For two hours on national television, seven candidates running for California governor wasted little time attacking one another on Tuesday night as they looked for memorable ways to differentiate themselves in the final weeks of the campaign.<\/p>\n
The debate at East Los Angeles College in Monterey Park, Calif., aired on CNN just as California began a month of early voting for the June 2 primary election. The race still has a large field of prominent candidates and has no clear favorite.<\/p>\n
All of them are running to succeed Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat who cannot run for re-election because of term limits.<\/p>\n
The two Republicans were Steve Hilton, a former Fox News host, and Chad Bianco, the Riverside County sheriff, each of whom seemed intent on criticizing Democrats but showed little interest in attacking one another.<\/p>\n
The top-polling Democrats in the debate included Xavier Becerra, a former California attorney general and cabinet secretary under President Joseph R. Biden Jr.; and Tom Steyer, a former hedge fund manager.<\/p>\n
Among the other Democrats were Katie Porter, a former congresswoman; Matt Mahan, the mayor of San Jose; and Antonio Villaraigosa, a former mayor of Los Angeles.<\/p>\n
In California\u2019s nonpartisan primary, candidates from all parties run on the same ballot, and the two who receive the most votes advance to the November election.<\/p>\n
Here are five takeaways from the debate:<\/p>\n
Becerra took fire from all sides.<\/p>\n
After languishing in the polls for months, Mr. Becerra has climbed toward the top of the pack ever since Eric Swalwell dropped out of the race<\/a>.<\/p>\n Democrats and Republicans alike tried to knock him down Tuesday.<\/p>\n Mr. Hilton and Mr. Villaraigosa questioned Mr. Becerra\u2019s role in a criminal case involving two of his top aides, with Mr. Hilton saying that his opponent was \u201cmired personally in a corruption scandal.\u201d<\/p>\n The accusation stems from a federal indictment<\/a> in which Sean McCluskie, Mr. Becerra\u2019s former chief of staff, pleaded guilty to a corruption scheme that involved skimming $225,000 from one of Mr. Becerra\u2019s campaign accounts. Dana Williamson, who ran Mr. Becerra\u2019s campaigns for attorney general, pleaded not guilty; court records suggest that she is in negotiations for a plea agreement.<\/p>\n Mr. Becerra said that he had no knowledge of the alleged crimes and no role in the case that rocked the State Capitol<\/a>. He has not been accused of any crimes.<\/p>\n \u201cIf I had been involved, the U.S. attorney would have had me in that indictment,\u201d he said. \u201cI was not involved.\u201d<\/p>\n Mr. Mahan went after Mr. Becerra over his record as health and human services secretary in the Biden administration, saying \u201cPresident Biden openly talked about firing him, had to sideline him during Covid because he wasn\u2019t delivering results.\u201d<\/p>\n And Mr. Steyer finally took a dig at Mr. Becerra onstage after holding back in past debates, accusing Mr. Becerra of \u201cbeing in bed with oil companies.\u201d<\/p>\n Mr. Becerra shot back by criticizing the investments Mr. Steyer made in fossil fuels<\/a> through the hedge fund he used to run: \u201cTom, the last thing we need is someone who makes riches from investing in oil companies and then accuses everyone else of doing the wrong thing.\u201d<\/p>\n Democrats don\u2019t like the billionaire tax as much as you think.<\/p>\n It might have seemed counterintuitive, but some of the most progressive Democratic candidates pointed out flaws in a billionaire tax initiative that is expected to qualify<\/a> for the November ballot.<\/p>\n Ms. Porter, asked to explain why she opposes the proposal, said it was \u201csimply not good tax policy.\u201d<\/p>\n Then she counted the ways: It would only tax billionaires once, but the state has ongoing needs for revenue; it would only tax billionaires, but \u201chalf billionaires\u201d should pay more, too; and 90 percent of revenues would go toward health care, leaving out other programs.<\/p>\n Mr. Steyer said he would vote for the tax if it appears on the November ballot because he believes \u201cbillionaires like me should pay more taxes.\u201d But he also said he thinks the proposal is flawed.<\/p>\n \u201cIt doesn\u2019t go to education and teachers and students, which is a critical need in the state of California,\u201d Mr. Steyer said.<\/p>\n Mr. Villaraigosa, a more moderate Democrat, chimed in that the state already relies too heavily on tax revenue from the wealthiest residents.<\/p>\n \u201cThat\u2019s why you have feast and famine virtually every year,\u201d he said.<\/p>\n Porter tried to turn her weaknesses into selling points.<\/p>\n \u201cBoys, boys,\u201d Ms. Porter interjected as the six men on either side of her argued with, and over, one another. \u201cEnough with the bickering.\u201d<\/p>\n Ms. Porter built her reputation as a minivan-driving single mother with a whiteboard \u2014 someone whose simple, concise criticisms of big corporations and inequality got her elected in a purple congressional district in Southern California.<\/p>\n But her campaign for governor seemed to have been derailed last year by two videos<\/a> that went viral: One in which she belittled a television reporter, and another in which she berated an aide for being in the background of her video shot.<\/p>\n On Tuesday night, Ms. Porter, the only prominent woman in the race, took that campaign vulnerability head-on, emphasizing her decorum in the debates and asserting that she is better suited for the governor\u2019s office than her male rivals. She said she apologized for mistreating her aide while her opponents had been unable to own up to their mistakes.<\/p>\n \u201c<\/strong>Californians can decide for themselves about my temperament based on what they\u2019ve seen here tonight,\u201d she said. \u201cAnd if these bullies, these boys bullying and bickering, hasn\u2019t been enough to raise questions about their temperament, I would really challenge that.\u201d<\/p>\n The attacks got more personal.<\/p>\n As candidates tried to make an impression on voters, their attacks on one another got more pointed. <\/p>\n At one point during an exchange about immigration enforcement, Mr. Villaraigosa called Mr. Bianco \u201ca bully,\u201d adding that he is \u201can Oath Keeper \u2014 we all know that.\u201d Mr. Bianco, the sheriff, was once a member of the Oath Keepers<\/a>, a far-right militia group.<\/p>\n Mr. Bianco said he was proud to keep his oaths and suggested that viewers read the group\u2019s mission statement, before saying that he was no longer a member<\/a>.<\/p>\n Mr. Villaraigosa also asked Mr. Hilton, \u201cHow can you say that Democrats have it wrong when you can\u2019t admit that Donald Trump lost the 2020 election?\u201d Mr. Hilton did not address that question and pivoted to blaming Democrats for high gas prices in California.<\/p>\n When Mr. Steyer talked about corporations and wealthy Californians paying their fair share of taxes, Mr. Becerra quipped about how much of his wealth was parked overseas, untaxed.<\/p>\n \u201cTom, one of these days, let us know how much money you have in the Cayman Islands, so we can make sure we tax you,\u201d Mr. Becerra said. Mr. Steyer has denied having money overseas, but his 2024 tax filings<\/a> show extensive foreign holdings, including in the Cayman Islands.<\/p>\n After Mr. Mahan repeatedly cited his work as mayor of San Jose, Mr. Becerra fired back at Mr. Mahan about the size of his jurisdiction.<\/p>\n \u201cMatt, here\u2019s the thing,\u201d Mr. Becerra said. \u201cI\u2019ve been able to balance budgets much larger than your city, San Jose.\u201d<\/p>\n A single-payer discussion tested Becerra.<\/p>\n One of the CNN moderators, Elex Michaelson, said that Mr. Becerra appeared to have changed his position on single-payer health care<\/a> in recent weeks and asked if he would push to create such a system as governor.<\/p>\n Mr. Becerra didn\u2019t give a straight answer.<\/p>\n Instead, he said he has consistently favored a \u201cMedicare for all\u201d approach and touted his work in Congress and as health and human services secretary to make health insurance available to more Americans through the Affordable Care Act.<\/p>\n Ms. Porter saw an opening. She pressed him on the difference between offering insurance to more people through existing plans and the creation of a single-payer system in which everyone is covered by a government-run insurance program.<\/p>\n \u201cCovering everyone with something is not single-payer,\u201d Ms. Porter said.<\/p>\n Mr. Becerra argued that the name of the insurance didn\u2019t matter, as long as people could see a doctor when needed. But he had given a muddled answer on an issue that has become a litmus test for many progressives.<\/p>\n Both Mr. Villaraigosa and Mr. Mahan jumped in to say that the discussion was pointless and suggested that their opponents were posturing because the state would never have enough money to pay for single-payer health care.<\/p>\n The conversation echoed debates from the 2018 governor\u2019s race, when Mr. Newsom supported single-payer in the primary, and Mr. Villaraigosa accused him of selling \u201csnake oil\u201d<\/a> to voters.<\/p>\n