While plaintiffs characterized their move as a win, the case was headed toward a skeptical appeals court.

kAm%96 4@FCE 7:=:?8 %F6D52J ?@E65 E92E E96 7656C2= @77:46CD =65 3J D6?:@C &]$] q@C56C !2EC@= @77:4:2= k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2A?6HD]4@>^2CE:4=6^:>>:8C2E:@?\4C24@?E9 7@C }@CE9 r2C@=:?2[ 3FE DA@C25:4 :>>:8C2E:@? 2CC6DED 92G6 4@?E:?F65 3J @E96C 7656C2= 286?ED]k^Am

kAm“(6 H@? @FC 42D6 E96 52J E96J =67E E@H?[” s2G:5 q] ~H6?D[ 2? 2EE@C?6J C6AC6D6?E:?8 E96 A=2:?E:77D[ D2:5 😕 2 DE2E6>6?E] “%96 A6@A=6 @7 r9:428@ DE@@5 FA E@ E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@?’D 3F==J:?8 2?5 :?E:>:52E:@?[ 2?5 D9@H65 E96> E96J H6C6 >6DD:?8 H:E9 E96 HC@?8 4:EJ]”k^Am

kAm%96 2EE@C?6JD 2=D@ ?@E65 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2A?6HD]4@>^2CE:4=6^49:428@\:46\3@C56C\A2EC@=\:>>:8C2E:@?\g_6c2g4ghgd_agg6aa454_3e3gh5a4fhQm3=:DE6C:?8 aab\A286 @A:?:@?k^2m 3J &]$] s:DEC:4E yF586 $2C2 t==:D =2DE >@?E9 E92E @FE=:?65 96C 7:?5:?8D 😕 :DDF:?8 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2A?6HD]4@>^2CE:4=6^49:428@\:==:?@:D\:>>:8C2E:@?\:46\3@C56C\A2EC@=\f33f5_d4h_3hf_aae_fbgdf5hfcaf4h6QmAC6=:>:?2CJ :?;F?4E:@?k^2m C6DEC:4E:?8 7656C2= 286?ED’ FD6 @7 7@C46]k^Am

kAm%96 72E6 @7 E96 @C56C H2D FA 😕 E96 2:C 27E6C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2A?6HD]4@>^2CE:4=6^:>>:8C2E:@?\49:428@\2CC6DED\7@C46\e5b7e_fcc`ed3b7b67d4b`_fbcdde42`Qm2? 2AA62=D 4@FCEk^2m =2DE >@?E9 566>65 :E “@G6C3C@25” 2?5 “E@@ AC6D4C:AE:G6]” qFE E96 fE9 &]$] r:C4F:E r@FCE @7 pAA62=D 2=D@ 42FE:@?65 282:?DE “@G6CC625:?8” :ED DE2J @7 t==:DV :?;F?4E:@? 2?5 D2:5 2 BF:4@C6 E2:=@C65 2?5 2AAC@AC:2E6” @C56C] pC8F>6?ED 367@C6 E96 E9C66\;F586 A2?6= H6C6 D6E 7@C =2E6C E9:D >@?E9]k^Am

kAmpEE@C?6JD 5:5 ?@E :>>65:2E6=J C6DA@?5 %F6D52J E@ 7@==@H\FA BF6DE:@?D 23@FE E96:C 564:D:@? E@ 5C@A E96 =2HDF:E]k^Am

kAm%96 :?;F?4E:@? H2D 😕 C6DA@?D6 E@ 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2A?6HD]4@>^2CE:4=6^49:428@\:46\:>>:8C2E:@?\3C@25G:6H\=2HDF:E\c5h3`c2a65g6ag5f2c3fd6ca355f42g2Qm=2HDF:Ek^2m 7:=65 3J ?6HD @FE=6ED 2?5 AC@E6DE6CD H9@ 4=2:>65 7656C2= @77:46CD FD65 6I46DD:G6 7@C46 5FC:?8 2? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2A?6HD]4@>^2CE:4=6^49:428@\:>>:8C2E:@?\AC@E6DE\2CC6DED\286?E\A@=:46\H9:DE=6D\57fa3a32c6df3674_gd5eha5aafbeb3gQm:>>:8C2E:@? 4C24@C6 E92? b[___ 2CC6DED D:?46 $6AE6>36C 24C@DD E96 ?2E:@?’D E9:C5\=2C86DE 4:EJ 2?5 :ED >2?J DF3FC3D] p>@?8 @E96C E9:?8D[ t==:D’ @C56C C6DEC:4E65 286?ED 7C@> FD:?8 A9JD:42= 7@C46 2?5 496>:42= 286?ED DF49 2D E62C 82D 2?5 A6AA6C 32==D[ F?=6DD ?646DD2CJ @C E@ AC6G6?E 2? “2? :>>65:2E6 E9C62E]” $96 D2:5 E96 4FCC6?E AC24E:46D G:@=2E65 E96 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= C:89ED @7 ;@FC?2=:DED 2?5 AC@E6DE6CD]k^Am

kAm“q642FD6 @7 E96 H@C2?J r9:428@2?D[ :?4=F5:?8 E96 3C2G6 A=2:?E:77D 😕 E9:D 42D6[ E96 3CFE2=:EJ @7 ~A6C2E:@? |:5H2J q=:EK H2D 42C67F==J 5@4F>6?E65 7@C 2== E@ D66[ E96 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= C:89ED @7 4:G:=:2?D 24C@DD E96 C68:@? H6C6 G:?5:42E65[ 2?5 E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@?’D ;FDE:7:42E:@?D 7@C :ED 4@?5F4E H6C6 6IA@D65 2D 3=2E2?E =:6D[” D2:5 2EE@C?6J $E6G6 pCE] “yF586 t==:D’D A@H6C7F= @A:?:@? DE2?5D 2D E96 7:?2= H@C5 😕 E9:D 42D6[ 2?5 2D 2 567:?:?8 5@4F>6?E @7 @FC E:>6]”k^Am

kAmp >6DD286 =67E %F6D52J 7@C E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 w@>6=2?5 $64FC:EJ H2D ?@E :>>65:2E6=J C6EFC?65] %96 56A2CE>6?E @G6CD66D 3@E9 E96 &]$ q@C56C !2EC@= 2?5 &]$] x>>:8C2E:@? 2?5 rFDE@>D t?7@C46>6?E]k^Am

kAmsw$ 92D 5676?565 :ED @A6C2E:@? 😕 r9:428@[ D2J:?8 286?ED H6C6 8@:?8 27E6C 4C:>:?2=D 2?5 72465 9@DE:=6 4C@H5D]k^Am

kAm%96 42D6 2=D@ AC64:A:E2E65 2 EC@G6 @7 ?6H 56E2:=D 23@FE E96 :>>:8C2E:@? @A6C2E:@? 😕 E96 r9:428@ 2C62[ :?4=F5:?8 E9C@F89 AC:G2E6 :?E6CG:6HD H:E9 q@G:?@[ 3@5J 42>6C2 7@@E286 2?5 H:E?6DD E6DE:>@?:6D 😕 4@FCE] t==:D 4:E65 6249 @7 E96D6 😕 96C @A:?:@?[ 56D4C:3:?8 286?ED =2F?49:?8 E62C 82D H:E9@FE H2C?:?8[ 2:>:?8 CF336C C@F?5D 2E C6A@CE6CD[ E24 2 56>@?DEC2E@C’D 62C — D46?6D E92E t==:D D2JD H6C6 7=2E=J 2E @55D H:E9 E96 8@G6C?>6?E’D @H? ?2CC2E:G6D]k^Am

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.