losing against their greatest rival more often than not, but making up for it by being a better overall program.
Maybe they have the most obnoxious fan base in the sport, but when looking at the history and numbers, you can understand why, because if your program had this kind of success, you’d be over the top too.
978 wins, nine claimed Natty’s, seven Heisman Trophy winners, 106 weeks at #1, 41 Conference Championships, and 93 All-Americans puts them in the top two for most of those categories and top five for the others, so what’s keeping them from the top spot?
It’s pretty much the fact that they have the fourth-worst Bowl Game winning percentage of all teams on this list at .508, just one game over .500. It took them down a notch, and the other thing holding them back is that Ohio State wasn’t first in any category. Still good enough for the runner-up spot, but it’s time to move on to the program that everyone likely knew would be at #1.
1- Alabama Crimson Tide
Total points: 24
When you think of college football, you think of the Alabama Crimson Tide before anything else. Bear Bryant and Nick Saban, Bryant-Denny Stadium, Dixieland Delight, they’ve got it all. The most dominant force in the history of college athletics is the football team from Tuscaloosa.
974 total wins, a record 18 claimed National Championships, four Heisman Trophy winners, a record 141 weeks at #1 in the AP Poll, a .609 Bowl Game winning percentage, 34 Conference Championships, and 84 All-Americans.
It’s an impressive history that Alabama carries to say the least. They’re the most consistent and well-rounded program the sport has ever seen, and for that, it lands them at #1, just like many of you probably expected.