Former Dallas Cowboys first-round NFL draft pick Mazi Smith is bordering on the label of bust, and he continued his struggles with consistency throughout the 2025 preseason.
Because of his lack of consistency, Smith did not see the field in the team’s Week 1 loss to the Super Bowl champion Philadelphia Eagles after being listed as inactive. It was the first time in his NFL career that Smith was inactive.
Cowboys head coach Brian Schottenheimer has continued to say Smith’s biggest issue is his up-and-down performances.
MORE: Dallas Cowboys share final injury report for Week 2 vs Giants
Unfortunately for Smith, those concerns still hang over his head, and he is again expected to miss the team’s game in Week 2 against the New York Giants as a healthy scratch.
Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Mazi Smith and Detroit Lions center Frank Ragnow battle during the second quarter / Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images
“In Mazi’s case, Mazi’s a good player,” Schottenheimer said. “The flashes are there. It’s just the consistency has to be there more often. Just because you’re inactive this week doesn’t mean you’re going to inactive this week. It just means you were inactive Week 1.
MORE: Russell Wilson’s history vs. Cowboys could strike fear into hearts of Dallas fans
“They have a big role in trying to get that changed. At the end of the day, we do a great job I believe of trying to communicate to these guys on game day or the night before in this case, because of the noon start, of what the plan is. But things change in a hurry.”
If Smith wants to return to the field, he will need to prove to the coaches that he is ready to return to the field and produce. After all, one of Schottenheimer’s biggest areas of focus has been “competition every day,” and you need that concistency to always come out on top.
Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Mazi Smith after the game against the San Francisco 49ers at Levi’s Stadium. / Kyle Terada-Imagn Images
— Enjoy free coverage of the Cowboys from Dallas Cowboys on SI —
Dallas Cowboys vs New York Giants, NFL Week 2 expert predictions
Jerry Jones looks to reclaim ‘Gambler’ title with Cowboys’ Micah Parsons trade
Russell Wilson’s history vs. Cowboys could strike fear into hearts of Dallas fans
Cowboys’ pass rush could shine vs depleted Giants offensive line in Week 2
Cowboys’ standout UDFA to be elevated from practice squad for Week 2
PHOTOS: Meet Kleine Powell, star of Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader Netflix doc