The Colorado Avalanche have run out of excuses.

Should the Avalanche suffer yet another premature postseason exit, the likelihood of consequential change—whether a targeted dismissal or a more sweeping organizational overhaul—becomes difficult to dispute. That prospect would be magnified exponentially were the club to succumb to a third consecutive playoff defeat at the hands of the Dallas Stars. Such an outcome ought to weigh on every echelon of leadership, from general manager Chris MacFarland to head coach Jared Bednar. Yet, the more constructive course is neither to dwell on apprehension nor to resign oneself to inevitability, but rather to transmute that pressure into purpose—a disciplined, collective resolve to capture another championship before the current window of contention closes.

The most significant transformations of Colorado’s offseason unfolded not on the ice, but behind the bench. Assistant coach Ray Bennett was dismissed, opening the door for the arrival of Dave Hakstol, the inaugural head coach of the Seattle Kraken. In a twist of sporting irony, it was under Hakstol’s guidance that the expansion franchise eliminated the reigning Stanley Cup champion Avalanche in the opening round of the 2022–23 playoffs. His extensive knowledge of the game, coupled with a reputation for engineering elite power-play units, should prove an asset to Bednar’s staff, particularly given the Avalanche’s struggles in that department during recent seasons under Bennett.

In addition, Colorado bolstered its developmental resources with the appointment of Mark Popovic as skills coach. A second-round selection (35th overall) by the then–Anaheim Mighty Ducks in the 2001 NHL Entry Draft, Popovic went on to appear in 81 NHL contests—80 of them with the now-defunct Atlanta Thrashers. Most recently, he has served as a consultant for both the Avalanche and their AHL affiliate, the Colorado Eagles, contributing to training and development camps while working closely with individual players throughout the season.

What emerges, then, is a multilayered familiarity. Bednar enters his tenth season at the helm of the Avalanche, Hakstol has already demonstrated the capacity to outmaneuver Colorado under the unforgiving glare of the postseason, and Popovic has been embedded within the organization for years. Yet this continuity of faces contrasts sharply with one of the franchise’s most persistent recent criticisms: an overreliance on short-term solutions. Rather than cultivating a cohesive brotherhood grounded in chemistry, mutual trust, and sustained commitment, the club has too often pursued the path of mercenaries and rental acquisitions. The result, more often than not, has been costly—both in performance and in the erosion of long-term identity.

There’s No Excuses Left

There is, in truth, little justification for why Colorado should not contend for—and capture—another Stanley Cup. Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar stand as two of the most transcendent talents of their generation. Valeri Nichushkin appears fully healthy and poised to have a great season, while Martin Nečas, a burgeoning star in his own right, brings a dynamic skill set—though questions remain as to whether his tenure in Denver will be a lasting one. Most notably, Captain Gabriel Landeskog returns to the lineup for the first time in three full seasons. While his offensive output may no longer match its peak, his shot remains of elite caliber, and his leadership—long absent—has been an intangible the locker room has sorely missed.

For several years, the Avalanche have boasted one of the NHL’s most formidable top-six forward groups—at least on paper. Yet injuries and off-ice complications have persistently undermined that potential. In the wake of Landeskog’s extended absence following knee surgery, his various replacements have collectively missed 55 games over the past three seasons—a disruption that cannot be dismissed as marginal. Evan Rodrigues, during his single season in Colorado, was sidelined for 13 contests, while Jonathan Drouin—whose performance has oscillated between bursts of productivity and prolonged inconsistency—was absent for nearly half of last season.

And that’s just the tip of the iceberg.

When Nichushkin and Artturi Lehkonen are both in the lineup, the Avalanche are, more often than not, a formidable force. Their concurrent absence, however, creates a void that is exceptionally difficult to fill. Over the past three seasons, the duo has missed a combined 164 games—a striking total given their standing among the league’s premier two-way checking forwards. Nichushkin accounts for more than half of those absences, the result of a complex intersection of injuries and personal challenges. Inevitably, some players are more susceptible to such setbacks than others; it is, as the saying goes, part of the nature of the game. Still, the Avalanche will be hoping for these two to remain strong throughout the campaign.

Colorado can no longer rely on goaltending as a convenient rationale for underperformance. The Avalanche engineered a significant trade, sending Alexandar Georgiev, alongside Nikolai Kovalenko, a 2025 conditional fifth-round pick, and a 2026 second-round selection to the San Jose Sharks in exchange for Mackenzie Blackwood, Givani Smith, and a 2027 fifth-round pick. Indeed, one might argue that Colorado now commands one of the NHL’s elite goaltending tandems, pairing Blackwood with Scott Wedgewood, the latter of whom arguably possesses starter-caliber potential. This pairing inevitably evokes comparisons to the 2008 Stanley Cup–champion Detroit Red Wings, who relied heavily on the formidable duo of Chris Osgood and Dominik Hasek en route to their title.

The trade sending Bowen Byram to the Buffalo Sabres in exchange for Casey Mittelstadt in 2024 stands as a strategic misjudgment of considerable consequence. While Byram contended with injury setbacks early in his career, he remained widely regarded as an elite defenseman with the potential to serve as a foundational pillar on Colorado’s blue line. Mittelstadt, despite a promising outset—registering 10 points in his initial 18 games with the Avalanche—experienced a marked decline in production the following season, tallying 34 points (11 goals, 23 assists) over 63 games. Most notably, his shooting percentage plummeted from 20% in his first 11 contests to a mere 6.5% across the subsequent 33 games, underscoring a significant offensive regression.

The trade was ostensibly designed to address Colorado’s persistent struggles at the second-line center position. Yet, rather than ameliorating these issues, the move exacerbated them—and in the process, the Avalanche relinquished a core defensive asset for no reason. Byram subsequently completed his first full 82-game regular season, achieving career highs in both assists (31) and points (38). Meanwhile, Mittelstadt’s tenure proved fleeting; he was subsequently traded to the Boston Bruins for Charlie Coyle, who has since departed the organization as well.

The Avalanche’s tumultuous trajectory continued when they traded promising prospect Calum Ritchie along with a 2026 draft pick to the New York Islanders in exchange for Brock Nelson. Unlike Charlie Coyle, Nelson remains with the organization, but securing his services required a substantial commitment—a three-year, $22.5 million extension carrying a $7.5 million average annual value. With the clarity of hindsight, it is reasonable to surmise that Colorado would have preferred to retain Nazem Kadri, whose departure has proven difficult to reconcile.

Amid a relatively subdued offseason, the Avalanche may be signaling a strategic pivot—favoring patience and deliberate team-building over a hasty, high-risk pursuit of immediate championship glory.

Ultimately, however, the burden of expectation remains firmly on Colorado’s shoulders. The time to perform is now.