Some of New York City’s best gems to visit are just a few steps away from the more well-known tourist attractions. Take the Met as a prime example — it’s one of the most famous museums in the world, but if you walk just a few blocks farther north, there’s a whole other assembly of memorable and underrated museums without the Met’s crowds. That area, stretching across four avenues and between 86th and 96th streets, is Carnegie Hill. It’s a historic district sitting on a gently inclined hill (a feature otherwise quite uncommon in Manhattan), full of gorgeous mansions and elegant townhouses that you could walk around and admire for hours.
Carnegie Hill was called “the cultural heart of the Upper East Side” by CityNeighborhoods.NYC for its mix of cultural institutions, civic history, and architectural legacy. The neighborhood gets its name from the industrialist Andrew Carnegie, who built his 64-room Georgian mansion here on 91st Street in 1902. Before Carnegie’s arrival, the area was a much more modest residential community, and, as CityNeighborhoods.NYC explains, it was Carnegie who inspired an influx of wealthy residents and more mansions built around his own.
Despite its expansion into a trove of museums and lavish homes, Carnegie Hill is far from the bustling streets more emblematic of other areas along Fifth Avenue and downtown. One local summed it up perfectly on Reddit: “It’s quiet and away from all the action. It’s cleaner. The proximity to the park and museums keeps me sane.” If you want to skip the tourist traps of Times Square for something calmer and more authentic, Carnegie Hill is well worth the detour.
Museums and mansions in Carnegie Hill
You might start a tour of Carnegie Hill at the site that lends it its name: the (former) Carnegie Mansion. According to American Aristocracy, the sprawling estate has over 56,300 square feet of living space and ranks among the top 100 biggest houses in the U.S. Today, the mansion is a museum, the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum. Its collection includes over 200,000 design objects, all laid out across the mansion’s grand interior, and you can get a guided tour focused on the mansion’s history on Tuesdays and Fridays. Alternatively, you can do a self-guided tour with the price of admission. (Tip: Admission is pay-what-you-wish from 5 to 6 p.m. daily).
Walking along the residential blocks outside of Carnegie Hill, you’ll find yourself on tree-lined streets full of historic townhouses (many dating to the late 1800s) and distinctly neoclassical mansions. In fact, directly across from the Carnegie Mansion is the James Burden Mansion, designed in 1901 by the same architects responsible for Grand Central Station. It’s a private venue but a beauty to behold from outside, nonetheless.
At the southern edge of Carnegie Hill is the famed Guggenheim Museum. Even if you don’t go inside, it’s a building worth admiring for the sake of its architectural legacy, being one of Frank Lloyd Wright’s most iconic designs. On 92nd Street is the Jewish Museum, a highlight among NYC’s underrated museums. Housed in another mansion, it showcases rotating art exhibitions related to the Jewish experience.
Tips for visiting Carnegie Hill
If there’s one caveat to visiting Carnegie Hill, it’s that it’s somewhat out of the way, at least for visitors more familiar with Midtown and Lower Manhattan. Still, it’s hardly the outskirts, and you can reach the neighborhood in under 20 minutes by subway from Grand Central Station. Take the 4, 5, or 6 train to the 86th Street station, and you’ll be at the southern border of Carnegie Hill — or go one stop farther, to 96th Street, if you want to be closer to the northern landmarks like the Jewish Museum and Hunter College campus.
When it’s time for a bite, Carnegie Hill has plenty of well-rated restaurants across a range of tastes. A more laid-back option, open for breakfast through dinner, is Bocado, with a solid 4.3 star-average on Google reviews. It doubles as a wine bar, too, so you could just stop by for a glass. Those seeking out fine dining will find options as well. One of the top-rated fine dining restaurants for Carnegie Hill on Tripadvisor is an Italian gem called Sfoglia. It’s open for dinners with a decadent menu of signature items like a chicken al mattone and tagliatelle with shrimp and labne. After a meal, you could unwind and digest with a walk around Central Park, which borders the neighborhood to the west — the quieter, northern half of Central Park is an excellent destination to spot a plethora of America’s bird species.
Ready to discover more hidden gems and expert travel tips? Subscribe to our free newsletter and add us as a preferred search source for access to the world’s best-kept travel secrets.
Read the original article on Islands.