The first person Tavel Bristol-Joseph called was his mother.
Deborah Bristol is the woman who brought him from Guyana to Brooklyn. The woman who watched him play basketball, then told him he’d better try culinary school. The woman who nodded proudly as he grew from 6-foot-5 at age 17 into a top Texas pastry chef at 45.
When his mom heard that her son’s original concept, Nicosi Dessert Bar, had earned a Michelin star, she went berserk.
“She was yelling and screaming on the phone,” Bristol-Joseph said. “She was telling me how proud she was of me. How amazing this is.”
Bristol-Joseph thought Michelin stars went to chefs in white coats and tall hats from big kitchens in New York City and Chicago. He works in a tiny space — 800 square feet — in Pullman Market. He toils in a city that’s never won a James Beard award. Until Oct. 28, San Antonio had earned only one Michelin star. To hear Nicosi’s name called at the Michelin Guide Awards transcended a dream.
“It was mind-blowing,” he said.
The pastry chef blows both minds and taste buds. He is an original, a culinary force whose artistry defies convention. Who else in San Antonio blends sweet, acidic, umami and bitter elements into an eight-course dessert experience?
Bristol-Joseph serves art on a plate with drizzle and crunch. He creates such visually arresting confections they all but seem more suited for admiring than tasting.
“The genius of Tavel is that he creates not only thinking about what a dessert will taste like, he creates thinking about how you will feel when eating that dessert,” said Jorge Hernández, corporate chef for innovation, research and development at Emmer & Rye Hospitality Group. “For him, making it taste good is the easy part. Making the connection is the art.”
The citrus buñuelo at Nicosi Dessert Bar in San Antonio, Texas. Credit: Amber Esparza / San Antonio Report
The venue is small, the decor dark, the rules stunning: No photography is allowed and payment is required in advance — $120, which includes the full dessert tasting menu with either alcohol or non-alcoholic pairings.
Nicosi is culinary theater. Two performers in a kitchen surrounded by 20 guests seated in suspense. Surprise: There’s not a single menu. The no-photography policy heightens the mystery.
What do patrons get? Eruptions of foam and color. Dessert and drink trailing with smoke to R&B, funk and indie music. A show from two artists, Bristol-Joseph and Jorge Hernández, creating sweet magic by sleight of hand.
Business is brisk. Nicosi was reaching twice-a-night capacity at 5:30 p.m. and 8 p.m. Thursday through Saturday. But after the Michelin star, Nicosi filled virtually every night it was open, Wednesday through Sunday.
“I would say business has been about 15 to 20 percent better,” Bristol-Joseph said. “It’s great.”
Nicosi is the pastry chef’s middle name. The dessert bar is an elevated vision of the space Bristol-Joseph imagined in his youth. Almost 30 years ago, Bristol-Joseph visited Room 4 Dessert, a groundbreaking, dessert-only restaurant in New York City. He took a seat, absorbed the aroma, design and menu, and ordered two items.
“If I ever get a chance,” he thought to himself, “I want to own something like this.”
The dream formed in the mid-’90s. Room 4 Dessert closed in 2007. Nicosi opened 17 years later, the journey from Brooklyn to Pullman Market yielding surprise after surprise.
Each course at Nicosi is specifically matched with a non-alcoholic beverage or an optional wine and cocktail pairing. Credit: Amber Esparza / San Antonio Report
From athlete to artist
Bristol-Joseph did not come to this career by design. He came to it by default. What else was he going to do?
After finishing high school, Bristol-Joseph moved from Georgetown, Guyana to New York City with aspirations of playing college basketball. Wanting to see if her son could hoop, Deborah Bristol went to a local park.
“I was so nervous that she was watching me play that I had the worst game,” Bristol-Joseph recalled. “People were blocking me. I was missing simple shots. So I sit down next to her and say, ‘What do you think?’ She’s like, ‘I think you got to go to culinary school.’”
Deborah enrolled her son at since-closed New York Restaurant School. He worked as a pastry cook intern at The River Cafe, a once Michelin-starred restaurant, where a chef advised him to check out Room 4 Dessert. The visit didn’t only inspire a career as a culinary artist. It inspired a dessert-only venue.
“I liked sweets,” said Bristol-Joseph, who learned to bake tarts and cheese rolls with his aunt for church in Guyana. “But I didn’t know if I wanted to be a pastry chef.”
Years passed. The vision changed to fit reality. He considered an ice cream shop, a cheesecake spot. He became a pastry and sous chef at a Times Square hotel, then took a job in Tucson, where he met Kevin Fink, who would found Emmer & Rye and be named one of Food & Wine’s Best New Chefs.
In Southern Arizona, Bristol-Joseph and Fink worked for a restaurant group. They formed a strong partnership — Fink as director of operations, Bristol-Joseph as corporate pastry chef — that lasted nearly a decade.
Chef Tavel Bristol-Joseph was a co-owner of the successful Emmer & Rye group before creating Nicosi. Credit: Amber Esparza / San Antonio Report
Fink moved to Austin a little more than a decade ago and asked Bristol-Joseph to help him launch Emmer & Rye. Before completing the concept, they ran out of money. To make ends meet, Bristol-Joseph became an Uber driver, sometimes working until 2:30 a.m.
When Emmer & Rye restaurant opened, Bristol-Joseph’s artistry blossomed. Success followed at Emmer & Rye Hospitality Group concepts Hestia, a live-fire restaurant, and Canje, a Caribbean eatery. Food & Wine named Bristol-Joseph a Best New Chef. Bon Appetit named Canje a Best New Restaurant. James Beard Award nominations for Best Chef: Texas followed in 2023 and 2024.
“I’m like, ‘cool,’” said the chef, co-owner of the Emmer & Rye group, “but I’m still not fulfilled.”
A chef can please customers and win awards, he explained, but still feel a void. He traced his emptiness to deep artistic desire: a longing to run a venue with creative confections.
The emptiness left last summer. Twenty seven years after drawing inspiration from Room 4 Dessert, Bristol-Joseph realized his aspiration. Emmer & Rye Hospitality launched Nicosi in June. Within months, Esquire named Bristol-Joseph and former Nicosi colleague, Karla Espinosa, Pastry Chefs of the Year. The magazine called the dessert experience “a blast.”
The cozy setting is designed to foster dialogue between patron and chef. Eliminating photography, menus and checks allows conversation to flow without distraction.
Chef de Parties Delissa Ramos, left, and Ana Morena behind the counter at Nicosi Dessert Bar at Pearl. Credit: Amber Esparza / San Antonio Report
“You talk to a PR person and that’s restaurant suicide,” Bristol-Joseph said. “They’re like, ‘Wait, what? We can’t get photos?’ No. Because I want people to walk into this space and have no option but to be present.”
Art at the chef’s table is to be viewed, appreciated and tasted. It is memorable but ephemeral. The menu changes every three months. The space, however, remains sacred, so intimate the artist can touch his audience. Like a long-ago dream.
Except better.