NORRISTOWN — A former Abington Township man who targeted his onetime neighbors for a gunpoint home invasion robbery during which he used packing tape and a dog leash to restrain a woman and her adult son was convicted of robbery and related charges by a jury.
Jonathan David Dell, 25, most recently of the 1700 block of North 16th Street in Philadelphia, showed no emotion as a Montgomery County jury convicted him of charges of robbery, conspiracy, burglary, simple assault, terroristic threats, access device fraud and carrying a firearm without a license in connection with the Dec. 2, 2024, home invasion at a home in the 200 block of Cedar Road in the Elkins Park section of Abington.
The jury of six men and six women deliberated about 5½ hours before reaching the verdict after hearing testimony at a three-day trial.
Jonathan Dell is escorted by a deputy sheriff from a Montgomery County courtroom after a jury convicted him of carrying out a home invasion robbery in Abington. (Photo by Carl Hessler Jr. – MediaNews Group)
Dell potentially faces decades in prison on the charges.
Judge William R. Carpenter deferred sentencing so that court officials can complete a background investigation report about Dell, who will remain in jail without bail while awaiting that sentencing hearing.
“I think the jury took a hard look at the evidence and ultimately came to the correct conclusion,” Assistant District Attorney Kathleen Alane McLaughlin reacted to the verdict.
“Not only did the defendant break into somebody’s home and take away their sense of security, but the individuals who were in the home that day were actually people that he knew from when he was growing up,” McLaughlin added. “The fact that he would choose them to commit such a heinous home invasion and tie them up, every step of this just shows how callous this was and the lack of care that he had.”
Testimony revealed Dell grew up in the Abington area, knew the family, had attended middle school with the male victim and had been an invited guest in the home when he was a teenager.
A second man, Jalen Douglas-Smith, 19, also of Philadelphia, previously pleaded guilty to robbery, conspiracy and gun related charges and is awaiting sentencing.
Douglas-Smith testified against Dell, pointing to Dell as the person who came up with the plot. Douglas-Smith said he had never met the victims.
“He told me he knew the people who lived there. He grew up with them,” Douglas-Smith told the jury, adding Dell told him they could get “cash” at the home. “I was following Jonathan’s lead.”
Jalen Douglas-Smith is escorted by sheriff’s deputies from a Montogmery County courtroom after he testified against his co-conspirator charged in Abington gunpoint home invasion. (Photo by Carl Hessler Jr. – MediaNews Group)
Douglas-Smith, who faces a possible maximum sentence of 53½ to 107 years in prison on the charges, didn’t hide from the jury that his hope is that his testimony against Dell, which he maintained was truthful, would result in the judge giving him a lesser sentence.
McLaughlin suggested Dell recruited Douglas-Smith to assist with the home invasion robbery.
“(Dell) was the one who knew this family. (Dell) was the one who had been in this home before. The testimony showed that (Dell) was the one who was in control,” McLaughlin said.
But defense lawyer Prince Yakubu argued there was reasonable doubt in the case and that prosecutors did not present sufficient evidence to prove that Dell was in the home. Yakubu, who handled the case with co-defense lawyer Danielle Malafu, argued there was no DNA or fingerprint evidence presented by prosecutors to link Dell to the crime and that the investigation was lacking.
“What I was trying to impress upon the jury is that they don’t have enough to say what the government is trying to say happened, which means you must acquit,” Yakubu said.
Jonathan Dell is escorted by a deputy sheriff from a Montgomery County jury convicted him of charges he participated in gunpoint home invasion in Abington. (Photo by Carl Hessler Jr. – MediaNews Group)
Testimony revealed a woman and her adult son were home at the time two men, covering their faces with masks and brandishing guns, invaded the home. Both victims testified they feared for their lives.
“We just kept asking for our lives,” the son testified. “My mom was frantically saying, ‘Don’t shoot, don’t shoot, he’s my son.’ I tried to do the best I could to give them what they wanted so they didn’t kill us. I was fearing for my life, just trying to do what I was told.”
The investigation began about 3:15 p.m. Dec. 2 when Abington police responded to a report of a robbery occurring at the Cedar Road residence. A woman told police that when she arrived home in her 2021 Subaru Ascent she was approached by two males on her driveway who forced her into her home.
“Both males followed her inside and demanded cash and other valuables from (the victim),” Abington Detective Robert Hill Jr. wrote in the arrest affidavit.
The woman’s son, who was in an upstairs bedroom, heard his mother crying and went downstairs to check on her when he “was threatened by the males with bodily harm” as they demanded cash and valuables, detectives said.
“The male suspects remained inside of their home for approximately one hour as they walked into various areas of the home with both victims. The males ransacked each room and took cash and other valuables. During the time the males were inside of the home they continued to point handguns at both victims and threatened both victims with harm if they did not cooperate or called the police,” Hill alleged.
The males took the victims’ cellphones and then used packing tape and a dog leash to tie up the victims before the intruders left the house, according to trial testimony.
The males took the keys to the woman’s Subaru vehicle and fled the area in that vehicle.
The victims were able to free themselves and ran to a nearby church to call the police. The victims reported jewelry, electronics, cash and sports memorabilia, valued at more than $2,000, were stolen from the home.
Detectives used a GPS tracker on the stolen vehicle as it traveled into Philadelphia and it was eventually found unoccupied in a parking lot in the 4300 block of North Broad Street. Security video from a nearby store depicted two males park the vehicle and walk away carrying a large bag of items, according to the criminal complaint.
The victims reported that unauthorized transactions were made with their stolen debit cards and Venmo app at locations in Philadelphia, including at a grocery mart.
Detectives retrieved video surveillance footage from the grocery mart that assisted them in identifying Douglas-Smith and Dell as suspects. Jurors also viewed images from video surveillance that depicted the two men walking in the Abington neighborhood toward the victims’ home around the time of the robbery.
Dell also posted a video to his Instagram social media account on Dec. 3 that showed him wearing a watch that was stolen from the Abington home.
During the investigation, detectives also determined that a fingerprint recovered from the passenger door of the victim’s stolen Subaru belonged to Douglas-Smith.
“The police work was top notch in this investigation. It was excellent work all-around,” said McLaughlin, adding the video surveillance evidence gathered by detectives corroborated Douglas-Smith’s testimony and linked Dell to the crime.